Published February 12, 2021 | Version Final
Journal article Open

Are field boundary hedgerows the earliest example of a nature-based solution?

  • 1. Trinity College Dublin

Description

The arrival of the phrase nature-based solutions into the lexicon of academics, planners, managers and policymakers in recent years has sparked a heated debate as to the effectiveness of using nature as a viable solution for mitigating the impacts of anthropogenic environmental change. One of the difficulties of evaluating the potential efficacy and impact of nature-based solutions is that it is believed that there is little evidence by way of a precedent or long-term successful examples. Much literature exists on the subject of designing with nature to provide multi-functional green infrastructure, connectivity in the landscape, and ecosystem service provision. Indeed, in the opinion of many, the nature-based solution approach appears to synergise research into green infrastructure, ecological connectivity and ecosystem service provision for building climate-related resilience. However, when a nature-based solution has been specifically selected over, say, an engineered solution the literature is rather less clear. So, decision-makers may find it necessary to rely on less reliable sources of impact evidence. This paper argues that field boundary hedgerows may be considered to be exemplars of a nature-based solution, one that was planned, designed, perfected and mainstreamed at a landscape scale, that was specifically selected over a non-nature-based solution, and one that is still in providing solutions and co-benefits today. Therefore, hedgerows may provide some perspective into the potential or emergent co-benefits that the current nature-based solution approach seeks to provide.

Notes

Suggested citation: M. J. Collier (2021) Are field boundary hedgerows the earliest example of a nature-based solution? Environmental Science & Policy 120, 73-80. DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2021.02.008

Files

Collier 2021.pdf

Files (800.9 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:d216c74a8e3188ed6c8146be090a11ac
800.9 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Funding

CONNECTING Nature – COproductioN with NaturE for City Transitioning, INnovation and Governance 730222
European Commission
RENATURE – promoting Research Excellence in NAture-based soluTions for innovation, sUstainable economic GRowth and human wEll-being in Malta 809988
European Commission
GO GREEN ROUTES – GO GREEN: Resilient Optimal Urban natural, Technological and Environmental Solutions 869764
European Commission