Published November 24, 2021 | Version v1
Journal article Open

Сrown divorce: the case of Europraxia (Adelgeide) Vsevolodivna

  • 1. PhD. in Historical Sciences, docent of the Department of World History and International Relations of Educational and Scientific Institute of History and Social Studies (National University «Chernihiv Colehium») (Chernihiv, Myru Avenue, 13, 14006)
  • 2. Ph.D. in Historical Sciences (Chernihiv)

Description

The purpose of the article is to analyze the reasons, circumstances and the process of divorce of Eupraxia (Adelheid) Vsevolodivna, to identify the forms and methods of her opposition to the established medieval marriage traditions. The methodological basis of the work is the method of «case study». The scientific novelty is the clarification of certain facts of the biography of Eupraxia Vsevolodivna, her psychological portrait, which allowed to understand better the reasons and circumstances of her divorce, as well as the impact of this event on the further reign of the Holy Roman Emperor Henry IV. Conclusions. In the process of the analysis of sources and the latest historiography, a number of clarifications were made about the circumstances and peculiarities of the divorce of Eupraxia Vsevolodivna, known in the Catholic tradition as Adelheid, or Praxedis, the wife of the Holy Roman Emperor Henry IV. It is established that the concept «divorce» in relation to medieval Europe, and in particular the Holy Roman Empire of the XI century, had a significantly different content from the modern one and consisted of the following trajectories: divorce could take either the form of annulment or separation (living without the possibility of re-marriage to another person). An analysis of the divorce process of the imperial spouses Henry IV and Adelheid suggests that the divorce was initiated by the wife under the influence of the set of circumstances, both personal and political. However, the personal factor was decisive – the circumstances of marriage without parental blessing, abuse and open violence from the husband, the death of a newborn son, the uncertainty of her imperial status, devotion to the canons of the Christian church and unwillingness to support the husband in his confrontation with the legitimate popes. The divorce, approved by the church council and Pope Urban II personally, took form of the separation (divortium a mensa et thoro). The severance of relations accelerated the deconstruction of Henrys sacred status as an emperor, but did not become decisive in his conflict with the church, as Henry had previously been twice excommunicated from the Church. Educated on traditional Christian values, Eupraxia gained personal freedom and the opportunity to return to her homeland, which became an example of an unprecedented opposition of a woman to the established medieval marriage traditions.

Files

Files (118.0 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:b483b02ee6ebae0e463c27d53d94671c
118.0 kB Download

Additional details

References

  • Creber, A. (2019). Breaking Up Is Hard To Do: Dissolving Royal and Noble Marriages in Eleventh-Century Germany. German History. 2019. Vol. 37. Is. 2. Pp. 149–171. Oxford University Press, United Kingdom.
  • Ignatieva, Е.Е. (2018). Italyanskiy pohod Genriha IV (1081−1084 гг.) v kontekste borbyi za investituru [The Italian Campaign of Henry IV (1081–1084) in the Context of the Investiture Controversy]. Novoe Proshloe – The New Past. 2018. № 2. Rostov-na-Donu, Russia.
  • Kozlov, A.S. (2008). Sudba knyazhnyi Evpraksii Vsevolodovnyi v rabote nemetskogo issledovatelya. Rets. na st.: Rüß H. Eupraxia-Adelheid: Eine biographische Annäherung Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas. 2006. Bd. 54, h. 4. S. 481–518 [The Fate of Princess Eupraxia Vsevolodovna in the Work of a German Researcher. Review of the Article: Rüß H. Eupraxia-Adelheid: Eine biographische Annäherung Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas. 2006. Bd. 54, h. 4. S. 481–518]. Izvestiya Uralskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser. 2, Gumanitarnyie nauki – Humanitarian sciences. 2008. № 59. Vyp. 16. Ekaterinburg, Russia.
  • Lesak, B, Homaiko, N, Chernenko, O. (2020) Pechati knyagini Marinyi [Princess Marina's stamps]. «Na odno kryilo serebryanaya, na drugoe – zolotaya». Sbornik statey pamyati S. Ryabtsevoy / pod red. R. Rabinovicha i N. Telnova. Kishenev: Biblioteka Stratum Plus, 2020. Kishinev, Moldova.
  • McLaughlin, М. (2011). "Disgusting Acts of Shamelessness": Sexual Misconduct and the Deconstruction of Royal Authority in the Eleventh Century. Early Medieval Europe. 19. (2011). John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
  • Miles, M.F. (2006). The Value of a Woman: A Comparison of the Laws and the Traditions of Divorce in Medieval Europe and Modern America. UCLA Women's Law Journal. 15(1). Los Angeles, California, USA.
  • Nazarenko, A.V. (2001). Drevnyaya Rus na mezhdunarodnyih putyah: Mezhdistsiplinarnyie ocherki kulturnyih, torgovyih, politicheskih svyazey ІХ–ХІІ vv. [Old Rus on International routes: Interdisciplinary Esseys on Cultural, Trade, Political Contacts of the ІХ–ХІІth centuries]. Moscow, Russia.
  • Nazarko, I. (2000). Trahichna dolia kniazhny Yevpraksii Vsevolodivny (1071–1109) [The Tragic Fate of Princess Evpraksia Vsevolodivna]. Khronika 2000 – Chonicle 2000. № 35–36. Kyiv, Ukraine.
  • Pushkareva, N.L. (2012). Chastnaya zhizn v Drevney Rusi i Moskovii. Nevesta, zhena, lyubovnitsa [Private Life in Old Rus and Moscowy: Bride, Wife, Mistress]. Moscow, Russia.
  • Raffensperger, С. (2003). Evpraksia Vsevolodovna between East and West. Russian History – Histoire Russe, 30, Nos 1–2. Chicago, USA.
  • Raffensperger, С. (2012). The Missing Russian Women: The Case of Evpraksia Vsevolodovna. Writing Medieval Women's Lives / ed. Goldy, Livingstone, USA.
  • Robinson, I.S. (2003) Henry IV of Germany, 1056–1106. Cambridge, United Kingdom.
  • Ryuss, H. (2010). Evpraksiya – Adelgeyda: biograficheskiy etyud [Eupraxia – Adelheida: biographical essey]. Sankt-Peterburg, Russia.
  • Vershinina, U.E. (2020). Prezentatsiya institutov rodstva i otnosheniy mezhdu rodstvennikami v istoricheskih narrativah rannego srednevekovya. (Dissertatsiya kand. ist. nauk) [Presentation of kinship institutions and relations between relatives in historical narratives of the early Middle Ages. (Ph.D. thesis)]. Nizhniy Novgorod, Russia.
  • Ward, J.C. (2002). Women in Medieval Europe, 1200–1500. London, United Kingdom.