Violation of Standards and Manipulation in Headlines of Ukrainian Media Materials About Mobilisation
Authors/Creators
- 1. Vasyl Stefanyk Precarpathian National University, Ukraine
Description
The article examines the problem of standards violation in the headlines of Ukrainian media publications on the topic of mobilisation. The article analyses the news of all-Ukrainian and Precarpathian publications about the same event. This refers to the news of 20 June 2023, in which the media presented false information with the standards violation of accuracy, reliability and completeness that the men from the Precarpathian region would be denied hospitalisation.
The author analysed 17 such publications. As a result, she identified violations of the accuracy standards, reliability and completeness of information in the headlines. Only three of the analysed publications turned out to be factual.
The issue of adherence to standards in journalistic materials has always been and will always be relevant. Especially at a time of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, which is accompanied by an escalation of information warfare and intensification of hostile information and psychological special operations. The credibility of the Ukrainian media depends primarily on how objectively and in compliance with all standards the news will be presented. This, in turn, helps to build society’s resistance to hostile propaganda. Conversely, disregard for standards in the news leads to public opinion shifting and becomes good fodder for the hostile information attacks creation.
The article focuses on the fact that 60 to 80 percent of people read only headlines and draw conclusions about events based on them. Therefore, when we talk about such a serious topic as mobilisation, the headlines of publications should be as accurate as possible so as not to cause unnecessary disturbance to society.
Neglecting the verification of information and the search for primary sources, completeness and reliability of information, in the pursuit of clickbait, the Ukrainian media may unconsciously play along with the enemy, feeding its propaganda narratives and information and psychological special operations. Such an attitude to professional duties becomes especially dangerous when it comes to the issue of mobilisation, which is already being heavily debated in society.
Other
Files
Violation_of_Standards_and_Manipulation_in_Headlines_of_Ukrainian_Media_Materials_About_Mobilisation.pdf
Files
(808.7 kB)
| Name | Size | Download all |
|---|---|---|
|
md5:7ff42ea791274ced4d7dd9133a8dadcb
|
808.7 kB | Preview Download |
Additional details
References
- Abramova, Yu. (2023, June 20). Advokat prokomentuvav zaboronu hospitalizatsii cholovikiv bez vidoma viiskkomativ v Ivano-Frankivskii oblasti [The lawyer commented on the prohibition of hospitalization of men without the knowledge of military commissars in the Ivano-Frankivsk region]. TSN. https://tsn.ua/ukrayina/advokat-prokomentuvav-zaboronu-gospitalizaciyi-cholovikiv-bez-vidoma-viyskkomativ-u-ivano-frankivskiy-oblasti-2354251.html [in Ukrainian].
- Andrieieva, V. (2022, December 6). MOZ rekomenduie pryzupynyty planovi operatsii cherez ymovirnist blekautu [The Ministry of Health recommends suspending scheduled operations due to the possibility of a blackout]. Ukrainska pravda. https://life.pravda.com.ua/health/2022/12/6/251700/ [in Ukrainian].
- Boiko, M. (2023, June 20). V Ivano-Frankivskii oblasti zaboronyly hospitalizatsiiu cholovikiv bez vidoma viiskkomativ [In the Ivano-Frankivsk region, hospitalization of men without the knowledge of military commissars was prohibited]. TSN. https://tsn.ua/ukrayina/v-ivano-frankivskiy-oblasti-zaboronili-gospitalizaciyu-cholovikiv-bez-vidoma-viyskkomativ-2354191.html [in Ukrainian].
- Bratiuk, Yu. (2023, June 20). Na Prykarpatti cholovikam bez dozvolu vid TTsK vidmovliatymut u hospitalizatsii [In Prykarpattia, men will be refused hospitalization without permission from the TCC]. Zaxid.net. https://zaxid.net/na_ivano_frankivshhini_ne_gospitalizovuvatimut_cholovikiv_bez_dozvolu_viyskkomativ_n1565915 [in Ukrainian].
- Chernovol, K. (2023, June 20). Na Ivano-Frankivshchyni viiskovozoboviazanykh ne hospitalizuvatymut bez dozvolu viiskkomatu [In Ivano-Frankivsk region, conscripts will not be hospitalized without the permission of the Military Commissariat]. UNIAN. https://www.unian.ua/society/na-ivano-frankivshchini-viyskovozobovyazanih-ne-gospitalizuvatimut-bez-dozvolu-viyskkomatu-12301062.html [in Ukrainian].
- Commission on Journalism Ethics. (2023, April 28). Rekomendatsii KZhE pro nalezhne vysvitlennia temy mobilizatsii v Ukraini [Recommendations of the CJEU on proper coverage of the topic of mobilization in Ukraine.] https://is.gd/rB87zS [in Ukrainian].
- Denkovych, Ya. (2023, July 23). Vruchennia povistky na vulytsi ta prymusove dostavlennia do TTsK – advokat poiasnyv, yak diiaty [Delivery of a summons on the street and forced delivery to the TCC – the lawyer explained how to act]. TSN. https://tsn.ua/ato/vruchennya-povistki-na-vulici-ta-primusove-dostavlennya-do-tck-advokat-poyasniv-yak-diyati-2358295.html [in Ukrainian].
- Holovchak, Kh. (2023, September 24). Advokat rozpoviv, do yakykh khytroshchiv vdaiutsia pratsivnyky TTsK pid chas vruchennia povistky [The lawyer told what tricks TCC employees resort to when serving a summons]. TSN. https://tsn.ua/ato/advokat-rozpoviv-do-yakih-hitroschiv-vdayutsya-pracivniki-tck-pri-vruchenni-povistki-2415703.html [in Ukrainian].
- Ivano-Frankivsk Regional State Administration. (2023, June 22). Vitalii Ilchyshyn: Pidstav dlia prypynennia planovykh hospitalizatsii viiskovoboviazanykh nemaie [Vitaly Ilchyshyn: There are no grounds for stopping scheduled hospitalizations of conscripts]. https://www.if.gov.ua/news/vitalii-ilchyshyn-pidstav-dlia-prypynennia-planovykh-hospitalizatsii-viiskovoboviazanykh-nemaie [in Ukrainian].
- Kurs. (2023, June 20). Za rishenniam rady oborony oblasti, viiskovozoboviazanykh ne budut klasty na planove likuvannia bez pohodzhennia z viiskkomatamy, a u vypadku nevidkladnoi [According to the decision of the regional defense council, conscripts will not be placed on planned treatment without approval from the military commissariats, and in case of emergency] [Post]. Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/share/woZNhuae96cTtgKA/?mibextid=WC7FNe [in Ukrainian].
- Kushpit, A. (2023, June 20). Na Ivano-Frankivshchyni cholovikiv ne hospitalizuvatymut do likaren bez dozvolu viiskkomativ [In Ivano-Frankivsk region, men will not be admitted to hospitals without the permission of the military commissariat]. 24 Kanal. https://health.24tv.ua/gospitalizatsiya-cholovikiv-ivano-frankivsku-oblasti-shho-vidomo_n2338450 [in Ukrainian].
- Kuznetsova, O., & Korol, T. (2020). Chynnyky psykholohichnoho vplyvu zaholovkiv lvivskykh hazet "Vysokyi zamok", "Ekspres", "Ratusha [Factors of Psychological Influence Headlines of Newspapers "Vysokyy Zamok", "Ekspres", "Ratusha"]. Bulletin of Lviv Polytechnic National University. Series: Journalistic sciences, 4, 53–62. https://doi.org/10.23939/sjs2020.01.053 [in Ukrainian].
- Malenko, H. (2023, April 13). Media ta viina: Pro vidpovidalnist zhurnalistiv i spikeriv za zdorovia suspilstva [Media and war: About the responsibility of journalists and speakers for public health]. Detektor media. https://detector.media/blogs/article/210073/2023-04-13-media-ta-viyna-pro-vidpovidalnist-zhurnalistiv-i-spikeriv-za-zdorovya-suspilstva/ [in Ukrainian].
- Mostova, N. (2023, June 20). Na Frankivshchyni cholovikam bez dozvolu viiskkomatu vidmovliatymut u hospitalizatsii [In the Frankiv region, men will be refused hospitalization without the permission of the Military Commissariat]. Halytskyi korespondent. https://gk-press.if.ua/na-frankivshhyni-cholovikam-bez-dozvolu-vijskkomatu-vidmovlyatymut-u-gospitalizatsiyi/ [in Ukrainian].
- Myhal, M. (2023, June 20). Na Prykarpatti likarni nadavatymut dopomohu cholovikam lyshe z dozvolu viiskkomativ [In Prykarpattia, hospitals will provide assistance to men only with the permission of the military commissars]. Hlavkom. https://glavcom.ua/country/incidents/na-ivano-frankivshchini-medichni-ustanovi-nadavatimut-dopomohu-cholovikam-z-dozvolu-vijskkomativ-935914.html [in Ukrainian].
- Na Prykarpatti prypyniaiut planovi hospitalizatsii viiskovozoboviazanykh bez dozvolu viiskkomativ [Planned hospitalization of conscripts without the permission of the military commissariat is stopped in Prykarpattia]. (2023, June 20). Ukrainian National News. https://unn.ua/news/na-prikarpatti-pripinyayut-planovi-gospitalizatsiyi-viyskovozobovyazanikh-bez-dozvolu-viyskkomativ [in Ukrainian].
- Na Prykarpatti pryzupyniat planovu hospitalizatsiiu viiskovozoboviazanykh bez zghody TTsK: Poiasnennia [Planned hospitalization of conscripts will be suspended in Prykarpattia without the consent of the TCC: Explanation]. (2023, June 19). Informator. https://if.informator.ua/2023/06/19/na-prykarpatti-pryzupynyat-planovu-gospitalizacziyu-vijskovozobovyazanyh-bez-zgody-tczk-poyasnennya/ [in Ukrainian].
- Nalyvaiko, A. (2023). Tendentsii porushennia profesiinykh standartiv u suchasnii ukrainskii zhurnalistytsi [Trends in violation of professional standards in contemporary Ukrainian journalism]. Ukrainian Information Space, 1(11), 90–106. https://doi.org/10.31866/2616-7948.1(11).2023.279587 [in Ukrainian].
- Nepravda: 13 chervnia v Ivano-Frankivskii oblasti zaboronyly shpytalizuvaty viiskovozoboviazanykh bez zghody TTsK ta SP [ False: On June 13, in the Ivano-Frankivsk region, it was forbidden to hospitalize conscripts without the consent of the TCC and SP]. (2023, June 27). Vox Ukraine. https://voxukraine.org/nepravda-13-chervnya-v-ivano-frankivskij-oblasti-zaboronyly-shpytalizuvaty-vijskovozobov-yazanyh-bez-zgody-ttsk-ta-sp [in Ukrainian].
- Syvakivskyi, Ya. (2019). Zhurnalistski standarty v umovakh viiny: Pozytsiia hromadianyna chy obiektyvnyi profesionalizm) [Journalistic standard sin warfare: Citizen's position versus objective professionalism]. Visnyk of the Lviv University. Series Journalism, 45, 84–89. http://dx.doi.org/10.30970/vjo.2019.45.9988 [in Ukrainian].
- Tymchasovo: Na Prykarpatti TTsK zaboronyv likarniam hospitalizovuvaty pryzovnykiv bez pohodzhennia [Temporarily: In Prykarpattia, the Central Committee forbade hospitals to hospitalize conscripts without consent]. (2023, June 21). Firtka. https://firtka.if.ua/blog/view/timchasovo-na-prikarpatti-ttsk-zaboroniv-likarniam-gospitalizovuvati-prizovnikiv-bez-pogodzhennia-video [in Ukrainian].
- Tymoshyk, M. (2022). Standarty zhurnalistyky: Poniattia, geneza, zmist, praktyka [Journalism standards: Concept, genesis, content, practice]. Ukrainian Information Space, 1(9), 30–56. https://doi.org/10.31866/2616-7948.1(9).2022.257058 [in Ukrainian].
- U likarniakh Prykarpattia planovi hospitalizatsii viiskovozoboviazanykh provodytymut za pohodzhenniam z TTsK [In the hospitals of Prykarpattia, planned hospitalizations of conscripts will be carried out in agreement with the TCC]. (2023, June 20). Kurs. https://is.gd/Zp8EmD [in Ukrainian].
- V Ivano-Frankivsku TTsK zaboronyla likarniam hospitalizuvaty pryzovnykiv bez pohodzhennia [In Ivano-Frankivsk, the Central Committee forbade hospitals to hospitalize conscripts without consent]. (2023, June 20). Fokus. https://focus.ua/uk/voennye-novosti/573871-v-ivano-frankivsku-likarnyam-zaboronili-gospitalizuvati-prizovnikiv-video [in Ukrainian].
- V Ukraini zaboronyly vsi planovi operatsii [All scheduled operations have been banned in Ukraine]. (2020, November 9). Rivne Vechirnie. https://rivnepost.rv.ua/news/v-ukraini-zaboronili-vsi-planovi-operatsii#google_vignette [in Ukrainian].
- Viiskovozoboviazani prykarpattsi ne zmozhut liahty do likarni bez pohodzhennia z TTsK – rada oborony [Conscripts of the Carpathians will not be able to go to the hospital without the approval of the TCC – the Defense Council]. (2023, June 20). Blitz-Info. https://www.blitz.if.ua/news/viyskovozobovyazani-prikarpattsi-ne-zmozhut-lyagti-do-likarni-bez-pogodzhennya-z-ttsk-rada-oboroni [in Ukrainian].
- Vynohradova, U. (2023, June 20). V Ivano-Frankivskii oblasti zaboronyly planovo hospitalizovuvaty viiskovozoboviazanykh bez dozvolu viiskkomatu [ In the Ivano-Frankivsk region, it was forbidden to hospitalize conscripts without the permission of the Military Commissariat]. Oboz.ua. https://news.obozrevatel.com/ukr/society/v-ivano-frankivskij-oblasti-zaboronili-planovo-gospitalizuvati-vijskovozobovyazanih-bez-dozvolu-vijskkomatu.htm [in Ukrainian].
- Yatskevych, M. (2020, November 9). V Ukraini zaboronyly usi planovi operatsii ta hospitalizatsii [In Ukraine, all planned operations and hospitalizations were banned]. Suspilne. https://suspilne.media/78305-v-ukraini-zaboronili-usi-planovi-operacii-ta-gospitalizacii/ [in Ukrainian].
- Yermolaieva, V. (Host). (2022, February 17). Yak pravylo, za sensatsiinymy zaholovkamy nemaie novyn – Diana Dutsyk [As a rule, there is no news behind the sensational headlines – Diana Dutsyk] [Audio podcast episode]. In Detoks [Detox]. Hromadske radio. https://hromadske.radio/podcasts/detoks/yak-pravylo-za-sensatsiynymy-zaholovkamy-nemaie-novyn-diana-dutsyk [in Ukrainian].
- Zakharchenko, O. (2017, April 7). Standarty zhurnalistyky: osnovy profesiinosti chy zastarili ramky? [Journalism standards: the basics of professionalism or outdated frameworks?]. Instytut masovoi informatsii. https://imi.org.ua/articles/standarti-jurnalistiki-osnovi-profesiynosti-chi-zastarili-ramki-i178 [in Ukrainian].