Data from: Temperature has an overriding role compared to photoperiod in regulating the seasonal timing of winter moth egg hatching
- 1. Nederlands Instituut voor Ecologie
Description
To accurately predict species' phenology under climate change, we need to gain a detailed mechanistic understanding of how different environmental cues interact to produce the seasonal timing response. In the winter moth (Operophtera brumata), seasonal timing of egg hatching is strongly affected by ambient temperature and has been under strong climate change-induced selection over the past 25 years. However, it is unclear whether photoperiod received at the egg stage also influences timing of egg hatching. Here, we investigated the relative contribution of photoperiod and temperature in regulating winter moth egg development using two split-brood experiments. We experimentally shifted the photoperiod eggs received by 2-4 weeks compared to the actual calendar date and measured the timing of egg hatching, both at a constant temperature and in combination with two naturally changing temperature treatments – mimicking a cold and a warm year. We found an eight-fold larger effect of temperature compared to photoperiod on egg development time. Moreover, the very small photoperiod effects we found were outweighed by both between- and within-clutch variation in egg development time. Thus, we conclude that photoperiod received at the egg stage does likely not play a substantial role in regulating the seasonal timing of egg hatching in the winter moth. These insights into the regulatory mechanism of seasonal timing could have important implications for predicting insect climate change adaptation, as we might expect different targets of selection depending on the relative contribution of different environmental cues.
Methods
We investigated whether photoperiod received at the egg stage influences the seasonal timing of egg hatching in the winter moth, both as a cue on its own and in interaction with temperature. In two split-brood experiments, we determined egg hatching date after giving eggs either an early or late season photoperiod treatment, with naturally changing day lengths shifted 2-4 weeks earlier or later compared to the actual calendar date. Temperature was kept constant in the first experiment, while the second experiment also incorporated two naturally changing temperature treatments – mimicking a cold and a warm year – to investigate the relative contribution of temperature and photoperiod.
Eggs were collected from wild females (31 clutches and 20 clutches, for experiment 1 and 2 respectively), with each clutch of eggs split into sub-clutches and divided over the different photoperiod and photoperiod-temperature treatments. Raw egg hatching data (i.e. 2-3 observations per week of the number of freshly hatched caterpillars per sub-clutch) have been processed by calculating the median hatching date per sub-clutch (D50, i.e. the day at which 50% of the sub-clutch has hatched). D50 data were used for the statistical analyses and have been deposited here, together with the raw temperature logger data from the experiment.
Files
db_EggPhot2014_boxes.csv
Files
(25.0 MB)
Name | Size | Download all |
---|---|---|
md5:f77ffce9769ebca4e403ab45423bb04a
|
884 Bytes | Preview Download |
md5:5bf5620ef65476ea8d2e1f7400e46ea8
|
28.6 kB | Preview Download |
md5:d3e1fb0248637c0af084fc6206cb9786
|
6.6 MB | Preview Download |
md5:9ca1cbc3b6729181ad324aff549cc2e3
|
6.7 MB | Preview Download |
md5:ffe6059b0df950fc5a1baac5ca8a0a27
|
6.7 MB | Preview Download |
md5:b773f50d45191af672172e1309777f88
|
3.8 kB | Preview Download |
md5:6c5fd3f77e77f23c4a0c4ef2089e0115
|
4.8 MB | Preview Download |
md5:cb5b897dea9925f935fe1259ecd934bf
|
96.8 kB | Download |
md5:5539951312b778e8d3d1a7cc44c571f5
|
5.7 kB | Preview Download |
md5:4a8fe50fa23082433dcf6852eae05ef5
|
6.7 kB | Preview Download |
md5:7654844ad97f7f8c394911e51ef47fcf
|
6.7 kB | Preview Download |
Additional details
Related works
- Is derived from
- https://github.com/NEvanDis/WM_photoperiod (URL)
- 10.5281/zenodo.10204003 (DOI)