Published October 18, 2023 | Version v1
Dataset Open

Iporangaia – Body condition affecting mating success and parenting behavior

  • 1. University of California, Santa Cruz
  • 2. University of Sao Paulo
  • 3. ScienceYourself*

Description

Female mate choice is usually based on traits that signal male quality as a sexual partner. According to the 'good parent hypothesis', female mate choice may also consider male quality as a caregiver in species with male-only care. Because parental activities may be costly, males in good condition should be more attractive to females than those in poor condition. We experimentally manipulated the body condition of parental and non-parental males of the egg-tending harvestman Iporangaia pustulosa and then evaluated how it affected their mating success and ability to protect eggs under field conditions. For non-parental males, individuals in good condition had twice the probability of mating than those in poor condition. For parental males, individuals in good condition had two times more chances of mating and acquired four times more eggs than those in poor condition. Surprisingly, males' body condition had no effect on the efficiency of egg protection. Thus, our results indicate that the male condition is a sexually selected trait, but we found no support for the 'good parent hypothesis' given that an increase in body condition does not improve the survival of the offspring under male care. Instead, these findings are congruent with predictions of the 'essential male care' model, which suggests that, when the costs of parental care are low (as is the case of egg attendance), most males can provide the minimum necessary care for offspring survival. However, only males in good condition can allocate surplus energy to advertise their overall quality and attract more mates.

Other

Funding provided by: Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo
Crossref Funder Registry ID: http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100001807
Award Number:

Methods

General description of the experiments

We performed two experiments in which we manipulated the body condition of both non-parental and parental I. pustulosa males, subsequently recording their mating success and number of acquired eggs under natural field conditions. Upon collecting males from the field, we transported them to the laboratory, where they were individually marked with enamel ink. This procedure does not appear to influence the behavior of the individuals (e.g., Requena et al. 2009, 2012; Requena & Machado 2015). Given that harvestmen have very low basal metabolism (Santos 2007), their body condition declines slowly under resting conditions. To accelerate this process, we experimentally forced all males to decline their body condition through a series of physical exercises (i.e., forced walking) in the laboratory. Only after the forced exercise, when we were able to decline the body condition of all males, we assigned them to one of two experimental groups: (a) 'good condition' group, in which males received water and food ad libitum, and (b) 'poor condition' group, in which males received water ad libitum but no food. We allowed males of the 'good condition' group to feed for one day, sufficient to induce significant food intake and, consequently, a marked increase in body condition (Fig. S1 in Supplementary Material). The criteria used to assign males to each of the two experimental groups are presented in Table S1 and Figs. S2-S4.

After the manipulation of body condition, we returned each male to the exact location of capture within our transects. During subsequent visits to the field, a team of four researchers actively surveyed the transects for three consecutive days. They searched for marked males during the afternoon (between 14:00 h and 18:00 h) and the night (between 20:00 h and 00:00 h). During each inspection visit, we recorded whether the recaptured males were successful or unsuccessful in acquiring eggs. To ensure that males were not tending to any clutches, upon encountering a marked male, we carefully searched the vegetation within a 2-meter radius around him. Given that males significantly reduce their movement while caring for eggs (Requena et al. 2012), this searching procedure allowed us to confirm whether a male was unsuccessful in acquiring eggs. For successful individuals, we took photographs of their broods to quantify the number of eggs acquired during the sampling interval, which spanned from one inspection visit to the next. 

Files

EXP1_allvisits.csv

Files (65.4 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:1b84bb721faf336ea36395b5c13d00f4
6.2 kB Preview Download
md5:1dcf8322ad348c91fe47305f941f27df
14.8 kB Preview Download
md5:777c8c54519156ba6d34fd53fef99a8f
783 Bytes Preview Download
md5:b2c3fac6e8a7543ec002bae14062c946
849 Bytes Preview Download
md5:a2cd586f4365a14b52478af77970cb27
225 Bytes Preview Download
md5:41c7a5f6eb46e3ffe3f06dcafe5b4f25
743 Bytes Preview Download
md5:ad974c429c255e72d3e10d23664006cb
737 Bytes Preview Download
md5:12d44a75c2e2f0afc0f4e5aaa6936c74
634 Bytes Preview Download
md5:10cc990287ec34f1016fe6cbcf67ca95
4.1 kB Preview Download
md5:d2052bcd93e505433fe6f7e31b7a89a7
7.4 kB Preview Download
md5:9eb972b8817cce591152540854228d8a
567 Bytes Preview Download
md5:e339f173d451a5cb271ac876a734df31
729 Bytes Preview Download
md5:98e7bb55cd5f256b2cd4ae23c412f8f4
1.4 kB Preview Download
md5:089161df712ab1f1f2eed472f7d6dd2c
238 Bytes Preview Download
md5:3c4fbca195189c9f928391c4d0a0b9fd
3.1 kB Preview Download
md5:5ae2d7cbec6b6f881d1eaca47a488ca0
1.5 kB Preview Download
md5:cbdaba613d962c90afaf8071cc5809a4
659 Bytes Preview Download
md5:f2e7ce0fa1a45a51738d79925ee88548
447 Bytes Preview Download
md5:6fb29ff3f8fdb8edab94ac64b68489bb
261 Bytes Preview Download
md5:70ffb0074ccf4cb093b5cb6b28e081ee
7.4 kB Preview Download
md5:ffcfeb2a18f2411d05d7cbbdd21d8964
6.4 kB Preview Download
md5:6fb09fada4acd351af680e5e5826c013
4.0 kB Preview Download
md5:de0c231c7343240f59ec0456cc1cc94d
2.3 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Related works

Is derived from
10.5281/zenodo.8403924 (DOI)