Planned intervention: On Thursday 19/09 between 05:30-06:30 (UTC), Zenodo will be unavailable because of a scheduled upgrade in our storage cluster.
Published October 6, 2023 | Version v1
Conference paper Open

ТЕРРИТОРИАЛЬНАЯ ЦЕЛОСТНОСТЬ И СЕЦЕССИЯ: КОНСТИТУЦИОННО-ПРАВОВОЕ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЕ

  • 1. Молдавский Государственный Университет

Description

Abstract: Secession is a historical phenomenon. This means that basically since the beginning of modernity, when states were formed and built, there have been political movements that have aimed to achieve secession from the political organization of which they are a part. It is therefore appropriate to use a broad concept, covering situations ranging from the first segregations in the old colonial powers in the 18th and 19th centuries to the dissolution of the former Yugoslavia at the end of the 20th decade. When states were attempted to be established based on former political formations, as in Ger-many or in Austria and Italy, self-determination was the result of an adapta-tion of the Kantian thesis of individual autonomy to a national or collective fact. In Europe, irredentism has always been associated with the principle of nationalities. In many cases, it is a random connection, because as we know, a nation is a human creation. But let’s leave that aside. It is important to note that today’s separatist demands may have ethnic or cultural overtones, but they are usually associated with the need to protect other interests, often of an economic nature. That is why it is so difficult, by traditional standards, to draw a common line between the situations in Scotland and Catalonia or the Faroe Islands and Greenland. In many respects because in the center of institutionalized Europe, after seeing how the principle of nationalities in-fluenced two world wars, a reasonable and satisfactory system of protection of national minorities was created. Territorial integrity has been central to peace and progress in Europe since the 1950s, and normative documents drawn up by the Council of Europe, the OSCE and the European Union itself have established normative guidelines of varying intensity to ensure adequate treatment of national minorities in domestic constitutional systems. This led to constitutionally guaranteed decisions on regional and federal autonomy, which made it possible to ensure the effective protection and development of national minorities in European nation-states. Currently, many of the pro-blems associated with secession as a manifestation of separatism have not been resolved. There are still heated debates in the international community and at the level of the constitutional courts of different countries regarding the legality and optimal mechanisms of secession, as well as regarding com-pliance with the principle of the territorial integrity of states, which is the reason for the relevance of the paper. The article analyzes the constitutional and legal content of the principle of territorial integrity, the mechanisms for determining the political status of sub-national territories, secession, and re-lated procedures in the constitutions of different countries, especially referen-da. Successful and unsuccessful practical secession attempts are examined.
 

Files

20_КОСТРОМИЦКИЙ Анатолий.pdf

Files (416.0 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:9e94c8a4862521753932b7c7beb77e08
416.0 kB Preview Download

Additional details

References

  • 1. Agreement between the United Kingdom Government and the Scottish Government on a referendum on independence for Scotland Edinbur-gh, 15 October 2012 [citat 02.03.2023]. Disponibil: https://assets.publi-shing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_ data/file/313612/scottish_referendum_agreement.pdf
  • 2. Ley 9/2008, de 27 de junio, de convocatoria y regulación de una consulta popular al objeto de recabar la opinión ciudadana en la Comunidad Autónoma del País Vasco sobre la apertura de un proceso de negociación para alcanzar la paz y la normalización política. Publicado en: «BOE» núm. 212, de 3 de septiembre de 2011. https://www.boe.es/eli/es-pv/l/2008/06/27/9.
  • 3. Sentencia del Tribunal constitucional español 103/2008, de 11 de septiembre (BOE núm. 245, de 10 de octubre de 2008) [citat 02.03.2023]. Disponibil: http://hj.tribunalconstitucional.es/es-ES/Resolu-cion/Show/6335#:~:text=La%20Ley%20se%20concibe%2C%20a,a%20 este%20propósito%20el%20art.
  • 4. Sentencia del Tribunal constitucional español 42/2014, de 25 de marzo (BOE núm. 87, de 10 de abril de 2014) [citat 02.03.2023]. Disponibil: http://hj.tribunalconstitucional.es/es/Resolucion/Show/23861
  • 5. Барабанов О. Н., Шибкова М. О. Евроскептицизм в Италии: эволюция политической программы «Лиги Севера» В: Вестник МГИМО -Университета, 2015, № 5. Стр. 99-107, ISSN: 2541-9099.
  • 6. Договор от 12 сентября 1990 г. об окончательном урегулировании в отношении Германии (договор «два плюс четыре») Vertrag vom 12. September 1990 über die abschließende Regelung in Bezug auf De-utschland (Zwei-plus-Vier-Vertrag) [citat 08.02.2023]. Disponibil: https://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/blob/243466/2851e102b97772a5772e9fdb 8a978663/vertragstextoriginal-data.pdf
  • 7. ЗАДОРОЖНЮК Э. Г. «Бархатный развод» Чешской и Словацкой федеративной республики (ЧСФР) в зеркале прессы распавшегося СССР. В: Славяне и Россия: славянские и балканские народы в периодической печати, 2014, 420 с. ISBN 978-5-7576-0310-0.
  • 8. Закон АТО Гагаузия Об отложенном статусе народа Гагаузии на внешнее самоопределение №33-Р Принят всенародным голосованием 02 февраля 2014 г. В: Официальном бюллетене Гагаузии «EKSPRES-KANON» № 2 (159) от 21 февраля 2014 года.
  • 9. Закон о референдуме о независимости Шотландии 2013 года, Scottish Independence Referendum Act 2013 [citat 02.03.2023]. Disponibil: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2013/14/contents
  • 10. Закон о самоуправлении Гренландии, [online]: Lov om Grønlands Selvstyre, LOV nr 473 af 12/06/2009 [citat 02.03.2023]. Disponibil: https://www.retsinformation.dk/eli/lta/2009/473
  • 11. Закон о самоуправлении Фарерских островов, Lov om Færøernes Hjemmestyre, LOV nr 137 af 23/03/1948 [citat 02.03.2023]. Disponibil: https://www.retsinformation.dk/eli/lta/1948/137
  • 12. Закон о Шотландии 1998 года, Scotland Act 1998 [citat 02.03.2023]. Disponibil: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/46/contents
  • 13. Закон об особом правовом статусе Гагаузии (Гагауз Ери) № 344 от 23.12.1994 года. В: Monitorul Oficial № 3-4 статья № 51, 14.01.1995 г.
  • 14. Конституции Австрии, Федеральный конституционный закон с последними изменениями от 25 июля 2012 г., (Вестник федеральных законов 65/2012) Verfassungen Österreichs [citat 11.02.2023]. Disponibil: https://verfassungen.at/indexheute.htm
  • 15. Конституционная Хартия государственного сообщества Сербии и Черногории. В: Официальный вестник Сербии и Черногории № 1 от 4 февраля 2003 года, [citat 05.03.2023]. Disponibil: https://www. osce.org/files/f/documents/7/e/35247.pdf
  • 16. Конституционный закон № 541 от 13 ноября 1992 г. о разделе имущества Чешской и Словацкой Федеративной Республики между Чешской Республикой и Словацкой Республикой и его передаче Чешской Республике и Словацкой Республике [citat 05.03.2023]. Disponibil: https://www.zakonyprolidi.cz/print/cs/1992-541/zneni-19921208.htm?sil=1
  • 17. Конституция Бельгии в редакции, обновленной после пересмотра Конституции 17 марта 2021 года (Бельгийский официальный вестник от 30 марта 2021 года), The Belgian Constitution [citat 08.02.2023]. Disponibil: https://www.dekamer.be/kvvcr/pdf_sections/publications/constitution/GrondwetUK.pdf