Conference paper Open Access

Mapping Topics in 100,000 Real-Life Moral Dilemmas

Nguyen, Tuan Dung; Lyall, Georgiana; Tran, Alasdair; Shin, Minjeong; Carroll, Nicholas George; Klein, Colin; Xie, Lexing

Abstract: Moral dilemmas play an important role in theorizing both about ethical norms and moral psychology. Yet thought experiments borrowed from the philosophical literature often lack the nuances and complexity of real life. We leverage 100,000 threads—the largest collection to date—from Reddit’s r/AmItheAsshole to examine the features of everyday moral dilemmas. Combining topic modeling with evaluation from both expert and crowd-sourced workers, we discover 47 fine-grained, meaningful topics and group them into five meta-categories. We show that most dilemmas combine at least two topics, such as family and money. We also observe that the pattern of topic co-occurrence carries interesting information about the structure of everyday moral concerns: for example, the generation of moral dilemmas from nominally neutral topics, and interaction effects in which final verdicts do not line up with the moral concerns in the original stories in any simple way. Our analysis demonstrates the utility of a fine-grained data-driven approach to online moral dilemmas, and provides a valuable resource for researchers aiming to explore the intersection of practical and theoretical ethics.

Visit https://github.com/joshnguyen99/moral_dilemma_topics for instructions on using this dataset.
Files (3.7 GB)
Name Size
bow_emb.pkl
md5:568581eb6f638c129f901ce9a6ffa7d6
54.6 MB Download
bow_vectorizer.pkl
md5:da427de47bea7c14c4feaf7a56c850e8
841.1 kB Download
clusters_info_with_topic.csv
md5:7917c402ff308d4938d33b32cd2754fe
24.1 MB Download
lda_bow_model.pkl
md5:50ddee49220870ba771a651f64ddd9c7
11.7 MB Download
nmf_tfidf_model.pkl
md5:77f6369b1099c880dd1dc7e4fc5577c7
2.9 MB Download
post_ids.pkl
md5:30b28332535a88128b64383bfcb14106
927.3 kB Download
reddit.gz
md5:4d417f329bc6a9315a7857ca3478cdb8
3.5 GB Download
tfidf_emb.pkl
md5:1d7532a472e9ca6a6dc6012186fce9bf
54.6 MB Download
tfidf_vectorizer.pkl
md5:391cda2b898f97d08f969b62f2e9dbfd
967.0 kB Download
  • Nguyen, T. D., Lyall, G., Tran, A., Shin, M., Carroll, N. G., Klein, C., & Xie, L. (2022). Mapping Topics in 100,000 Real-Life Moral Dilemmas. Proceedings of the International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media, 16(1), 699-710.

141
620
views
downloads
All versions This version
Views 141122
Downloads 620620
Data volume 23.7 GB23.7 GB
Unique views 115102
Unique downloads 515515

Share

Cite as