National Center for Water Quality Research (NCWQR)
Published February 15, 2015 | Version v1
Journal article Open

Implementing agricultural phosphorus science and management to combat eutrophication

Authors/Creators

  • 1. USDA-ARS Pasture Systems and Watershed Management Unit
  • 2. University of Arkansas
  • 3. Bangor University
  • 4. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences
  • 5. National Center for Water Quality Research
  • 6. Agri-food and Bioscience Institute

Description

ABSTRACT

Experience with implementing agricultural phosphorus (P) strategies highlights successes and uncertainty over outcomes. We examine case studies from the USA, UK, and Sweden under a gradient of voluntary, litigated, and regulatory settings. In the USA, voluntary strategies are complicated by competing objectives between soil conservation and dissolved P mitigation. In litigated watersheds, mandated manure export has not wrought dire consequences on poultry farms, but has adversely affected beef producers who fertilize pastures with manure. In the UK, regulatory and voluntary approaches are improving farmer awareness, but require a comprehensive consideration of P management options to achieve downstream reductions. In Sweden, widespread subsidies sometime hinder serious assessment of program effectiveness. In all cases, absence of local data can undermine recommendations from models and outside experts. Effective action requires iterative application of existing knowledge of P fate and transport, coupled with unabashed description and demonstration of tradeoffs to local stakeholders.

Files

Kleinman et al 2015 Ambio.pdf

Files (4.1 MB)

Name Size Download all
md5:898a538f834d11cf2ec29b4bfe90abf6
4.1 MB Preview Download

Additional details

References

  • Anon. 2003. Responsible Phosphorus Management on Grassland Farms. Report on a joint initiative by the Fertilisers Manufactures Association, Northern Ireland Agricultural Producer's Association, Ulster Farmers' Union and Department of Agriculture, Northern Ireland. Retrieved Nov. 19, 2014, from http:// eservices.ruralni.gov.uk.
  • Aronsson, H., G. Torstensson, and L. Bergström. 2007. Leaching and crop uptake of N, P and K from organic and conventional cropping systems on a clay soil. Soil Use and Management 23: 71–81.
  • Baker, D.B., and R.P. Richards. 2002. Phosphorus budgets and riverine phosphorus export in northwestern Ohio watersheds. Journal of Environmental Quality 31: 96–108.
  • Baker, D.B., R. Confesor, D.E. Ewing, L.T. Johnson, J.W. Kramer, and B.J. Merryfield. 2014. Phosphorus loading to Lake Erie from the Maumee, Sandusky and Cuyahoga rivers: The importance of bioavailability. Journal of Great Lakes Research 40: 502–517.
  • Bergfur, J., B.O. Demars, M.I. Stutter, S.J. Langan, and N. Friberg. 2012. The Tarland Catchment Initiative and its effect on stream water quality and macroinvertebrate indices. Journal of Environmental Quality 41: 314–321.
  • Boesch, D.R., R. Hechy, C. O'Melia, D. Schindler, and S. Seitzinger. 2006. Eutrophication of the Swedish Seas. Swedish Environmental Protection Agency. Report 5509, Stockholm.
  • Bowes, M.J., J.T. Smith, C. Neal, D.V. Leach, P.M. Scarlett, H.D. Wickham, S.A. Harman, L.K. Armstrong, et al. 2011. Changes in water quality of the River Frome (UK) from 1965 to 2009: Is phosphorus mitigation finally working? Science of the Total Environment 409: 3418–3430.
  • Bowes, M.J., H.P. Jarvie, P.S. Naden, G.H. Old, P.M. Scarlett, C. Roberts, L.K. Armstrong, S.A. Harman, et al. 2014. Identifying priorities for nutrient mitigation using river concentration–flow relationships: The Thames basin, UK. Journal of Hydrology 517: 1–12.
  • Brandt, M., H. Ejhed, and L. Rapp. 2009. Nutrient loads to the Swedish marine environment in 2006. Swedish Environmental Protection Agency. Report 5995, Stockholm. Retrieved Nov. 19, 2014, from http://www.naturvardsverket.se/Nerladdningssida/ ?fileType=pdf&downloadUrl=/Documents/publikationer/978-91 -620-5995-8.pdf.
  • Buda, A.R., P.J.A. Kleinman, R.B. Bryant, G.W. Feyereisen, D.A. Miller, P.G. Knight, and P.J. Drohan. 2013. Forecasting runoff from Pennsylvania landscapes. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 68: 185–198.
  • Chaffin, J.D., T.B. Bridgeman, S.A. Heckathorn, and S. Mishra. 2011. Assessment of Microcystis growth rate potential and nutrient status across a trophic gradient in western Lake Erie. Journal of Great Lakes Research 37: 92–100.
  • Cherry, K.A., M. Shepherd, P.J.A. Withers, and S.J. Mooney. 2008. Assessing the effectiveness of actions to mitigate nutrient loss from agriculture: A review of methods. Science of the Total Environment 406: 1–23.
  • Defra. 2010. The Fertiliser Manual (RB209). Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, TSO (The Stationary Office). Retrieved, Nov 19, 2014, from http://www.defra.gov.uk/ publications/2011/03/25/fertiliser-manual-rb209/.
  • Defra. 2013. Catchment based approach: Improving the quality of our water environment. London: Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs.
  • Defra. 2014. Phosphate Resources, Postnote No. 477. London: The Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology.
  • DeLaune, P.B., B.E. Haggard, T.C. Daniel, I. Chaubey, and M.J. Cochran. 2006. The Eucha/Spavinaw phosphorus index: A court mandated index for litter management. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 61: 96–105.
  • Dolan, D.M., and S.C. Chopra. 2012. Great Lakes total phosphorus revisited: Loading analysis and update (1994-2008). Journal Great Lakes Research 38: 730–740.
  • Doody, D.G., P.J.A. Withers, and R.M. Dils. 2014. Prioritizing waterbodies to balance agricultural production and environmental outcomes. Environmental Science and Technology 48: 7697–7699.
  • Doody, D.G., R.H. Foy, and C.D. Barry. 2012. Accounting for the role of uncertainty in declining water quality in an extensively farmed grassland catchment. Environmental Science & Policy 24: 15–23.
  • Dorioz, J.M., D. Wang, J. Poulenhard, and D. Trevisan. 2006. The effect of grass buffer strips on phosphorus dynamics: A critical review and synthesis as a basis for application in agricultural landscapes in France. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 117: 4–21.
  • EA. 2011. Catchment Sensitive Farming—ECSFDI Phase 1 & 2 Full Evaluation Report. London: Environment Agency. Retrieved, Nov 14, 2014, from http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/ourwork/ farming/csf/evaluation.aspx.
  • EA. 2013. Water for Life and Livelihoods. England's waters: Challenges and choices, 42 pp. Retrieved, Nov 14, 2014, from https://consult.environment-agency.gov.uk/portal/ho/wfd/water/ choices?pointId=s1359025359987.
  • EA. 2014. Progressing towards WFD objectives—The role of agriculture. April, 2014. London: Environment Agency.
  • Egan, D. 2014. Toxic algae cocktail brews in Lake Erie. Retrieved, Nov 10, 2014, from http://www.jsonline.com/news/wisconsin/ toxic-algae-cocktail-brews-in-lake-erie-b99344890z1-274542731. html.
  • Fölster, J., K. Kyllmar, M. Wallin, and S. Hellgren. 2012. Kväve- och fosforförluster i jordbruksvattendrag. Har åtgärderna get effect? Report 2012:1. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Dept. of Aquatic Sciences and Assessment (In Swedish with English summary).
  • Haggard, B.E. 2010. Phosphorus concentrations, loads, and sources within the Illinois River drainage area, northwest Arkansas, 1997–2008. Journal of Environmental Quality 39: 2113–2120. doi:10.2134/jeq2010.0049.
  • Heidelberg University. 2010. Phosphorus stratification in relation to agricultural production practices and the soil resource base in the Sandusky River Watershed. Great Lakes Protection Fund Report, Grant 833. Retrieved, Nov 19, 2014, from http://www.heidel berg.edu/sites/default/files/jfuller/images/5%20Mtg%203%2C% 20set%202%2C%20ag%20prod%20practices.pdf.
  • Henry, T. 2014. Ag group gives $1 M to reduce runoff Farm Bureau cites landowners' buy-in. Toledo, OH: Toledo Blade. Retrieved, Nov 17, 2014, from http://m.toledoblade.com/local/2014/09/13/ Ag-group-gives-1M-to-reduce-runoff.html.
  • Herron, S., A.N. Sharpley, S. Watkins, and M. Daniels. 2012. Poultry litter management in the Illinois River Watershed of Arkansas and Oklahoma. Cooperative Extension Service, Division of Agriculture, University of Arkansas. Fact Sheet FSA 9535. Retrieved, Nov 17, 2014, from http://www.uaex.edu/Other_ Areas/publications/PDF/FSA-9535.pdf).
  • International Fertilizer Association. 2009. The Global ''4R'' nutrient stewardship framework: Developing fertilizer best management practices for delivering economic, social and environmental benefits, 10 pp. Paris: International Fertilizer Industry Association (IFA). Retrieved, Nov 17, 2014, from http://www.ipni. net/ipniweb/portal.nsf/0/F14DC337AC2F848B85257A8C0054E 006/$FILE/The%20Global%204R%20Nutrient%20Stewardship %20Framework.pdf.
  • International Joint Commission. 2014. A Balanced Diet for Lake Erie: Reducing Phosphorus Loadings and Harmful Algal Blooms. Report of the Lake Erie Ecosystem Priority. Retrieved, Nov 17, 2014, from http://www.ijc.org/files/publications/2014%20IJC% 20LEEP%20REPORT.pdf.
  • International Plant Nutrition Institute. 2014. 4R Nutrient stewardship portal. Retrieved, from http://www.ipni.net/4R.
  • Jarvie, H.P., A.N. Sharpley, P.J.A. Withers, J.T. Scott, B.E. Haggard, and C. Neal. 2013. Phosphorus mitigation to control river eutrophication: Murky waters, inconvenient truths and 'postnormal' science. Journal of Environmental Quality 42: 295–304.
  • Joosse, P.J., and D.B. Baker. 2011. Context for re-evaluating agricultural source phosphorus loadings to the Great Lakes. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 91: 317–327.
  • Jordan, P., W. Menary, K. Daly, G. Kiely, G. Morgan, P. Byrnee, and R. Molese. 2005. Patterns and processes of phosphorus transfer from Irish grassland soils to rivers—Integration of laboratory and catchment studies. Journal of Hydrology 304: 20–34.
  • Jordan, P., A.R. Melland, P.-E. Mellander, G. Shortle, and D. Wall. 2012. The seasonality of phosphorus transfers from land to water: Implications for trophic impacts and policy evaluation. Science of the Total Environment 434: 101–109.
  • Kleinman, P.J.A., A.N. Sharpley, L.S. Saporito, A.R. Buda, and R.B. Bryant. 2009. Application of manure to no-till soils: Phosphorus losses by sub-surface and surface pathways. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 84: 215–227.
  • Kleinman, P.J.A., A.N. Sharpley, A.R. Buda, R.W. McDowell, and A.L. Allen. 2011. Soil controls of phosphorus in runoff: Management barriers and opportunities. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 91: 329–338.
  • King, K.W., M.R. Williams, M.L. Macrae, N.R. Fausey, J. Frankenberger, D.R. Smith, P.J.A. Kleinman, and L.C. Brown. 2014a. Phosphorus transport in agricultural subsurface drainage: A review. Journal of Environmental Quality. doi:10.2134/jeq2014. 04.0163.
  • King, K.W., M.R. Williams, and N.R. Fausey. 2014b. Contributions of systematic tile drainage to watershed-scale phosphorus transport. Journal of Environmental Quality. doi:10.2134/ jeq2014.04.0149.
  • Mallarino, A.P., J.M. Bordoli, and R. Borges. 1999. Effects of phosphorus and potassium placement on early growth and nutrient uptake of no-till corn and relationships with grain yield. Agronomy Journal 91: 37–45.
  • Mallarino, A.P., and R. Borges. 2005. Broadcast and deep band placement of phosphorus for soybeans managed with ridge tillage. Better Crops Plant Food 89: 8–11.
  • Mallarino, A.P., and R.A. Borges. 2006. Phosphorus and potassium distribution in soil following long-term deep-band fertilization in different tillage systems. Soil Science Society of America Journal 70: 702–707.
  • McGonigle, D.F., R.C. Harris, C. McCamphill, S. Kirk, R. Dils, J. Macdonald, and S. Bailey. 2012. Towards a more strategic approach to research to support catchment-based policy approaches to mitigate agricultural water pollution: A UK case-study. Environmental Science & Policy 24: 4–14.
  • Michalak, A.M., E.J. Anderson, D. Beletsky, S. Boland, N.S. Bosch, T.B. Bridgeman, J.D. Chaffin, K. Cho, et al. 2013. Record-setting algal bloom in Lake Erie caused by agricultural and meteorological trends consistent with expected future conditions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 110: 6448–6452.
  • Miller, C., A. Magdalina, R.I. Willows, A.W. Bowman, E.M. Scott, D. Lee, C. Burgess, L. Pope, et al. 2014. Spatiotemporal statistical modelling of long-term change in river nutrient concentrations in England & Wales. Science of the Total Environment 466–467: 914–923.
  • Ohio Lake Erie Task Force. 2013. Ohio Lake Erie Task Force II Final Report. Retrieved Nov. 19, 2014, from http://www.epa.ohio.gov/ portals/35/lakeerie/ptaskforce2/Task_Force_Report_October_2013. pdf.
  • Page, T., A.L. Heathwaite, B. Moss, C. Reynolds, K.J. Beven, L. Pope, and R. Willows. 2010. Managing the impacts of nutrient enrichment on river systems: dealing with complex uncertainties in risk analyses. Freshwater Biology 57: 108–123.
  • Preedy, N., K. McTiernan, R. Matthews, L. Heathwaite, and P. Haygarth. 2001. Rapid incidental phosphorus transfers from grassland. Journal of Environmental Quality 30: 2105–2112.
  • Radcliffe, D.E., D.K. Reid, K. Blombäck, C.H. Bolster, A.S. Collick, Z.M. Easton, W. Francesconi, D.R. Fuka, et al. 2014. Applicability of models to predict phosphorus losses in drained fields: A review. Journal of Environmental Quality. doi:10.2134/jeq2014. 05.0220.
  • Richards, P.R., D.B. Baker, and D.J. Eckert. 2002. Trends in agriculture in the LEASEQ watersheds, 1975–1995. Journal of Environmental Quality 31: 17–24.
  • Richards, P.R., D.B. Baker, J.P. Crumrine, J.W. Kramer, D.E. Ewing, and B.J. Merryfield. 2008. Thirty-year trends in suspended sediment in seven Lake Erie Tributaries. Journal of Environmental Quality 37: 1894–1908.
  • Richards, R.P., D.B. Baker, and J.P. Crumrine. 2009. Improved water quality in Ohio tributaries to Lake Erie: A consequence of conservation practices. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 64: 200–211.
  • Ryder, C., and C. Bennett. 2010. The River Basin Districts Typology, Standards and Groundwater Threshold Values (Water Framework Directive) (England and Wales) Directions 2010, 63 pp. London: Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.
  • Sharpley, A.N. 2003. Soil mixing to decrease surface stratification of phosphorus in manured soils. Journal of Environmental Quality 32: 1375–1384.
  • Sharpley, A.N., and S.J. Smith. 1994. Wheat tillage and water quality in the Southern Plains. Soil and Tillage Research 30: 33–38.
  • Sharpley, A.N., S. Herron, and T.C. Daniel. 2007. Overcoming the challenges of phosphorus-based management in poultry farming. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 62: 375–389.
  • Sharpley, A.N., R.P. Richards, S. Herron, and D.B. Baker. 2012. Can production and environmental goals coexist in phosphorus-based farm management? Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 67: 149–193.
  • Sharpley, A., H.P. Jarvie, A. Buda, L. May, B. Spears, and P. Kleinman. 2013. Phosphorus legacy: Overcoming the effects of past management practices to mitigate future water quality impairment. Journal of Environmental Quality 42: 1308– 1326.
  • Smith, D.R., K.W. King, L. Johnson, W. Francesconi, P. Richards, D. Baker, and A.N. Sharpley. 2014. Surface runoff and tile drainage transport of phosphorus in the midwestern United States. Journal of Environmental Quality. doi:10.2134/jeq2014.04.0176.
  • Stumpf, R.P., T.T. Wynne, D.B. Baker, and G.L. Fahnenstiel. 2012. Interannual variability of cyanobacterial blooms in Lake Erie. PLoS One 7: e42444. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0042444.
  • Stutter, M.J., W. Chardon, and B. Kronvang. 2012. Riparian buffer strips as a multifunctional management tool in agricultural landscapes: Introduction. Journal of Environmental Quality 41: 297–303.
  • Tiessen, K.H.D., J.A. Elliott, J. Yarotski, D.A. Lobb, D.N. Flaten, and N.E. Glozier. 2009. Conventional and conservation tillage: Influence on seasonal runoff, sediment, and nutrient losses in the Canadian prairies. Journal of Environmental Quality 39: 964–980.
  • U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 2013. Literature review of contaminants in livestock and poultry manure and implications for water quality. Retrieved Nov 19, 2014, from http://water.epa. gov/scitech/cec/upload/Literature-Review-of-Contaminants-in-Live stock-and-Poultry-Manure-and-Implications-for-Water-Quality.pdf.
  • Uusi-Kämppä, J., and L. Jauhiainen. 2010. Long-term monitoring of buffer zone efficiency under different cultivation techniques in boreal conditions. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 137: 75–85.
  • Ulén, B., and A. Etana. 2012. Phosphorus leaching from clay soils can be counteracted by structure liming. Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section B. doi:10.1080/09064710.2014.920043.
  • Vaughan, I., and S.J. Ormerod. 2012. Large-scale, long-term trends in British river macroinvertebrates. Global Change Biology 18: 2184–2194.
  • White, M. 2014. 'Incredible Hulk' algae unleashes economic fury on Toledo. NBC News. Retrieved Nov 17, 2014, from http:// www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/incredible-hulk-algaeunleashes- economic-fury-toledo-n172351.
  • Withers, P.J.A., B. Ulén, C. Stamm, and M. Bechmann. 2003. Incidental phosphorus losses—Are they significant and can they be predicted? Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science 166: 459–468.
  • Withers, P.J.A., C. Neal, H.P. Jarvie, and D.G. Doody. 2014. Agriculture and eutrophication: Where do we go from here? Sustainability 6: 5853–5875.
  • Zhang, Y., A.L. Collins, N. Murdoch, D. Lee, and P.S. Naden. 2014. Cross sector contributions to river pollution in England and Wales: Updating waterbody scale information to support policy delivery for the Water Framework Directive. Environmental Science & Policy 42: 16–32.