Working paper Open Access
Resetting History's Dial? A Critique of David Graeber and David Wengrow, "The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity"
Scheidel, Walter
Graeber and Wengrow’s sprawling new history of freedom has considerable strengths: its emphasis on formative processes that unfolded before literate civilizations appeared, its global reach, and its skepticism about the connection between state power and civilization. But it also suffers from serious shortcomings: the authors’ commitment to an excessively idealist view of historical dynamics, their use of rhetorical strategies that misguide their audience, and their resultant inability to account for broad trajectories of human development.
Files
(356.6 kB)
| Name | Size | |
|---|---|---|
|
Scheidel on Graeber and Wengrow.pdf
md5:cbb9839922d9ef44f7350789030f3da8 |
356.6 kB | Download |
12,998
11,043
views
downloads
| All versions | This version | |
|---|---|---|
| Views | 12,998 | 12,998 |
| Downloads | 11,043 | 11,043 |
| Data volume | 3.9 GB | 3.9 GB |
| Unique views | 12,137 | 12,137 |
| Unique downloads | 9,941 | 9,941 |
Indexed in
- Publication date:
- January 26, 2022
- DOI:
-
- Keyword(s):
- World History Social Evolution Foragers State Formation Agrarian Societies Inequality
- License (for files):
- Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International