Journal article Open Access

Quantitative Storytelling: Science, Narratives, and Uncertainty in Nexus Innovations

Di Felice, L.J.; Cabello, V.; Ripa, M.; Madrid-Lopez, C.

Innovations are central instruments of sustainability policies. They project future visions onto technological solutions and enable win-win framings of complex sustainability issues. Yet, they also create new problems by interconnecting different resources such as water, food, and energy, what is known as the “WEF nexus.” In this paper, we apply a new approach called Quantitative Storytelling (QST) to the assessment of four innovations with a strong nexus component in EU policy: biofuels, shale gas, electric vehicles, and alternative water resources. Recognizing irreducible pluralism and uncertainties, QST inspects the relationships between the narratives used to frame sustainability issues and the evidence on those issues. Our experiences outlined two rationales for implementing QST. First, QST can be used to question dominant narratives that promote certain innovations despite evidence against their effectiveness. Second, QST can offer avenues for pluralistic processes of co-creation of alternative narratives and imaginaries. We reflect on the implementation of QST and on the role played by different uncertainties throughout these processes. Our experiences suggest that while the role of nexus assessments using both numbers and narratives may not be instrumental in directly inducing policy change, they are valuable means to open discussions on innovations outside of dominant nexus imaginaries.

This research has been funded by: the European Union's H2020 project MAGIC: Moving Towards Adaptive Governance in Complexity (MAGIC GA No. 689669); European Union's FP7 project IANEX: Integrated Assessment of the Nexus: the case of hydraulic fracturing, Marie Curie International Outgoing Fellowship GA No. 623593; Spanish Ministry of Science' Juan de la Cierva Fellowship IJC2019-038847-I/ AEI / 10.13039/501100011033; Maria de Maetzu CEX2019-000940-M. The present work reflects only the authors' view and the funding Agencies cannot be held responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains.
Files (1.1 MB)
Name Size
1.1 MB Download
Views 93
Downloads 170
Data volume 193.1 MB
Unique views 83
Unique downloads 163


Cite as