On the agreement between bibliometrics and peer review. Supplementary materials

Data sets and supplementary materials of the paper "On the agreement between bibliometrics and peer review: evidence from the Italian research assessment exercises" 

DS1_EXP1 and EXP2 data.xls: raw anonymized data of the two experiments EXP1 and EXP2.

DS2_Avg_score_vs_perc_peer_review_VQR1_VQR2. average score and proportion of peer review evaluations at a scientific field level. Data from the two Italian research assessment exercises VQR1 and VQR2. 

SM1_Fig_1_EXP1_geom_count_peer_vs_bibliometrics_all.png: joint distribution of peer review and bibliometrics evaluations for EXP1. R_ggplot: count overlapping points (proportion). All research areas.

SM1_Fig_2_EXP1_geom_count_peer_vs_bibliometrics_area.png:  joint distribution of peer review and bibliometrics evaluations for EXP1. R_ggplot: count overlapping points (proportion). Separate plot for each research area.

SM1_Fig_3_EXP2_geom_count_peer_vs_bibliometrics_all.png: joint distribution of peer review and bibliometrics evaluations for EXP2. All scientific areas. R_ggplot: count overlapping points (proportion). All areas.

SM1_Fig_4_EXP2_geom_count_peer_vs_bibliometrics_area.png:  joint distribution of peer review and bibliometrics evaluations for EXP2. R_ggplot: count overlapping points (proportion). Separate plot for each research area.

SM2_Fig_1_VQR1_plot_avg_score_percentage_peer.png: Average score and percentage of articles evaluated by peer review for
research fields in VQR1. All areas.

SM2_Fig_2_VQR1_avg_score_vs_percentage_peer: Regression lines for average score and percentage of articles evaluated by peer review for different research areas. VQR1.

SM2_Fig_3_VQR2_plot_avg_score_percentage_peer.png: Average score and percentage of articles evaluated by peer review for
research fields in VQR2. All areas.

SM2_Fig_4_VQR2_avg_score_vs_percentage_peer: Regression lines for average score and percentage of articles evaluated by peer review for different research areas. VQR2.

SM_supplementary_table_linear_weights.pdf: Cohen's kappa estimates with linear weights for EXP1 and EXP2. 4 tables.