Published July 3, 2019 | Version v1
Conference paper Open

Virtual integration: managing complex warship design through model based engineering

  • 1. BAE Systems Maritime – Submarines, UK
  • 2. BAE Systems Maritime – Naval Ships, UK

Description

Modern warships have become increasingly complex systems, capable of performing a variety of roles, in demanding environments whilst under the presence of a military threat. As the complexity of warships has increased, so too have the systems and processes established to design and manufacture them. Warship designers have become systems engineers charged with delivering integrated products often within programmes constrained by cost, risk, resource and commercial construct.

For centuries, if not millennia, models have been an essential component of the warship design process providing a contextual reference for what the finished product may look like and how it may perform. Traditionally, these models have focussed on the physical performance attributes of the warship, its hull-form, its length, beam and displacement, its propulsion system and its likely payload; in unison these models provide an early understanding of key characteristics such as range, speed, complement and sea-keeping. However, with the reduction of ships’ companies and the proliferation of increasingly complex software-based control systems, coupled with a backdrop of squeezed defence budgets/development timescales, the call upon models to help manage and de-risk such complexity is becoming prevalent.

Across the industrial landscape, model based systems engineering, architectural frameworks and the Systems Modelling Language have become common tools within the systems engineer’s arsenal as a means for managing system complexity and mitigating system integration risk. Within the warship design domain, the use of model based systems engineering has been most widely deployed by combat system designers, largely in recognition of the software based nature of these systems. This paper discusses how such approaches are equally applicable to the wider warship design and manufacture process – notably the development of Marine and Platform Systems; it describes the deployment of model based engineering and the Systems Modelling Language to de-risk modern warship design. It presents an overarching modelling framework and corresponding design methodology that can be deployed in concert with the more traditional modelling techniques used in warship design, to more effectively reduce risk and manage whole-ship integration.

Files

EAAW VIII Paper 009 Tudor Final P.pdf

Files (2.5 MB)

Name Size Download all
md5:d659f5f832db14e7c419cdb10c7be2c1
2.5 MB Preview Download

Additional details

References

  • D J Andrews, 'Simulation and the design building block approach in the design of ships and other complex systems', Proceedings: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, Vol. 462, No. 2075, pp.3407- 3433, The Royal Society (2006).
  • A R Edmondson, B Twomey, 'Systems Engineering – The Hard Way', Proceedings of the International Naval Engineering Conference 2018, IMarEST, (2018).
  • Z Liang, L Yan, J Shang, 'Collaborative multidisciplinary decision making based on game theory in ship preliminary design', Journal of Marine Science and Technology, Vol.14, No. 3, pp. 334-344, JASNAOE (2009).
  • C Buck, 'The use of an Integrated Architecture Framework for the design of the Type 26 Global Combat Ship', Proceedings of the International Naval Engineering Conference 2012, IMarEST, (2012).
  • P Pearce & M Hause, 'ISO-15288, OOSEM and model-based submarine design', Proceedings from the Systems Engineering Test & Evaluation Conference 2012, 6th Asia Pacific Conference On Systems Engineering (2012).
  • I Boyle & A Hird, 'An Evaluation of the Integrated Architecture Framework', University of Strathclyde report produced for BAE Systems' Integrated Product Development Environment project, (2013).
  • D J Andrews, 'A Comprehensive Methodology for the Design of Ships (and other Complex Systems)', Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, Vol. 454, pp. 187-211, The Royal Society – London (1998).
  • K Forsberg & H Mooz, 'The Relationship of Systems Engineering to the Project Cycle', Engineering Management Journal 4, pp.36-43, Hunstville (1992).
  • J Harvey-Evans, 'Basic Design Concepts', U.S. Navy Design Journal 71, pp.671-678, United States Navy (1959).
  • D J Andrews, 'Integrated Approach to Ship Synthesis', Royal Institute of Naval Architects 128, pp.73-102, United Kingdom (1986).
  • N A Tepper, 'Exploring the use of Model Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) to develop System Architectures in Naval Ship Design', MSc Thesis submitted to Department of Mechanical Engineering Department, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA (2010).
  • M R Emes et. al, 'Interpreting "Systems Architecting"', INCOSE UK Systems Engineering Volume 15 No.4, pp.369-395, London (2012).
  • J A Estefan, 'Survey of Model Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) Technologies', Revision. B, INCOSE MBSE Initiative, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, USA (2008).
  • INCOSE, 'What is Model-Based Systems Engineering?', INCOSE UK Leaflet-Z9, International Council of Systems Engineering, London (2015)
  • D Steinbach, D, 'Guidelines for Model Based Systems Engineering', from http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/articleDetails.jsp?reload=true&arnumber=6176450, (2015).
  • L Baker et al., 'Foundational Concepts for Model Driven Systems Design', INCOSE Model Driven Systems Design Interest Group Paper, International Council on Systems Engineering, London (2009)
  • D Harvey, M Waite, P Logan & T Liddie, 'Document the Model, Don't Model the Document', from http://shoalgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Harvey-et-al-2012-Document-the-Model-Dont-Modelthe- Document-SETE-2012.pdf, (2012).
  • S Pilemalm, N Hallberg, M Sparf, & T Niclason, 'Practical Experiences of Model Based Development: Case Studies from the Swedish Armed Forces', INCOSE Systems Engineering Vol. 15, Issue 4, pp.407- 421, International Council on Systems Engineering, London (2012).
  • W Tudor & C Bach, 'Designing marine systems in complex warships: an exploration into the deployment of model based systems engineering', Proceedings from International Naval Engineering Conference, IMarEST, Bristol (2016)
  • A Edmondson & B Twomey, 'Systems Engineering – The Hard Way', Proceedings from International Naval Engineering Conference, IMarEST, Glasgow (2018)