Book section Open Access

Can cross-linguistic regularities be explained by constraints on change?

Martin Haspelmath

This paper addresses a recent trend in the study of language variation and universals, namely to attribute cross-linguistic patterns to diachrony, rather than to other causal factors. This is an interesting suggestion, and I try to make the basic concepts clearer, by distinguishing clearly between language-particular regularities, universal tendencies, and mere recurrent patterns, as well as three kinds of causal factors (preferences, constraints, restrictions). I make four claims: (i) Explanations may involve diachrony in different ways; (ii) for causal explanations of universal tendencies, one needs to invoke mutational constraints (change constraints); (iii) in addition to mutational constraints, we need functional-adaptive constraints as well, as is clear from cases of multi-convergence; and (iv) successful functional-adaptive explanations do not depend on understanding the precise pathways of change.

Files (198.2 kB)
Name Size
198.2 kB Download
All versions This version
Views 401399
Downloads 186186
Data volume 36.9 MB36.9 MB
Unique views 353351
Unique downloads 170170


Cite as