Planned intervention: On Wednesday April 3rd 05:30 UTC Zenodo will be unavailable for up to 2-10 minutes to perform a storage cluster upgrade.
Published November 1, 1999 | Version v1
Journal article Open

Are there principles of grammatical change (A review article of David Lightfoot's book "The development of language")

  • 1. Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology

Description

This is a highly critical review of David Lightfoots 1999 book "The development of language", which argues that there are no principles of grammatical change, so that “historicist” or deterministic approaches to diachronic change are misguided. Instead, Lightfoot argues that language change can only be understood by taking the perspective of the “growth” (i.e. acquisition) of an individual’s biological grammar, which may end up with a different parameter setting from the parent’s generation when the trigger experience changes. This review is very critical of most aspects of Lightfoot's theory: his strange notions of “language” and “social grammar”, his failure to say anything meaningful about “nongrammatical changes” (i.e. apparently the great majority of changes), his unconstrained theoretical innovation of “diglossia”, his complete misunderstanding of the neogrammarian revolution, and his irresponsible ignoring of much of contemporary work on language change.

Files

Haspelmath1999.pdf

Files (5.0 MB)

Name Size Download all
md5:4d289abb0d47d59fcceec946ec8daeb8
5.0 MB Preview Download