Info: Zenodo’s user support line is staffed on regular business days between Dec 23 and Jan 5. Response times may be slightly longer than normal.

Published November 30, 2014 | Version v1
Journal article Open

If It Looks Like a Duck and Quacks Like a Duck: Evaluating the Validity of Borderline Personality Disorder in Adolescents

Creators

  • 1. University of Houston, The Menninger Clinic, Baylor College of Medicine,TX,USA
  • 2. Developmental Psychopathology Lab, Dep. of Psychology, University of Houston,TX,USA

Description

The validity of borderline personality disorder (BPD) has been a topic of much controversy in psychiatry. Over the last two decades, a wealth of empirical work has challenged long-held concerns regarding the validity of adolescent BPD. However, this research has been conducted within a traditional approach to psychiatric nosology.In this article, we aim to evaluate the validity of adolescent BPD as guided by both the Robins and Guze criteria for the validity of psychiatric constructs and the new National Institute of Mental Health Research Domain Criteria (NIMH RDoC).We used the five principles of the Robins and Guze approach to evaluate selected research from our own and other groups regarding the validity of adolescent BPD. These principles include clinical description studies, laboratory studies, studies that delimitate the disorder from other related syndromes, follow-up studies, and family studies.Within the Robins and Guze criteria framework, evidence to date supports the validity of adolescent BPD to some extent. However, limitations of the research about the construct validity of adolescent BPD have also been identified, most notably regarding the delimitation of adolescent BPD from other disorders as well as a lack of longitudinal and family studies.Given these limitations and the limitations of the Robins and Guze approach to psychiatric nosology, we recommend exploring the potential of the National Institute of Mental Health Research Domain Criteria as a complement to previous work.

Files

10.21307_sjcapp-2015-005.pdf

Files (291.8 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:6e25c3a6ef882ba266b9ebe0e75dd30a
291.8 kB Preview Download

Additional details

References

  • Chanen AM, McCutcheon LK. Personality disorder in adolescence: The diagnosis that dare not speak its name. Personal Ment Health 2008;2:35-41.
  • Griffiths M. Validity, utility and acceptability of borderline personality disorder diagnosis in childhood and adolescence: survey of psychiatrists. Psychiatrist 2011;35(1):19-22.
  • Laurenssen EM, Hutsebaut J, Feenstra DJ, Van Busschbach JJ, Luyten P. Diagnosis of personality disorders in adolescents: A study among psychologists. Child Adolesc Psychiatry Ment Health 2013;7(1):3.
  • Kernberg PF, Weiner AS, Bardenstein KK. Personality disorders in children and adolescents. New York: Basic Books; 2000.
  • Shapiro T. Debate forum-resolved: borderline personality disorder exists in children under twelve. J Am Acad Child Psychiatry 1990;29:478–483.
  • Crick NR, Murray-Close D, Woods K. Borderline personality features in childhood: a short-term longitudinal study. Dev Psychopathol 2005;17(4):1051-1070.
  • Meijer M, Goedhart AW, Treffers PDA. The persistence of borderline personality disorder in adolescence. J Pers Disord 1998;12:13-22.
  • Nelson EE, Leibenluft E, McClure EB, Pine DS. The social reorientation of adolescence: a neuroscience perspective on the process and its relation to psychopathology. Psychol Med 2005;35(2):163-174.
  • Fossati A. Borderline personality disorder in adolescence: Phenomenology and construct validity. In: Sharp C, Tackett JL (eds). Handbook of borderline personality disorder in children and adolescents. New York, NY: Springer; 2014, p. 19-34.
  • Moran P, Coffey C, Romaniuk H, et al. The natural history of self-harm from adolescence to young adulthood: a population-based cohort study. Lancet 2012;379(9812):236-243.
  • Copeland WE, Shanahan L, Costello EJ, Angold A. Childhood and adolescent psychiatric disorders as predictors of young adult disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2009;66(7):764-772.
  • Paris J. A history of research on borderline personality disorder in childhood and adolescence. In: Sharp C, Tackett JL (eds). Handbook of borderline personality disorder in children and adolescents. New York, NY: Springer; 2014, p. 9-17.
  • Robins E, Guze SB. Establishment of diagnostic validity in psychiatric illness - Its application to schizophrenia. Am J Psychiatry 1970;126(7):983-987.
  • Luyten P, Blatt SJ. Integrating theory-driven and empirically-derived models of personality development and psychopathology: a proposal for DSM V. Clin Psychol Rev 2011;31(1):52-68.
  • Silverman MH, Krueger RF. Borderline personality disorder and DSM-5: New directions and hopes for the future. In: Sharp C, Tackett J (eds). Handbook of borderline personality disorder in children and adolescents. New York, NY: Springer; 2014, p. 433-450.
  • Insel T, Cuthbert B, Garvey M, et al. Research domain criteria (RDoC): toward a new classification framework for research on mental disorders. Am J Psychiatry 2010;167(7):748-751.
  • Cuthbert BN, Insel TR. Toward the future of psychiatric diagnosis: the seven pillars of RDoC. BMC Med 2013;11:126.
  • National Institute of Mental Health. Research Domain Criteria (RDoC); 2011. Available at: http://www.nimh.nih.gov/research-priorities/rdoc/index.shtml. Accessed June 7, 2014.
  • National Institute of Mental Health. The National Institute of Mental Health strategic plan (NIH Publication No. 08-6368); 2008. Available at: http://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/strategic-planning-reports/index.shtml. Accessed June 7, 2014.
  • Aggen SH, Neale MC, Roysamb E, Reichborn-Kjennerud T, Kendler KS. A psychometric evaluation of the DSM-IV borderline personality disorder criteria: age and sex moderation of criterion functioning. Psychol Med 2009;39(12):1967-1978.
  • Feske U, Kirisci L, Tarter RE, Pilkonis PA. An application of item response theory to the DSM-III-R criteria for borderline personality disorder. J Pers Disord 2007;21(4):418-433.
  • Clifton A, Pilkonis PA. Evidence for a single latent class of Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders borderline personality pathology. Compr Psychiatry 2007;48(1):70-78.
  • Fossati A, Maffei C, Bagnato M, Donati D, Namia C, Novella L. Latent structure analysis of DSM-IV borderline personality disorder criteria. Compr Psychiatry 1999;40(1):72-79.
  • Johansen M, Karterud S, Pedersen G, Gude T, Falkum E. An investigation of the prototype validity of the borderline DSM-IV construct. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2004;109(4):289-298.
  • Chabrol H, Montovany A, Callahan S, Chouicha K, Duconge E. Factor analyses of the DIB-R in adolescents. J Pers Disord 2002;16(4):374-384.
  • Michonski JD, Sharp C, Steinberg L, Zanarini MC. An item response theory analysis of the DSM-IV borderline personality disorder criteria in a population-based sample of 11-to 12-year-old children. Personal Disord 2013;4(1):15-22.
  • Zanarini MC. The Child Interview for DSM-IV borderline personality disorder. Belmont, MA: McLean Hospital; 2003.
  • Becker DF, Grilo CM, Edell WS, McGlashan TH. Diagnostic efficiency of borderline personality disorder criteria in hospitalized adolescents: comparison with hospitalized adults. Am J Psychiatry 2002;159(12):2042-2047.
  • Resch F, Parzer P, Brunner R. Self-mutilation and suicidal behaviour in children and adolescents: prevalence and psychosocial correlates: results of the BELLA study. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2008;17 Suppl 1:92-98.
  • Sharp C, Ha C, Michonski J, Venta A, Carbone C. Borderline personality disorder in adolescents: evidence in support of the Childhood Interview for DSM-IV borderline personality disorder in a sample of adolescent inpatients. Compr Psychiatry 2012;53(6):765-774.
  • Huprich SK, Schmitt TA, Richard DC, Chelminski I, Zimmerman MA. Comparing factor analytic models of the DSM-IV personality disorders. Personal Disord 2010;1(1):22-37.
  • Howard RC, Huband N, Duggan C, Mannion A. Exploring the link between personality disorder and criminality in a community sample. J Pers Disord 2008;22(6):589-603.
  • Durrett C, Westen D. The structure of axis II disorders in adolescents: a cluster- and factor-analytic investigation of DSM-IV categories and criteria. J Pers Disord 2005;19(4):440-461.
  • Blackburn R, Logan C, Renwick SJ, Donnelly JP. Higher-order dimensions of personality disorder: hierarchical structure and relationships with the five-factor model, the interpersonal circle, and psychopathy. J Pers Disord 2005;19(6):597-623.
  • Torgersen S, Skre I, Onstad S, Edvardsen J, Kringlen E. The psychometric-genetic structure of DSM-III-R personality-disorder criteria. J Pers Disord 1993;7(3):196-213.
  • Morey LC. The categorical representation of personality disorder: a cluster analysis of DSM-III-R personality features. J Abnorm Psychol 1988;97(3):314-321.
  • Moldin SO, Rice JP, Erlenmeyer-Kimling L, Squires-Wheeler E. Latent structure of DSM-III-R Axis II psychopathology in a normal sample. J Abnorm Psychol 1994;103(2):259-266.
  • Nestadt G, Eaton WW, Romanoski AJ, Garrison R, Folstein MF, McHugh PR. Assessment of DSM-III personality structure in a general-population survey. Compr Psychiatry 1994;35(1):54-63.
  • Reise SP, Moore TM, Haviland MG. Bifactor models and rotations: exploring the extent to which multidimensional data yield univocal scale scores. J Pers Assess 2010;92(6):544-559.
  • Jennrich RI, Bentler PM. Exploratory bi-factor analysis. Psychometrika 2011;76(4):537-549.
  • Chanen AM, Jackson HJ, McCutcheon LK, et al. Early intervention for adolescents with borderline personality disorder using cognitive analytic therapy: randomised controlled trial. Br J Psychiatry. 2008;193(6):477-484.
  • Sharp C, Steinberg L, Temple J, Newlin E. An 11-item measure to assess borderline traits in adolescents: refinement of the BPFSC using IRT. Personal Disord 2014; 5(1):70-78.
  • Sharp C, Mosko O, Chang B, Ha C. The cross-informant concordance and concurrent validity of the Borderline Personality Features Scale for Children in a sample of male youth. Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry 2011;16(3):335-349.
  • Verhulst FC, Van der Ende J. Agreement between parents' reports and adolescents' self-reports of problem behavior. J Child Psychol Psychiatry Allied Discip 1992;33(6):1011-1023.
  • Achenbach TM, Rescorla LA. Manual for ASEBA school-age forms and profiles. Burlington: University of Vermont, Research Center for Children, Youth and Families; 2001.
  • Chang B, Sharp C, Ha C. The criterion validity of the Borderline Personality Feature Scale for Children in an adolescent inpatient setting. J Pers Disord 2011;25(4):492-503.
  • Eaton NR, Krueger RF, Keyes KM, et al. Borderline personality disorder co-morbidity: relationship to the internalizing-externalizing structure of common mental disorders. Psychol Med 2011;41(5):1041-1050.
  • James LM, Taylor J. Associations between symptoms of borderline personality disorder, externalizing disorders, and suicide-related behaviors. J Psychopathol Behav Assess 2008;30(1):1-9.
  • Achenbach TM, McConaughy SH, Howell CT. Child/adolescent behavioral and emotional problems: implication of cross-informant correlations for situational specificity. Psychol Bull 1987;101:213-232.
  • Zanarini MC, Vujanovic AA, Parachini EA, Boulanger JL, Frankenburg FR, Hennen J. A screening measure for BPD: the McLean Screening Instrument for Borderline Personality Disorder (MSI-BPD). J Pers Disord 2003;17(6):568-573.
  • Noblin JL, Venta A, Sharp C. The validity of the MSI-BPD among inpatient adolescents. Assessment 2013;21(2):210-217.
  • Chanen AM, Jovev M, Djaja D, et al. Screening for borderline personality disorder in outpatient youth. J Pers Disord 2008;22(4):353-364.
  • Patel AB, Sharp C, Fonagy P. Criterion validity of the MSI-BPD in a community sample of women. J Psychopathol Behav Assess 2011;33(3):403-408.
  • McManus M, Lerner H, Robbins D, Barbour C. Assessment of borderline symptomatology in hospitalized adolescents. J Am Acad Child Psychiatry 1984;23(6):685-694.
  • Becker D, McGlashan TH, Grilo CM. Exploratory factor analysis of borderline personality disorder criteria in hospitalized adolescents. Compr Psychiatry 2006;47(2):99-105.
  • Mattanah JJ, Becker DF, Levy KN, Edell WS, McGlashan TH. Diagnostic stability in adolescents followed up 2 years after hospitalization. Am J Psychiatry 1995;152(6):889-894.
  • Butcher JN, Williams CL, Graham JR, et al. Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-Adolescent (MMPI-A): manual for administration, scoring, and interpretation. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press; 1992.
  • Archer RP, Ball JD, Hunter JA. MMPI characteristics of borderline psychopathology in adolescent inpatients. J Pers Assess 1985;49(1):47-55.
  • De Clercq B, De Fruyt F, Van Leeuwen K, Mervielde I. The structure of maladaptive personality traits in childhood: a step toward an integrative developmental perspective for DSM-V. J Abnorm Psychol 2006;115(4):639-657.
  • Krueger RF, Derringer J, Markon KE, Watson D, Skodol AE. Initial construction of a maladaptive personality trait model and inventory for DSM-5. Psychol Med 2012;42(9):1879-1890.
  • De Clercq B, De Fruyt F, De Bolle M, Van Hiel A, Markon KE, Krueger RF. The hierarchical structure and construct validity of the PID-5 trait measure in adolescence. J Pers 2014;82(2):158-169.
  • Kaess M, Hille M, Parzer P, Maser-Gluth C, Resch F, Brunner R. Alterations in the neuroendocrinological stress response to acute psychosocial stress in adolescents engaging in nonsuicidal self-injury. Psychoneuroendocrino 2012;37(1):157-161.
  • Garner B, Chanen AM, Phillips L, et al. Pituitary volume in teenagers with first-presentation borderline personality disorder. Psychiatry Res 2007;156(3):257-261.
  • Whittle S, Chanen AM, Fornito A, McGorry PD, Pantelis C, Yucel M. Anterior cingulate volume in adolescents with first-presentation borderline personality disorder. Psychiatry Res 2009;172(2):155-160.
  • Goodman M, Hazlett EA, Avedon JB, Siever DR, Chu KW, New AS. Anterior cingulate volume reduction in adolescents with borderline personality disorder and co-morbid major depression. J Psychiatr Res 2011;45(6):803-807.
  • Brunner R, Henze R, Parzer P, et al. Reduced prefrontal and orbitofrontal gray matter in female adolescents with borderline personality disorder: Is it disorder specific? Neuroimage 2010;49(1):114-120.
  • Chanen AM, Velakoulis D, Carison K, et al. Orbitofrontal, amygdala and hippocampal volumes in teenagers with first-presentation borderline personality disorder. Psychiatry Res 2008;163(2):116-125.
  • Cicchetti D, Rogosch FA. A developmental psychopathology perspective on adolescence. J Consult Clin Psychol 2002;70(1):6-20.
  • Fonagy P, Target M, Gergely G. Attachment and borderline personality disorder. A theory and some evidence. Psychiatr Clin North Am 2000;23(1):103-122.
  • Fonagy P, Luyten P. A developmental, mentalization-based approach to the understanding and treatment of borderline personality disorder. Dev Psychopathol 2009;21(4):1355-1381.
  • Sharp C, Fonagy P. The parent's capacity to treat the child as a psychological agent: constructs, measures and implications for developmental psychopathology. Soc Dev 2008;17(3):737-754.
  • Sharp C, Fonagy P. Social cognition and attachment-related disorders. In: Sharp C, Fonagy P, Goodyer I (eds). Social cognition and developmental psychopathology. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 2008, p. 269-302.
  • Shurz M, Radua J, Aichorn M, Richlan F, Perner J. Fractionating theory of mind: a meta-analysis of funtional brain imaging studies. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2014;42:9-34.
  • Dziobek I, Fleck S, Kalbe E, et al. Introducing MASC: a movie for the assessment of social cognition. J Autism Dev Disord 2006;36(5):623-636.
  • Sharp C, Pane H, Ha C, et al. Theory of mind and emotion regulation difficulties in adolescents with borderline traits. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2011;50(6):563-573.
  • Sharp C, Ha C, Carbone C, et al. Hypermentalizing in adolescent inpatients: treatment effects and association with borderline traits. J Pers Disord 2013;27(1):3-18.
  • Fonagy P, Luyten P. Translation: mentalizing as treatment target in BPD. Personal Disord (in press).
  • Franzen N, Hagenhoff M, Baer N, et al. Superior 'theory of mind' in borderline personality disorder: an analysis of interaction behavior in a virtual trust game. Psychiatry Res 2011;187(1-2):224-233.
  • Sharp C, Monterosso J, Montague R. Neuroeconomics: a bridge for translational research. Biol Psychiatry 2012;72(2):87-92.
  • Domes G, Schulze L, Herpertz SC. Emotion recognition in borderline personality disorder - a review of the literature. J Pers Disord 2009;23(1):6-19.
  • Widiger TA, Trull TJ. Borderline and narcissistic personality disorders. 2nd ed. Sutker PB, Adams HE (eds). New York, NY: Plenum Press; 1993.
  • Oldham JM, DeMasi ME. An integrated approach to emergency psychiatric care. New Dir Ment Health Serv 1995(67):33-42.
  • Zanarini MC, Frankenburg FR, Dubo ED, et al. Axis I comorbidity of borderline personality disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1998;155(12):1733-1739.
  • Zimmerman M, Mattia JI. Axis I diagnostic comorbidity and borderline personality disorder. Compr Psychiatry 1999;40(4):245-252.
  • McGlashan TH, Grilo CM, Skodol AE, et al. The Collaborative Longitudinal Personality Disorders Study: baseline axis I/II and II/II diagnostic co-occurrence. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2000;102(4):256-264.
  • Skodol AE, Gunderson JG, Pfohl B, Widiger TA, Livesley WJ, Siever LJ. The borderline diagnosis I: Psychopathology, comorbidity, and personality structure. Biol Psychiatry 2002;51(12):936-950.
  • Lenzenweger MF, Lane MC, Loranger AW, Kessler RC. DSM-IV personality disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Biol Psychiatry 2007;62(6):553-564.
  • Grant BF, Chou SP, Goldstein RB, et al. Prevalence, correlates, disability, and comorbidity of DSM-IV borderline personality disorder: results from the Wave 2 National Epidemiologic Survey on alcohol and related conditions. J Clin Psychiatry 2008;69(4):533-545.
  • Cohen P. Child development and personality disorder. Psychiatr Clin North Am 2008;31(3):477-493, vii.
  • Crawford TN, Cohen P, First MB, Skodol AE, Johnson JG, Kasen S. Comorbid Axis I and Axis II disorders in early adolescence: outcomes 20 years later. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2008;65(6):641-648.
  • Ha C, Balderas J, Zanarini M, Oldham J, Sharp C. Psychiatric comorbidiby in hospitalized adolescents with borderline personality disorder. J Clin Psychiatry 2014;75(5)e457-464.
  • Sharp C, Elhai J, Kalpacki A, Michonski J, Pavlidis I. Locating BPD within the internalizing-externalizing spectrum in adolescents. J Abnorm Psychol (under review)
  • Zanarini MC, Frankenburg FR, Khera GS, Bleichmar J. Treatment histories of borderline inpatients. Compr Psychiatry 2001;42:144-150.
  • Kessler RC, Avenevoli S, Costello EJ, et al. National comorbidity survey replication adolescent supplement (NCS-A): II. Overview and design. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2009;48(4):380-385.
  • Chanen AM, Jovev M, Jackson HJ. Adaptive functioning and psychiatric symptoms in adolescents with borderline personality disorder. J Clin Psychiatry 2007;68(2):297-306.
  • Chanen AM, Kaess M. Developmental pathways to borderline personality disorder. Curr Psychiatry Rep 2012;14(1):45-53.
  • Caspi A, Bern D. Personality continuity and change across the life course. In: Pervin LA, (ed). Handbook of personality: theory and research. New York, NY: Guilford Press; 1990, p. 549-575.
  • Stepp SD, Burke JD, Hipwell AE, Loeber R. Trajectories of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and oppositional defiant disorder symptoms as precursors of borderline personality disorder symptoms in adolescent girls. J Abnorm Child Psychol 2012;40(1):7-20.
  • Chanen AM, Jackson HJ, McGorry PD, Allot KA, Clarkson V, Yuen HP. Two-year stability of personality disorder in older adolescent outpatients. J Pers Disord 2004;18(6):526-541.
  • Zanarini MC, Horwood J, Wolke D, Waylen A, Fitzmaurice G, Grant BF. Prevalence of DSM-IV borderline personality disorder in two community samples: 6,330 English 11-year-olds and 34,653 American adults. J Pers Disord 2011;25(5):607-619.
  • Skodol AE, Gunderson JG, Shea MT, et al. The Collaborative Longitudinal Personality Disorders Study (CLPS): overview and implications. J Pers Disord 2005;19(5):487-504.
  • Distel MA, Trull TJ, Derom CA, et al. Heritability of borderline personality disorder features is similar across three countries. Psychol Med 2008;38(9):1219-1229.
  • Torgersen S, Lygren S, Oien PA, et al. A twin study of personality disorders. Compr Psychiatry 2000;41(6):416-425.
  • Kendler KS, Myers J, Reichborn-Kjennerud T. Borderline personality disorder traits and their relationship with dimensions of normative personality: A web-based cohort and twin study. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2011;123(5):349-359.
  • Belsky DW, Caspi A, Arseneault L, et al. Etiological features of borderline personality related characteristics in a birth cohort of 12-year-old children. Dev Psychopathol 2012;24(1):251-265.
  • Bornovalova MA, Hicks BM, Iacono WG, McGue M. Stability, change, and heritability of borderline personality disorder traits from adolescence to adulthood: a longitudinal twin study. Dev Psychopathol 2009;21(4):1335-1353.
  • Zaboli G, Gizatullin R, Nilsonne A, et al. Tryptophan hydroxylase-1 gene variants associate with a group of suicidal borderline women. Neuropsychopharmacol 2006;31(9):1982-1990.
  • Ni X, Bismil R, Chan K, Sicard T, et al. Serotonin 2A receptor gene is associated with personality traits, but not to disorder, in patients with borderline personality disorder. Neurosci Lett 2006;408(3):214-219.
  • Ni X, Chan D, Chan K, McMain S, Kennedy JL. Serotonin genes and gene-gene interactions in borderline personality disorder in a matched case-control study. Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 2009;33(1):128-133.
  • Ni X, Sicard T, Bulgin N, et al. Monoamine oxidase A gene is associated with borderline personality disorder. Psychiatr Genet 2007;17(3):153-157.
  • Hankin BL, Barrocas AL, Jenness J, et al. Association between 5-HTTLPR and borderline personality disorder traits among youth. Front Psychiatry 2011;2:6.
  • Bornovalova MA, Huibregtse BM, Hicks BM, Keyes M, McGue M, Iacono W. Tests of a direct effect of childhood abuse on adult borderline personality disorder traits: a longitudinal discordant twin design. J Abnorm Psychol 2013;122(1):180-194.
  • Jahng S, Trull TJ, Wood PK, et al. Distinguishing general and specific personality disorder features and implications for substance dependence comorbidity. J Abnorm Psychol 2011;120(3):656-669.