Published July 28, 2023 | Version 1

Flux-Like Probability ex(ipx) Guaranteeing One Dimensional Photon Reflection-Refraction Probability Conservation

Authors/Creators

Description

 Consider the problem of a photon moving in the x direction in a medium with index of refraction n1 and striking an interface along the y axis at x=0 with n2=n1 for x>0. It is evident that 1= Probability(reflect) + Probability(refract), but this equation does not yield the relative probability ratio. One might try to apply maximization of Shannon’s entropy subject to the constraint Sum over i P(i) = 1 ((1)). This, however, like for a coin, yields probabilities of .5 which do not match experiment. What is wrong? First, it seems like there are more constraints in the problem which have been overlooked in the constraint ((1)). For instance, E=pc and E is constant for all x. There is a discontinuity in p (momentum) and speed at x=0. The speed of light in a medium with index of refraction is c/ni where c is the speed in a vacuum. Thus we suggest a kind of motion related equilibrium throughout the medium. This same idea applies to p, momentum. How does one characterize such an equilibrium. In (1), we suggested a probability P(x) obtained by maximizing Shannon’s entropy subject to the periodic constrain i p x P(x) with p being the Lagrange multiplier. Here we point out that this maximization of entropy is equivalent to the statement that P(p,x)P(-p,x) = 1.  Thus a very different kind of equilibrium i.e. maximization of Shannon’s entropy exists. One does not maximize a Shannon’s entropy based on allowable state results as in the toss of a coin or die, or a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas. The equation P(reflect)+P(refract)=1, however, is based on state probabilities and we ask: Why is it guaranteed to exist if one uses an equilibrium based on exp(ipx) flux-like probabilities?

    Given the constraint that E is the same for all x, a particle reflecting at x=0 back into x<0 has no choice but to have a momentum of -p. This has important consequences on the link between the exp(ipx) flux-like probability and the state probabilities P(reflect), P(refract). In fact, we argue that it guarantees that a probability calculation using exp(ipx) yields P(reflect)+P(refract) =1 . In (2), for example, such a relationship is shown to exist, but it is not explained why it must exist. 

 

Files

physFluxProb2.pdf

Files (74.7 kB)

Name Size
md5:bc8dfce303c9894c0b026638269f90ac
74.7 kB Preview Download