Published September 7, 2022 | Version v1

An exploratory study of the efficiency of different models for institutional research funding of European universities: linking ETER and Leiden Ranking databases

  • 1. Centre for Science and Technology Studies

Description

This exploratory study illustrates the potential of linking input and output data with the university as the aggregation level to explore effects of funding models.

A first tentative conclusion is the greater efficiency of the universities in countries using a metric-based funding system compared with those without or with a limited performance based funding model; statistically there is no difference between the peer review and the metrics-based model. Using the proportion of highly cited papers as an indicator, an increase in the quality of the publication output of universities with metrics-based and to a lesser extent peer review based funding is observed. For the other two models no such effect was detected.

However caution is needed: only WoS publications are taken into account and due to limitations in the available ETER data a rather small time interval is used. As recently a new release of the ETER database became available, the analysis presented in this paper will be updated using somewhat longer time series.

More generally, internationally comparable input and output data covering not only publications but the broad range of academic work should be collected to gain insight into the effects of different funding models at the university level but also at lower aggregation levels. These studies could provide background material for more qualitative work on this important aspect of a country’s science policy, stimulate experts to better articulate their opinion on different funding models and provide incentives to further develop existing or devise new, more efficient funding models for universities.

Files

S27- Marc Luwel.pdf

Files (2.8 MB)

Name Size
md5:48526dcb38538b4445554314fe2efdfc
2.8 MB Preview Download

Additional details

Related works

Describes
Conference paper: 10.5281/zenodo.6975480 (DOI)