Published December 5, 2017 | Version v1

Changes in Water Quality of Grand Lake St. Marys Watershed Following Implementation of a Distressed Watershed Rules Package

  • 1. Wright State Univ.– Lake Campus
  • 2. National Center for Water Quality Research
  • 3. Mercer County Community and Economic Development Office

Description

ABSTRACT

Grand Lake St. Marys watershed has drawn attention over the past decade as water quality issues resulting from nutrient loading have come to the forefront of public opinion, political concern, and scientific study. The objective of this study was to assess long-term changes in water quality (nutrient and sediment concentrations) following the distressed watershed rules package instituted in 2011. Since that time, a variety of rules (e.g., winter manure ban) and best management practices (cover crops, manure storage or transfers, buffers, etc.) have been implemented. We used a general linear model to assess variation in total suspended solids, particulate phosphorus, soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP), nitrate N, and total Kjeldahl nitrogen concentrations from daily Chickasaw Creek (drains ~25% of watershed) samples spanning 2008 to 2016. Parameters were related to flow (higher values during high flows), timing (lower values during winter months), and the implementation of the distressed watershed rules package (lower values following implementation). Overall, reductions following the distressed designation for all parameters ranged from 5 to 35% during medium and high flow periods (with exception of SRP). Reductions were even more pronounced during winter months covered by the manure ban, where all parameters (including SRP) exhibited decreases at medium and high flows between 20 and 60%. While the reductions seen in this study are significant, concentrations are still highly elevated and continue to be a problem. We are optimistic that this study will serve to inform future management in the region and elsewhere.

Notes

Thank you to Terry M. Mescher (Division of Soil and Water Conservation, Ohio Department of Agriculture) for his insight into the project and work in the watershed and to Jason C. Doll (Quantitative Fisheries Center, Michigan State University) for his suggestions on the statistical approach used. Funding for water quality monitoring on Chickasaw Creek was provided to the National Center for Water Quality Research by the Ohio Water Development Authority and USDA–NRCS.

Files

Jacquemin et al. 2018 JEQ.pdf

Files (2.2 MB)

Name Size
md5:28249bb6c754f1bbfdd77304df559f2c
2.2 MB Preview Download

Additional details

References

  • Baker, D.B., R. Confesor, D.E. Ewing, L.T. Johnson, J.W. Kramer, and B.J. Merryfield. 2014. Phosphorus loading to Lake Erie from the Maumee, Sandusky, and Cuyahoga Rivers: The importance of bioavailability. J. Great Lakes Res. 40:502–517. doi:10.1016/j.jglr.2014.05.001
  • Carpenter, S.R. 2005. Eutrophication of aquatic ecosystems: Bistability and soil phosphorus. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102:10002–10005. doi:10.1073/ pnas.0503959102
  • Clark, C.F. 1960. Lake St. Marys and its management. Ohio Department of Natural Resources, Division of Wildlife. Columbus.
  • Converse, J.C., G.D. Bubenzer, and W.H. Paulson. 1976. Nutrient losses in surface runoff from winter spread manure. Trans. ASAE 19:0517–0519.
  • de Souza Beghelli, F.G., D. Frascareli, M.L.M. Pompêo, and V. Moschini-Carlos. 2016. Trophic state evolution over 15 years in a tropical reservoir with low nitrogen concentrations and cyanobacteria predominance. Water Air Soil Pollut. 227:95. doi:10.1007/s11270-016-2795-1
  • Dubrovsky, N.M., and P.A. Hamilton. 2010. Nutrients in the nation's streams and groundwater: National findings and implications. USGS Fact Sheet 2010-3078. USGS, Reston, VA.
  • Filbrun, J.E., J.D. Conroy, and D.A. Culver. 2013. Understanding seasonal phosphorus dynamics to guide effective management of shallow, hypereutrophic Grand Lake St. Marys, Ohio. Lake Reservoir Manage. 29:165–178.
  • Fleming, R., and H. Fraser. 2000. Impacts of winter spreading of manure on water quality: Literature review. Ridgetown College, University of Guelph, Ridgetown, ON, Canada. https://www.ridgetownc.com/research/documents/ fleming_manure.pdf (accessed June 2017).
  • Grand Lake/Wabash Watershed Alliance (GLWWA). 2008. Grand Lake St. Marys/Wabash River watershed action plan: A partnership between Soil and Water Conservation Districts. Darke, Auglaize, and Mercer Counties and the city of Celina. https://water.ohiodnr.gov/portals/soilwater/ downloads/wap/Wabash.pdf.
  • Hensler, R.F., R.J. Olsen, S.A. Witzel, O.J. Attoe, W.H. Paulson, and R.F. Johannes. 1970. Effect of method of manure handling on crop yields, nutrient recovery and runoff losses. Trans. ASAE 13:0726–0731.
  • Hoorman, J., T. Hone, T. Sudman, Jr., T. Dirksen, J. Iles, and K.R. Islam. 2008. Agricultural impacts on lake and stream water quality in Grand Lake St. Marys, western Ohio. Water Air Soil Pollut. 193:309–322. doi:10.1007/ s11270-008-9692-1
  • Hoorman, J.J., S.C. Prochaska, J.N. Rausch, and M. Fritz. 2005a. Ohio dairy farm manure application survey. Ohio J. Sci. 104:A-34.
  • Hoorman, J.J., S.C. Prochaska, J.N. Rausch, and M. Fritz. 2005b. Ohio swine farm manure application survey. Ohio J. Sci. 104:A-34.
  • Hoorman, J.J., and M.J. Shipitalo. 2006. Subsurface drainage and liquid manure. J. Soil Water Conserv. 61:94–97.
  • Inamdar, S.P., S. Mostaghimi, P.W. McClellan, and K.M. Brannan. 2001. BMP impacts on sediment and nutrient yields from an agricultural watershed in the Coastal Plain Region. Trans. ASAE 44:1191–1200. doi:10.13031/2013.6449
  • Khaleel, R., K.R. Reddy, and M.R. Overcash. 1980. Transport of potential pollutants in runoff water from land areas receiving animal wastes: A review. Water Res. 14:421–436. doi:10.1016/0043-1354(80)90206-7
  • Kongoli, C.E., and W.L. Bland. 2002. Influence of manure application on surface energy and snow cover. J. Environ. Qual. 31:1166–1173. doi:10.2134/ jeq2002.1166
  • Lorimor, J.C., and J.C. Melvin. 1996. Nitrogen losses in surface runoff from winter-applied manure. Final Report. University of Iowa.
  • Makarewicz, J.C., T.W. Lewis, I. Bosch, M.R. Noll, N. Herendeen, R.D. Simon, J. Zollweg, and A. Vodacek. 2009. The impact of agricultural best management practices on downstream systems: Soil loss and nutrient chemistry and flux to Conesus Lake, New York, USA. J. Great Lakes Res. 35:23–36. doi:10.1016/j.jglr.2008.10.006
  • McDowell, R.W., and A.N. Sharpley. 2001. A comparison of fluvial sediment phosphorus (P) chemistry in relation to location and potential to influence stream P concentrations. Aquat. Geochem. 7:255–265. doi:10.1023/A:1015274426411
  • Mescher, T., and F. Springer. 2013. Grand Lake St. Marys watershed update. Presented at: Lake Improvement Association, Montezuma, OH. 21 Oct. 2013. https://www.slideshare.net/lakeimprovement/grand-lake-st-maryswatershed- update (accessed Sept. 2017).
  • Minshall, N.E., S.A. Witzel, and M.S. Nichols. 1970. Stream enrichment from farm operations. J. Sanit. Eng. Div. Am. Soc. Civ. Eng. 96:513–524.
  • Molnau, M., and J.G. Cherry. 1990. A comparison of runoff occurring on frozen and unfrozen soils. In: K.R. Cooley, editor, Proceedings of International Symposium, Spokane, WA. CRREL Special Rep. 90-1. Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory, US Army Corps of Engineers, Hanover, NH. p. 279–281.
  • National Center for Water Quality Research. 2017. Tributary data download. National Center for Water Quality Research, Heidelberg University. https://ncwqr.org/monitoring/data/.
  • NRCS. 1999. Agricultural waste characteristics. In: J.N. Krider, and J.D. Rickman, editors, Part 651, Agricultural waste management field handbook. USDA-NRCS, Washington, DC.
  • NRCS. 2010–2013. Grand Lake St. Mary's watershed special project. USDA- NRCS. https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/oh/ programs/?cid=nrcs144p2_029521.
  • Ohio EPA. 2007. Total maximum daily loads for the Beaver Creek and Grand Lake St. Marys watershed. Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, Columbus.
  • Ohio Lake Erie Phosphorus Task Force. 2013. Ohio Lake Erie Phosphorus Task Force II final report. Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, Columbus.
  • Pearce, N.J.T., and A.G. Yates. 2017. Intra-annual variation of the association between agricultural best management practices and stream nutrient concentrations. Sci. Total Environ. 586:1124–1134. doi:10.1016/j. scitotenv.2017.02.102
  • Phillips, P.A., A.J. MacLean, F.R. Hore, F.J. Sowden, A.D. Tenant, and N.K. Patni. 1975. Soil water and crop effects of selected rates and times of dairy cattle liquid manure applications under continuous corn. Engineering Research Service Contribution 540. Agriculture Canada, Ottawa, ON.
  • Puckett, L.J. 1995. Identifying the major sources of nutrient water pollution. Environ. Sci. Technol. 29:408A–414A. doi:10.1021/es00009a743
  • R Core Team. 2016. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria. https://www.Rproject. org.
  • Richards, R.P., D.B. Baker, J.P. Crumrine, J.W. Kramer, D.E. Ewing, and B.J. Merryfield. 2008. Thirty-year trends in suspended sediment in seven Lake Erie tributaries. J. Environ. Qual. 37:1894–1908. doi:10.2134/jeq2007.0590
  • Russelle, M.P., M.H. Entz, and A.J. Franzluebbers. 2007. Reconsidering integrated crop–livestock systems in North America. Agron. J. 99:325–334. doi:10.2134/agronj2006.0139
  • Sharpley, A., H.P. Jarvie, A. Buda, L. May, B. Spears, and P. Kleinman. 2013. Phosphorus legacy: Overcoming the effects of past management practices to mitigate future water quality impairment. J. Environ. Qual. 42:1308– 1326. doi:10.2134/jeq2013.03.0098
  • Sibbesen, E., and A.N. Sharpley. 1997. Setting and justifying upper critical limits for phosphorus in soils. In: H. Tunney, et al., editors, Phosphorus loss from soil to water. Center for Agriculture and Biosciences Int., New York. p. 151–176.
  • Srinivasan, M.S., R.B. Bryant, M.P. Callahan, and J.L. Weld. 2006. Manure management and nutrient loss under winter conditions: A literature review. J. Soil Water Conserv. 61:200–209.
  • Stuntebeck, T.D., M.J. Komiskey, M.C. Peppler, D.W. Owens, and D.R. Frame. 2011. Precipitation–runoff relations and water-quality characteristics at edge-of-field stations, Discovery Farms and Pioneer Farm, Wisconsin, 2003-8. USGS Scientific Investigations Rep. 2011-5008. USGS, Reston, VA.
  • USDA. 2009. 2007 census of agriculture. USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service, Washington, DC. https://www.agcensus.usda.gov/ Publications/2007/.
  • USDA, 2014. 2012 census of agriculture. USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service, Washington, DC. https://agcensus.usda.gov/Publications/2012/.
  • USEPA. 2009. National lakes assessment: A collaborative survey of the nation's lakes. Office of Water and Office of Research and Development, USEPA. Washington, DC.
  • Vitosh, M.L., J.W. Johnson, and D.B. Mengel. 1995. Tri-state fertilizer recommendations for corn, soybeans, wheat, and alfalfa. Michigan State University Ext. Bull. E-2567. https://soil.msu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/ Tri-State-Fertilizer-Recs-E-2567.pdf (accessed June 2017).
  • Witzel, S.A., N. Minshall, M.S. Nichols, and J. Wilke. 1969. Surface runoff and nutrient losses of Fennimore watersheds. Trans. ASAE 12:338–341. doi:10.13031/2013.38837
  • Young, R.A., and C.K. Mutchler. 1976. Pollution potential of manure spread on frozen ground. J. Environ. Qual. 5:174–179. doi:10.2134/ jeq1976.00472425000500020013x
  • Zuur, A.F., E.N. Ieno, N.J. Walker, A.A. Saveiliev, and G.M. Smith. 2009. Mixed effects models and extensions in ecology with R. Springer, New York. doi:10.1007/978-0-387-87458-6