Published February 8, 2021 | Version v1

The Veil of ignorance Process Tracing (VPT) Methodology: Some Practical Considerations and Limitations (to Decoupling)

Authors/Creators

Description

With the introduction of their new approach to process tracing (PT), Copestake, Goertz, and Haggard seek to tackle what is arguably the most prevalent and most serious shortcoming in qualitative case study research: the “cherry-picking” of cases, data sources, or evidence to fit the claim or theory that the researcher is trying to substantiate. The authors should also be complimented for their attempt to make process tracing analyses “more rigorous and transparent” (this issue). By now, we have a variety of handbooks that offer high quality, hands-on advice on how to set up and conduct a process tracing analysis (see e.g., Beach and Pedersen 2019; Bennett and Checkel 2014). However, the term “process tracing” is still being stretched by scholars, who essentially provide us with a narrative reconstruction of a (causal) process. The question “how valid are my causal inferences compared to the inferences of others?” remains central to process tracing analyses. And we should welcome attempts to further develop the methodology of causal attribution, specifically for within-case analyses, in which we deal with one or a few instances of a cause-and-effect relationship.

Files

Smeets_VPT_QMMR_2020_18-2.pdf

Files (143.8 kB)

Name Size
md5:af18a990502eaad1bc1c4ccd02330c5a
143.8 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Related works

Is part of
2153-6767 (ISSN)