Published January 29, 2020 | Version v1

Life Cycle Cost (LCC) assessment of WADI technique

Authors/Creators

  • 1. CIRCE

Description

The objective of the present Life Cycle Cost (LCC) study is to perform a complementary evaluation to the environmental assessment of WADI technique. To do this, an environmental LCC approach has been applied. This methodology comprises the following kind of costs:

  • Investment costs (acquisition costs)
  • Operation costs
  • Maintenance costs
  • End-of-life costs
  • Externalities costs (environmental costs

The representativeness and accuracy of this study directly depends on the quantity and quality of the information provided by the involved partners. In order to stablish a LCC study as much realistic as possible, most of the WADI project partners were asked for data to perform this deliverable depending on their profile: costs of acquiring the equipment (AM, GG, ONERA,  NTGS), operation costs (AM, ONERA) and market estimations and detection efficiency (SGI, SST). Besides, some costs that were difficult to estimate, such as the end of life costs, were taken from specialized literature.

The content of this report is divided into two main section. In the first one, the LCC study itself is presented, differentiating between the costs associated with each of the techniques developed in the project: MAV and UAV. In the second part of this report, a simplified economic evaluation has been performed, considering not only the costs involved in the LCC study but also the incomes that could be obtained for a company running the WADI water leakage detection systems. In those studies, the expected annual profits and cash flows have been also estimated to evaluate the profitability of the investment by using some economic parameters such as the payback period, the NPV or the IRR.

In summary, LCC results indicate that the most significant costs are those relate to the operation activities (up to 82% of the total LCC for MAV and 97% for UAV). Most specifically, processing the information recorded during the flights is the costliest factor both for the MAV and UAV units. Regarding the investment costs, the plane acquisition cost (aircraft) is much greater than the cost of acquiring the remaining components of the MAV unit, whereas the purchase of the batteries is the main acquisition cost that be must be afforded during the life cycle of the UAV unit. Finally, the maintenance, end-of-life and environmental costs are significantly smaller in comparison to the rest of the cost categories.

Regarding the economic study, the profitability of both systems is clear. The payback period of the MAV system would be around 3 years with a service demand of 400 h/year, and the UAV unit payback would be lower than 1 year with an estimated demand of the service of 600 h/year.

The results and conclusions obtained in this deliverable represents a first step to evaluate the economic feasibility of the developed technologies. However, some of the considerations taken to perform this deliverable could change after performing a deeper market analysis and business plan (WP9) and then, results should be updated.

Files

Life cycle cost assessment of WADI technique.pdf

Files (899.8 kB)

Name Size
md5:079bcb4e646164a28f57fd2e5ddd8440
899.8 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Funding

European Commission
WADI - WADI 689239