Published November 5, 2019 | Version v1

(Re)Building Trust. Will visible Open Science Practices foster perceived integrity of journal articles?

  • 1. Department of School Education, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany,
  • 2. Department of Research Literacy and User-Friendly Research Support, Leibniz Institute for Psychology

Description

The Replication Crisis diminishes trust in empirical sciences and with it the perceived value of science (Lupia, 2018). Open Science Practices (i.e. open data, open analysis script, open materials) are an increasingly popular approach to deal with challenges in replication and to rebuilt trust (Geukes, Schönbrodt, Utesch, Geukes, & Back, 2016). Trusting the integrity of researchers is particularly significant within professions that include reflections on evidence-based actions, like in teaching (Cochran-Smith, 2009). First investigations could, however, deliver no evidence toward the effects of Open Science Practices (OSP) on trustworthiness (Wingen, Berkessel, & Englich, 2019). The study investigated the effect on a discipline level (psychology) with an abstract description of OSP. Within the ongoing discussion about incentives for OSP (e.g. badges), we want to shift the focus from discipline level to concrete individual journal articles and consider epistemic beliefs of readers to play a moderating role (Merk & Rosman, 2018): Will visible OSP (vs. not visible vs. visibly non-OSP) foster perceived trustworthiness when reading journal articles of empirical studies? Will multiplistic epistemic beliefs moderate the relationship between OSP and trustworthiness?

Files

04_OPINE_Schneider Merk Rosman.pdf

Files (60.4 kB)

Name Size
md5:d23e6bb2b53bd03aa32e03422383bdc5
60.4 kB Preview Download