Published November 18, 2026 | Version v1

Techno-economic evaluation report

Description

This report develops a bottom-up techno-economic assessment for full carbon capture and storage

(CCS) chains covering capture, conditioning, transport, and geological storage, applied to four

European regions: the Baltic Sea, the Black Sea (Ukraine and Romania), the North Sea and the Atlantic

coast of Portugal. The purpose of this work is to perform a techno-economic evaluation of the direct

injection of CO2 from a ship (DSI) when compared with its relevant alternatives; a dedicated pipeline

(PIPE-scenario) and conventional shipping with offloading at an offshore platform (SHIP).

DSI is currently at TRL 4–5; the strong parallels with established offshore oil and gas technologies

support its technical credibility, but the ship-to-subsea connection and intermittent-injection

performance still require demonstration.

 

The evaluation extends the TEA tool developed in the Horizon 2020 STRATEGY CCUS project, with a

dedicated direct-injection module, and reports costs as net present costs in 2030 euros (at a 5%

discount rate and over a maximum scenario timeframe of 35 years, 2031-2065), alongside energy use

and chain emissions. The results correspond to an AACE Class 4 feasibility-stage cost estimate with

expected accuracy of -30% to +50%.

 

Capture costs dominate the chain. In every region, capture accounts for the majority of costs and

energy use. Its share of discounted full-chain costs ranges from around 65% in the North Sea scenario

case, to nearly 90% in Portugal. Transport mode is therefore a second-order question at full-chain level:

the spread between the cheapest and most expensive transport configurations is generally within a

few percent of total costs. The decisive full-chain levers are the capture stage and the participation of

a few anchor emitters that underpin the economics of any shared network.

 

When a pipeline option is feasible, it is the lowest-cost option. In the three regions where a pipeline

was assessed, PIPE has the lowest cost for the transport and storage portion of the chain. In Romania,

the normalised transport-and-storage costs of DSI and SHIP are about 28% and 35% above PIPE,

respectively; in Portugal, DSI is about 54% higher in absolute transport and storage costs (55% per

tonne abated). Ukraine shows the same ranking, with DSI cheaper than SHIP but remaining above PIPE.

PIPE also has the lowest chain emissions and non-capture energy demand in the Ukrainian, Romanian

and Portuguese scenarios.

 

Conventional shipping and direct injection costs are often close, with a structural trade-off. DSI

removes the need for a fixed offshore platform (or equivalent on-land infrastructure for CO2

conditioning before injection), thereby saving substantial storage CAPEX. It reduces storage CAPEX by

about 47% relative to SHIP in the Baltic case and avoids several billion euros of fixed storage

infrastructure in the gigatonne-scale North Sea network. That saving is offset by higher transport costs

due to onboard reconditioning before injection, dynamic positioning and marine fuel consumption. In

the Baltic Sea, SHIP is about 6% cheaper for transport and storage, while DSI removes the platform,

delivers slightly higher net abatement and provides greater flexibility.

 

Carbon intensity of the electric energy use/grid decides outcome. Handling CO2 requires energy. In

the North Sea case, where the local grid is among the cleanest in Europe (30–80 gCO2e/kWh),

powering fixed injection from shore is far less carbon intensive than burning marine diesel onboard

(500–600 gCO2e/kWh for the same service). DSI is about 3% cheaper in absolute transport and storage

costs and costs per tonne stored, but its higher chain emissions make it more expensive per tonne

abated. The cluster analysis bears this out: small, local clusters favour DSI, whereas long-distance, high-volume port clusters favour conventional shipping. Decarbonised ship fuel or onboard capture would

strengthen DSI; gas-turbine-powered fixed injection would narrow the emissions difference.

 

Direct injection from a ship is technically credible and economically competitive with conventional

shipping wherever the sea is the only practical route to the storage facility. Its distinctive value lies in

the elimination of fixed offshore infrastructure, and the flexibility this gives to smaller or early mover

projects, rather than a headline cost advantage over pipeline. The strongest cases for DSI are dispersed

and modest volume emitters, regions without a pipeline viable option and possibly regions with

variable or shallow water depth. The weakest case for DSI is when considering gigatonne-scale

injection, long-haul chains served by long centralized pipelines, and when decarbonisation of ship fuel

is needed to keep DSI attractive per tonne of CO2 abated.

Files

D3.1 - Techno-economic evaluation report.pdf

Files (4.0 MB)

Name Size
md5:dffb1d573083513696ec8a7c0a7196ec
4.0 MB Preview Download