The Shuttle and Missile Objection to the Block Universe and Responses to Other Attempts at Refutation
Authors/Creators
Description
This working paper supplements Chapter 2 of Conceptual Foundations of a Theory of the Universe. It presents the shuttle and missile objection, a thought experiment that tests the physical interpretation of the postulate that the one-way speed of light is invariant.
As a shuttle changes velocity, its successive simultaneity slices can select a stage after the launch of a distant missile and then a stage before its launch or even its assembly. A numerical example illustrates this geometrical result. The paper then asks whether those slices determine which material states are physically present and, if so, how their succession can be reconciled with the missile’s actual trajectory.
The paper examines the main responses to the objection, including the block-universe interpretation, and sets out the author’s argument for absolute simultaneity.
English translation of version 1.1, dated 17 November 2026. Original French version on Zenodo.