Published November 14, 2026 | Version v1

Exploratory Tests of the Correction Freeze Problem: Professional Forecasters and Lake Mead

  • 1. ROR icon Phenikaa University
  • 2. Faculty of Nursing, Widya Mandala Surabaya Catholic University

Description

The Correction Freeze Problem (CFP) describes four routes by which beliefs can fail to correct while the world changes. This note records four further exploratory tests of Routes 1, 2 and 3 in two domains new to the authors. The rules of each test were written into a script and fingerprinted before the data were run. Two tests use the Survey of Professional Forecasters, in which economists forecast U.S. unemployment. Route 3 predicts that forecasters who are less sure of themselves lean more on the consensus. They lean less, and the prediction is falsified. Route 1 predicts that revisions follow the latest step of news rather than the drift accumulated since the last revision. This is also falsified, although forecasters revise so often that the two are hard to separate. Two tests use U.S. Google searches for “Lake Mead” against the lake’s monthly water level from 2004 to 2026. Route 1 is falsified again: attention follows the accumulated decline, not the latest monthly drop. Route 2 is supported at all three thresholds tested. Searches do not respond to the water level above the official shortage line of 1,075 feet and rise by about 2.5% per foot below it. This support rests mainly on the low of 2022 to 2023. Route 2 has now passed twice, each time on one salient episode, while the readings of Routes 1 and 3 tested here have failed.

Files

CFP_SPF_LakeMead.pdf

Files (515.3 kB)

Name Size
md5:84f29a96e2e499ca4c7f08a4f4347c18
515.3 kB Preview Download