The Zero–Equity Identity: Monetary Claims, Settlement, and Equity
Authors/Creators
Description
Version 2.0.0 — Conceptual and Structural Refinements
This version reconceptualises the Monetary Authority's administrative role, eliminating the need to exclude it from the economic agent domain. It replaces the Monetary Settlement Relation with the Monetary Claim as the primitive monetary relation, and explicitly identifies true financial equity with financial wealth. The Settlement Identity is renamed as Reinach's Identity. The logical development has been streamlined. The distinction between financial wealth and conventional sectoral accounting balances has also been sharpened. The central mathematical result remains unchanged.
Abstract
The financial wealth of an agent set cannot, in general, be identified with its accounting position. This paper examines the distinction by interpreting financial wealth as a net claim for economic resources, formally represented by true financial equity and determined by monetary claims and their correlative obligations. Drawing on Reinach's analysis of claims and obligations, the paper treats a monetary claim for resources as one pole of a relation necessarily carrying a correlative obligation to supply resources. Correlativity and exhaustiveness establish Reinach's Identity: aggregate monetary claims for resources equal their correlative obligations over an exhaustive economic agent domain. Applying this result to fiat, Thornton's Obligation attributes the corresponding resource obligation to the composed economic agent domain. Reinach's Identity establishes that aggregate true financial equity has no independent degree of freedom, yielding the Zero--Equity Identity,
\[
\boxed{E_{\mathcal A}^{*}\equiv 0.}
\]
The Monetary Authority's liability position is accordingly interpreted as an administrative representation of the composed economic agent domain, rather than an independent source of economic obligation.
The identity is structural rather than empirical. Individual true financial equity positions may be unknown, imperfectly measured, or differently represented under alternative accounting conventions, while their aggregate remains determined exactly by the underlying relational structure. Balance-sheet equity and true financial equity must therefore be distinguished: accounting records may accurately represent a particular accounting convention without explicitly attributing the correlative obligations implied by monetary claims.
The result clarifies the nature of financial wealth and provides a settlement-layer constraint on monetary analysis that is invariant to institutional form and accounting representation.
Files
zero-equity-identity-v2.0.1.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- Is derived from
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.22037465 (DOI)