Published November 12, 2026 | Version v1

Route 4 of the Correction Freeze Problem in a household panel: an exploratory test on the New York Fed Survey of Consumer Expectations

Authors/Creators

  • 1. ROR icon Phenikaa University

Description

Route 4 of the Correction Freeze Problem (CFP), the information limit, states that no detector can identify a change more accurately than the information in its observations allows. In earlier tests on aggregate data, expectations followed large and salient price changes and ignored slow trends, and observed accuracy stayed below the computed ceiling. This note asks whether the same holds for individuals. Using 152,768 pairs of consecutive monthly answers from the New York Fed Survey of Consumer Expectations (June 2013 to January 2026), we scored each revision of the one-year inflation forecast by whether it moved in the same direction as the national gasoline price that month. Observed accuracy never exceeded the information ceiling, in any band of signal strength, in either numeracy group, or for the slow trend in consumer prices, so the hard prediction of Route 4 held throughout. It held with an enormous margin to spare, though, because individual revisions were close to a coin flip at every signal strength: for gasoline moves of 10% or more, where the ceiling is 0.97 to 0.99, only 53% of revisions moved in the same direction. Accuracy barely rose with the strength of the signal, and high-numeracy respondents were no more accurate than others. The survey’s monthly median, by contrast, moved with gasoline every time it changed during a large event. Two conclusions follow. The ceiling computed from price noise alone is far too loose to constrain individual answers, so this design had little power to falsify Route 4.

Files

R4_SCE.pdf

Files (621.0 kB)

Name Size
md5:559025de18a0f2972e4f2f3df2780a0d
621.0 kB Preview Download