Published September 20, 2021 | Version v1
Other Open

The Principles of Unceded Intelligence: Capability Without Ceding Control

Authors/Creators

  • 1. Independent Researcher, Singapore

Description

The Principles of Unceded Intelligence: Capability Without Ceding Control develops Herbert R. Sim’s proposed framework for intelligent assistance that expands human capability while preserving legitimate human authority.

The paper examines seven connected principles:

  • Explicit authorization

  • Bounded scope

  • Meaningful understanding

  • Contestability

  • Revocation

  • Practical independence

  • Respect for other people’s rights

Through conceptual analysis and engagement with relevant scholarship, it explains why technical access, predicted preferences and successful performance do not independently authorize a system to expand its mandate. It distinguishes operational autonomy from legitimate authority and examines the practical conditions needed to challenge, redirect or replace assistance.

A hypothetical conference travel coordination case illustrates how the principles apply to permissions, confidential information, commercial incentives, delegated tasks, pending commitments and continuity after withdrawal. The discussion also addresses efficiency, human error, accessibility and unequal access to alternatives.

This expanded conceptual working paper includes scholarly references, objections, limitations and a research agenda. It proposes normative conditions for legitimate delegation rather than an empirically validated assessment instrument. It has not been peer reviewed.

Files

Unceded_Intelligence_Principles_Zenodo.pdf

Files (1.6 MB)

Name Size
md5:10db4fd31cafb7b245ad47a5feb1e811
1.6 MB Preview Download