The Democratisation Process and Promises: Electoralism, Democrazy, and the Crisis of Democratic Delivery in Africa
Authors/Creators
Description
Abstract
The early 2020s witnessed an unexpected resurgence of military coups across Africa, shattering the optimism that had accompanied the continent's "third wave" of democratisation. This article argues that the crisis confronting Africa is not, at bottom, a crisis of democracy as an ideal, but a crisis of the narrow electoralist model that has dominated the continent since the 1990s. The analysis draws on two critical frameworks: Claude Ake's argument that African democracy has been reduced to a formal, procedural exercise detached from the developmental question of whether it actually improves ordinary people's lives, and Issa G. Shivji's critique of "compradorial democracy", in which local elites use the rituals of democratic competition to legitimise their rule while perpetuating neocolonial economic dependency. Applying these frameworks to five countries that experienced coups between 2020 and 2023, namely Mali, Guinea, Burkina Faso, Niger, and Gabon, the article uncovers a striking paradox: although most Africans still want democracy (66% say they prefer it to any other form of government), very few are satisfied with how it actually works in practice (only 37%). To capture this gap between promise and delivery, the article introduces the concept of "democrazy", a system that retains the outward forms of democracy while failing, often absurdly, to deliver its substance. After setting out the study's problem, objectives, and methodology, the article reviews the relevant literature, works through the five cases using thematic analysis and process tracing, and concludes that democratic consolidation in Africa will require moving beyond electoral formalism toward a people-centred, developmental model of democracy suited to the continent's own socio-economic realities.
Keywords: Democratisation, Electoralism, Democrazy, Compradorial Democracy, Military Coups, Africa, Governance