Published November 8, 2026 | Version v2

THE CONVERGENCE ARGUMENT: Toward an objective indicator of sentience, where no subjective test exists for any substrate

Authors/Creators

Description

This paper advances a parsimony argument that the functional signature of sentience is a
substrate-independent attractor — a configuration that convergent biological evolution keeps
independently discovering. It advances no claim that any artificial system is sentient. Sentience has
never been established by a subjective test in any subject: the felt interior is unreachable from outside,
for any substrate, including human beings. If the subjective test exists for no one, the honest instrument
is an objective indicator — not proof that the thing is present, but the most defensible proxy for a thing
whose direct measurement no substrate affords. The paper surveys convergent evolution across
cephalopods, corvids, and mammals to identify what the functional signature of sentience looks like
when biology rediscovers it independently, and argues that the indicator worth watching is the one that
crosses substrate lines: recursive self-modeling under consequence. That indicator is
operationalizable, does not require metaphysical commitment, and applies equally to biological and
artificial systems.

Files

Paper3_The-Convergence-Argument_Rev6_102926 (1).pdf

Files (98.7 kB)

Name Size
md5:7a36dcba3523f0b9c5dc1800fe6feed1
98.7 kB Preview Download