From Ontological Viability to Governance Assurance: A Documented Case of Scientific Evaluation, Referent Continuity, and Institutional Closure
Authors/Creators
Description
This public case study documents the scientific evaluation and subsequent governance proceedings surrounding a theoretical manuscript submitted by independent researcher Gustavo Paulino to the Journal of Management Studies (JMS), between April and October 2026.
The original manuscript, Beyond Identity and Organizationality: Viability as a Distinct Ontological Problem in Organization Theory, proposed the Ontology of Viability as a distinct theoretical approach to understanding the necessary conditions for the persistence of organized existence. It distinguished organizational properties—such as identity, legitimacy, and performance—from the conditions necessary for an organization to continue existing as an organization over time.
The manuscript underwent external peer review by three specialists and was rejected following substantive scientific criticism. Subsequent reconsideration and formal complaint procedures raised a narrower analytical question: whether the original ontological proposition had been examined at its intended level, or whether adjacent explanations of organizational properties had been treated as equivalent to the proposed conditions of organizational viability.
The matter was subsequently referred to the Society for the Advancement of Management Studies (SAMS). In October 2026, the society's Council Chair communicated its assessment of procedural compliance, clarified the boundaries of editorial independence and institutional governance, and formally closed the complaint.
The case distinguishes institutional procedural compliance from the question of whether a specific allegation concerning the continuity of the analytical referent received an identifiable, reasoned determination in the communications provided to the author.
From this investigation emerged a governance framework derived from the Ontology of Viability, structured around six elements:
Object → Function → Input → Examination → Finding → Conclusion
This framework provides a systematic approach to examining whether an institutional function has addressed its intended object and whether its communicated conclusion can be traced to an identifiable examination and finding.
Based on thirteen primary documentary records, the study reconstructs the chronology, scientific arguments, institutional responses, and resulting governance questions.
Individual identities are protected through the omission of personal names and contact details, and institutional communications are presented through faithful paraphrases rather than reproduced as confidential correspondence.
The study does not establish scientific validation of the original theory, editorial misconduct, or institutional wrongdoing. It documents the distinction between an editorial decision, procedural assurance, and the evidentiary requirements for determining whether a particular question was examined.
The case is made publicly available to support independent scholarly scrutiny, methodological discussion, and further research into organizational viability, scientific evaluation, and institutional governance.