Axiom Dynamics 5: Transition Replay Verdict—Historical Taint, Bleach Impossibility, and Conservation Transmission
Authors/Creators
Description
The object of a replay verdict is history, not the terminal state. This pa
per establishes a segment-by-segment dual-scale replay protocol on a finite Horn
fragment, taking the initially pre-registered protected core Core0 as the sole final
instance breach core, and taking archive monotonicity, final-column priority, and
the dual-reporting obligation as protocol constraints. The segment-by-segment ver
dict is mechanically given by the legality scale and the timing scale: the legality
scale precedes the timing scale, and a nonempty final-instance newly added breach
is illegal; the timing scale uses the zero boundary of the total-ledger difference,
with net benefit greater than zero as timely and equal to zero or less than zero
as untimely. Under this protocol three structural conclusions are proved. First,
conservation transmission: if the starting Core0 is contained in the initial theorem
set and the final-instance newly added breach of each segment is empty, then the
terminal Core0 is still contained in the theorem set; the induction step uses only
the emptiness of the newly added breach and does not depend on gain conditions
or the sign of net benefit. Second, re-deliberation rupture manifests as caliber sep
aration: core re-deliberation can occur and generate parallel readings, but the final
column still judges by Core0; a drift chain can be segment-by-segment legal under
the parallel caliber, while under the final caliber speculative segments appear, and
the full-history drift amount is the loss set of original core members. Third, the
historicity of verdict and bleach impossibility: there exist two histories whose end
points are pointwise identical in rule set, theorem set, depth ledger, and total ledger,
while one is a clean history and the other contains speculative segments and inher
ited breaches; under fixed Core0, archive monotonicity, and final-column priority,
subsequent batch sequences can only add archive entries and cannot delete existing
tainted segments and inherited breach entries, so a tainted history cannot be rewrit
ten as a clean history. Verdict-core fixation and final arbitration are a temporary
protocol closure before a theory of re-deliberation legitimacy is established: they
prohibit re-deliberation from writing back into past segments, but do not evaluate
which re-deliberations are substantively legitimate. This closure is not a replace
ment for open problems, but an operational constraint during the open period to
prevent historical responsibility from being retrospectively rewritten. The mechan
ical recomputability of the replay verdict presupposes closure of the pre-registered
list and archive discipline; non-Horn generalization, multi-candidate joint verdicts,
and the completeness of real historical archives remain open boundaries.