TIC 38699429: an unconfirmed transit candidate around a faint nearby M dwarf, from a hash-registered search of public TESS-SPOC light curves
Description
Version 3 (26 October 2026): adds an automated flux-level vetting with LEO-Vetter, a remark on the missing TOI and corrections (author statement, description of the reproduction); no analysis number of Version 2 changed (Version 2: 10.5281/zenodo.23642367).
We report an unconfirmed transit candidate on TIC 38699429 (Gaia DR3 4676612253064169344; Tmag 15.27, Teff about 2914 K, d about 57 pc), a faint nearby M dwarf with 31 TESS-SPOC full-frame light curves (Sectors 1-69) and no 2-min data. The signal has P = 11.718179 d, a depth of 24621 +/- 893 ppm in the frozen template (about 2.5 %) and a measured duration of about 1.4 h. It was the only survivor of a hash-registered coherent multi-sector search of 400 M dwarfs without 2-min data; the threshold comes from 110 control stars and 331 scrambled runs (at most 0.05 expected false positives for the noise in the scrambled data). The ephemeris was written to file before Sectors >= 86 were looked at (its hash was recorded in a hash file only afterwards), and the signal is recovered there (z = 10.8, 17 events). A reproduction (blind only for the periodogram) and a counter-evidence analysis, both by AI instances of the same model family using the same photons, find the signal real, strictly periodic and located on or near the target within a few arcseconds. The candidate is not validated: TRICERATOPS gives FPP 0.19 and NFPP 0.16, the pixel position test is only moderately discriminating (p = 0.087) and shows the best position 5.7 arcsec from the Gaia position, and a bound faint companion, an unresolved background eclipsing binary and a twin eclipsing binary at twice the period are not excluded. The radius of about 2.8 Earth radii holds only if the signal is on a single star. The signal is also not new to the SPOC pipeline: a multi-sector SPOC data-validation report with a consistent period has been public since 14 September 2024, although the star is not a TOI or CTOI as of 25 October 2026; no claim of first detection is made. The analysis was AI-assisted (Claude, Anthropic); the author checked all figures, data sources and analyses, ran the (AI-written) scripts in his own Python environment and verified the results (statement of the author, 25 October 2026); the reviewers are AI instances, not independent human replications.
What changed in this version (Version 3, 26 October 2026):
- New section 10, "Automated vetting (LEO-Vetter, added 26 October 2026)": LEO-Vetter 1.2.0 (default thresholds), flux level only, run at the fixed in-sample ephemeris with two box durations (1.0 h and 1.4 h). No false-alarm test (13) and no false-positive test (4) flags the signal in either run (MES 28.13 and 27.42, 60 transits); every test is listed with its value and limit. The metric "mean chases" (0.558 and 0.570) is below its limit of 0.78, but the test is not applied for more than 5 transits. Limits stated in the text: the ephemeris is fixed and in-sample, only the flux level was run (the pixel-level tests were not), and passing the tests is not a validation; the signal remains an unconfirmed candidate.
- Statement of AI use corrected: Version 2 stated that the author had also recomputed the values and figures in separate Python code of his own; this is withdrawn. His statement is that he checked all figures, data sources and analyses, ran the (AI-written) scripts in his own Python environment and verified the results. Added: the LEO-Vetter run of version 3 was executed by an AI instance and has not yet been re-run by the author (his verification protocol will follow), and the edits and corrections of version 3 were also made by AI instances.
- The reproduction is no longer called "blind" without qualification: the ephemeris/approximate period was in its instructions, only its periodogram and folding were blind (abstract, Sect. 1, title of Sect. 6, Table 2).
- Section 9 (novelty status): the missing TOI is discussed with verifiable facts only: the star (T = 15.27) is fainter than the limit of the Quick-Look Pipeline light curves (T <= 13.5) and a SPOC TCE exists; the missing TOI does not by itself imply a negative vetting verdict, and the reason is not known.
- Section 1: a wrong back-reference to Version 1 corrected (Version 1 used the term "pre-registered").
- References: Kunimoto et al. 2025 (LEO-Vetter) with journal and DOI; the sister notes cited by their concept DOIs and current titles. Data and code availability: DOI sentence updated for Version 3.
- Supplementary archive: new folder replikation_leo/ (script, inputs, SHA-256 list, JSON results, logs of the LEO-Vetter runs); paper sources updated; a text copy of a published paper that contained a third-party e-mail address was removed.
Files
TIC38699429_preprint_v3.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- Cites
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.23538454 (DOI)
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.23599358 (DOI)
- Dataset: 10.17909/t9-wpz1-8s54 (DOI)
- Is new version of
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.23642367 (DOI)