Published October 25, 2026 | Version v1

Comparative surround recording 2007

Authors/Creators

  • 1. ROR icon Université du Québec à Montréal

Description

On October 14, 2007, an organ recital by Robert Sigmund, featuring tenor Hugues St-Gelais, was recorded in the chapel of the Grand Séminaire de Montréal with three surround microphone systems mounted on the same stand: a SoundField ST350 (tetrahedral array), a native B-Format assembly of AKG Blue Line microphones (one omnidirectional and two figure-8) and a Zoom H2 portable recorder (four cardioid capsules). The recording was made during a surround sound production workshop held at OBORO, Montreal, in September and October 2007. The question was how three systems at very different price points compare in timbre quality and directional encoding.

The same performance is presented for each system in three formats. It contains three excerpts from the Livre d’orgue de Montréal: Voix humaine, Trio and Dialogue.

- Ambisonic B-Format, first order, FuMa: st350_b-format_fuma.flac (WXYZ, the four original channels), akg_b-format_fuma.flac (WXY, the three original channels) and h2_b-format_fuma.flac (the H2 quad transcoded to horizontal B-Format, WXY).
- Quad, L, R, Ls, Rs (90° front pair, 120° rear pair, as on the Zoom H2): st350_quad.flac and akg_quad.flac (B-Format decoded to quad) and h2_quad.flac (the four original channels).
- Stereo: st350_stereo.flac, akg_stereo.flac and h2_stereo.flac, decoded from B-Format (110° width, 0.75 hypercardioid virtual microphones).

Apart from the spatial processing listed above (B2G plug-in for the quad decoding, Quad2B for the H2 transcoding, B2Stereo for the stereo decoding), no other processing was applied: no EQ, no compression. The B-Format RMS levels of the AKG assembly and the Zoom H2 were matched to those of the ST350 on a sustained organ chord (5-second RMS window). The output levels were then matched by ear and are within 2 dB of each other.

9 FLAC files, 24-bit, 48 kHz, 5 min 27 s each.

Full report, with the description of the setup and a photo journal: https://courville.uqam.ca/ambisonic/comparative_recording.html

Thanks to Robert Sigmund and Yves G. Préfontaine for allowing the recording of the recital.

Files

akg_b-format_fuma.flac

Files (745.4 MB)

Name Size
md5:a55403a9adee155baaefd082e050337a
79.0 MB Preview Download
md5:a89b19f9fcce855ae2b7b999db4bd58f
103.6 MB Preview Download
md5:9cb1911972b8f155bda215a4244acdfe
52.3 MB Preview Download
md5:2127af5f539579b3696c7a798f9b2e9e
79.9 MB Preview Download
md5:4f39199c6579676b7dbb82f1083f786e
106.9 MB Preview Download
md5:77dbdaf032aa03e39a65be76a497f48f
54.1 MB Preview Download
md5:8bdb556d2c2c0ece2dcc8702b52f99b8
109.0 MB Preview Download
md5:bd61e28de80a2ab103c0cc5d174bb1ad
106.7 MB Preview Download
md5:fb01f0697d88f7711d89a4d1dedd050d
54.0 MB Preview Download

Additional details

Dates

Created
2007-10-14