Published October 25, 2026 | Version v1

Explaining Physical Coupling: Reciprocal Closure and the Limits of Response Reconstruction

  • 1. ROR icon Islamic Azad University of Tabriz

Description

A physical model may reproduce the observable behavior of an interaction without explaining the physical organization that realizes it or the origin of its characteristics. This raises a question about the scope and adequacy of physical explanation: what does successful response reconstruction explain about an interaction, and what remains unexplained? This article develops a framework for assessing the explanatory content of interaction models by distinguishing three achievements: recovering the response, identifying the physical organization that realizes it, and explaining the origin of the channel’s characteristics from independent premises. An ‘interaction profile’ specifies the features to be explained, while ‘reciprocal closure’ assesses the consistency of mutual dependencies and backreaction within a shared dynamical problem. The methodological contribution connects a criterion for response recovery with an assessment of the origin of interaction characteristics. Examples from several physical systems show that preserving the response alone neither uniquely identifies the realizing organization nor explains the origin of the channel’s coefficients and features. Applying the framework to entropic gravity, we distinguish the premises responsible for the form of the force law, interaction strength, and universality of acceleration. In particular, additivity of mass and entropy change alone does not ensure a common ratio of entropy sensitivity to inertial mass. The analysis provides a way to identify an explanation’s achievements, isolate its remaining independent assumptions, and specify conditions for progress in explaining the origin of physical interactions.

Files

Sub_Couplability.pdf

Files (679.4 kB)

Name Size
md5:0c95e1b081b9f77429428e606e5e2189
679.4 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Dates

Submitted
2026-10-25