Published October 17, 2026
| Version v1
Other
Open
Five corrections were made. None stuck.
Authors/Creators
Description
A short, first-hand sort of why a correction fails to propagate, drawn from five present-tense cases (Macchiarini, GFAJ-1, Wakefield, Stapel, Mbeki) plus one counter-case (OPERA). Top line: a fix fails when it corrects the record, but the wrong thing was never living in the record anymore. The five mechanisms name where the thing had already moved: irreversibility, decoupling, motivated retransmission, load-bearing, held. Cross-cutting factor, not a mechanism: latency. Refinement from the counter-case: propagation tracks whether the reason-holder also owns the correction.