Published October 12, 2026 | Version 1.0

A Robinson counterexample to ideal-only tangency certificates

Authors/Creators

  • 1. Independent researcher

Description

The classical Robinson sextic is globally nonnegative, but adding any nonnegative constant does not make it a finite sum of real polynomial squares modulo even the full ideal of polynomials vanishing on its real tangency variety. This refutes both the exact ordinary-radical certificate and the every-positive-epsilon original-ideal certificate proposed in the unrestricted tangency-minor formulation of Schweighofer's 2007 question. The same zero-line and coordinate-axis obstruction refutes the separate-cross-product reading printed in the report. Arbitrarily many summands of arbitrary degree are allowed. The attained example is within the unrestricted question; a separate nonattaining diagnostic concerns only the literal-product reading and uses a constant shift of the standard example in Schweighofer (2006), Section 1.6, equation (6). The standard sphere-minimization mechanism retains its attribution to Laurent's updated manuscript dated 6 February 2010, Section 7.2.3, Lemma 7.21, manuscript pages 117-118 (https://homepages.cwi.nl/~monique/files/moment-ima-update-new.pdf). The earlier 2009 published chapter has a different Lemma 7.21; its DOI is bibliographic context, not the tangency locator. Robinson's form and classical zero-set ingredients retain their attribution. The identical ten-zero cubic obstruction is explicitly credited to Reznick (2000), Section 4(b), printed page 259, authenticated in the author-hosted publisher reprint. Complete 2008 and 2009 Ha-Pham article texts were not obtained; truncated-certificate comparisons rely on later primary statements and the access gaps remain disclosed. The 66-record citation graph is a metadata screen with marked primary-text follow-ups. No author-approved formula correction, first bibliographic priority or continued open status through 2026 is asserted.

This unrefereed research note is accompanied by its unchanged historical candidate, reproducible exact-algebra checks, fresh independent adversarial proof/computational/source reviews, and a bounded priority audit. AI tools were used extensively in development, verification, adversarial review and writing. Independent AI-assisted review is not independent human or journal peer review; the note has received neither. Finite controls supplement the universal mathematical proof and are not formal proof-assistant certification or numerical SOS-degree-cutoff evidence.

Files

robinson-tangency-certificates-v1.0.pdf

Files (252.7 kB)

Name Size
md5:de41f1c1ca4203154b65f03695ae57f3
65.8 kB Preview Download
md5:2134ecad888c7d78412529cc70b1470b
186.9 kB Preview Download

Additional details

References

  • Markus Schweighofer, Gradient tentacles and sums of squares, Oberwolfach Report 14/2007, pp.810ff., Conjecture 2 p.811, DOI 10.4171/owr/2007/14.
  • Bruce Reznick, Hilbert's construction of psd polynomials that are not a sum of squares, Oberwolfach Report 14/2007, pp.797-799, Robinson form p.798 equation (2), DOI 10.4171/owr/2007/14.
  • Markus Schweighofer, Global optimization of polynomials using gradient tentacles and sums of squares, SIAM J. Optim. 17(3) (2006),920-942, DOI 10.1137/050647098.
  • Ha Huy Vui and Pham Tien Son, Global optimization of polynomials using the truncated tangency variety and sums of squares, SIAM J. Optim. 19(2) (2008),941-951, DOI 10.1137/080719212.
  • Feng Guo, Mohab Safey El Din and Lihong Zhi, Global optimization of polynomials using generalized critical values and sums of squares, ISSAC 2010, author manuscript https://perso.lip6.fr/Mohab.Safey/Articles/gcv_sos.pdf.
  • Bruce Reznick, Some concrete aspects of Hilbert's 17th problem, Contemporary Mathematics 253 (2000), 251-272, DOI 10.1090/conm/253/03936; Section 4(b), printed p.259. Author-hosted publisher reprint https://reznick.web.illinois.edu/Paper34.pdf.
  • Monique Laurent, Sums of squares, moment matrices and optimization over polynomials, updated manuscript, 6 February 2010, Section 7.2.3, Lemma 7.21, manuscript pp.117-118, https://homepages.cwi.nl/~monique/files/moment-ima-update-new.pdf. Earlier published chapter in Emerging Applications of Algebraic Geometry, IMA Volumes 149, Springer (2009),157-270, DOI 10.1007/978-0-387-09686-5_7; that published Lemma 7.21 is not the cited tangency lemma.