時間変数を物理法則の前提から帰結へ移す: 局所比較による時間成立の完全記述と破綻分類の一般理論
Description
Moving the Time Variable from a Premise of Physical Law to a Consequence: A General Theory of the Complete Description of Time Establishment through Local Comparison and Failure Classification
時間参照の局所比較理論(Local-comparison theory of time reference; LCTR)は、非時間的な物理入力だけから物理時間を最後まで構成した、人類史上初の理論であると主張する。 その構成のどの段階でも、まだ生成していない時間量や時間的関係を前提として導入しない。
The local-comparison theory of time reference (LCTR) claims to be the first theory in human history to construct physical time from start to finish using only nontemporal physical inputs. At no stage does the construction presuppose temporal quantities or relations that it has not yet generated.
日本語要旨(原典)
時間参照の局所比較理論(LCTR)は、物理法則に現れる時間変数を、法則記述の原始前提から、理論内部で物理的成立根拠を生成した後に使用できる表現へ移す。本稿が変更する対象は、時間変数を法則へ投入する以前に、その成立根拠と使用資格を構成しなければならないという、理論物理が法則を記述する際の前提順序である。
その理論構造は、計算機科学の型、依存、状態および変更影響に関する設計原理を、物理時間の生成、使用資格、失効局在化および下流再生成を規定する数理構造として統合する。
この構成は、装置や対象に生じた局所的な表示と状態差を記録として保持し、比較に必要な情報がどこで結び付くかを、時間量を用いずに確定するところから始まる。そこから比較結果の統合と順序、運動記述と時間表現、法則内で使用できる時間変数の構成へ進む。連続近似の有効域と微分形式についても、それぞれの成立条件を定める。時間変数の使用は、当該使用に至る生成依存上の成立条件が満たされる場合にのみ許される。LCTRは、この生成によって時間内容の同一性、前後関係、比較可能性と比較不能性、線形順序および実数値表現の成立条件を順に与え、時間構造の成立と時間座標の選択を分離する。この構成により、LCTRは物理時間を語義ではなく成立条件によって構成的に定義する。
生成過程の条件が満たされない場合、本稿の監査は、生成依存上で最初に失われた条件を特定し、その位置に不成立を局在化する。そのうえで、時間変数の成立域、最初の失効位置の集合、近似尺度の境界情報、失効原因、および構造上の負担を返す。これにより、連続近似と微分形式について、使用できる範囲、失効する位置と理由、および修復して再生成または再計算すべき対象を、一つの依存順序に沿って示す。したがって、この監査は連続と微分に対し、使用条件と失効原因を伴う条件付きの動作保証を与える。LCTRは、古典的連続時間の成立上の位置を、法則記述の原始前提から、物理的成立条件と最大有効域をもつ生成済み近似表現へ変更する。
この監査は、形式的な理論条件と物理的実現条件の双方を監査対象とする。理論条件と工学条件を異なる種類の条件として区別したまま、物理担体、記録、通信、有限分解能および証拠の来歴を一つの監査上の依存関係へ接続し、物理的実現と使用可能範囲の提示までを理論の成立責任に含める。複数対象を同一の時間表現上で記述し、同時刻判定、同期および共通時間表現を使用する資格は、各対象の物理担体、記録、情報結合、通信および多対象関係が成立する領域で得られ、遠隔または大域的な構成では輸送と貼り合わせの整合条件をさらに要する。
本稿では、時間内容を非時間的物理入力から成立させる完全な生成経路を欠いたまま、その時間内容を法則の演算または成果の導出へ投入することを原始時間入力と呼ぶ。数学的一貫性、予測性能および経験的適合は、原始時間入力に欠落している生成経路を補わない。測定、予測、模型適合または計算の成功が直接支持する範囲を証拠効力域と定める。成果を別の対象、述語、証拠の型、成立条件または適用域へ移す主張は、その証拠効力域を越える。
この基準により、古代から現代までの理論、実験、計量標準および工学にまたがる代表的72資料を監査した。その全てに原始時間入力とそれに依存する成果があった。使用する時間内容の全体を非時間的な物理入力から生成した資料は一件もなかった。生成過程の一部に相当する物理的関係を備えた資料でも、使用する時間内容全体の生成には到達しておらず、原始時間入力とそれに依存する成果が残る。この全件一致は、原始時間入力が特定の時代や分野に限られず、物理学の歴史を通じて反復してきたことを示す。
原始時間入力を含む現行の理論記述は、物理時間成立資格を満たさない。したがって、現代物理学は現在の時間変数使用のままでは成立しない。原始時間入力が使用に必要な条件を背景化し、独立証拠が同じ条件の実失効と下流成果への依存到達を確定する場合、その成果自体も当該評価領域で使用資格を失い、修復後の再生成または再計算を要する。一方、既存の数学的、実験的、工学的成果と物理関係は証拠効力域内で保持され、時間内容とその成立根拠を生成し、成立域と失効位置を監査した範囲で安全に再使用できる。時間次元を含むか、時間を用いて定義される物理量についても、物理関係の保持と時間依存表現の使用資格を分離し、後者を時間生成後の成立域で定める。
原始時間前提の資格失効、既存成果の保持および安全な再使用を統合する成果保存的再基礎化は、外部時間の除去と物理時間の生成を、別の責務として区別する。記録、比較、対象状態の差異および観測者側での情報結合から、法則内で使用できる時間を生成する。時間順序の生成と因果順序の構成は別の責務であり、因果順序の成立から時計尺度、時間間隔または法則時間の成立は導かれない。この生成順序は、周期、振動数およびHzを生成後の計量成果として定め、ローレンツ変換の作用対象を生成済み時間表現と空間表示として確定し、局所固有時と大域法則時間を別の成立段階へ分離する。量子重力の時間問題を法則時間の使用資格の問題へ変更し、時間の矢を生成済み時間表現への後続の向きづけ条件として定め、時間の創出、創発、回復および非存在に、生成経路または代替構造と全時間内容・後続成果からの原始時間依存排除を証明する責務を課す。その生成依存上で、従来別個の時間問題として論じられてきた各問題を、異なる失効位置へ配置する。これにより、古典物理から相対論、計量・工学、量子重力・宇宙論までを、時間を成立させるための負担、有効域および失効位置という共通の軸で比較できる。
この共通の軸のもとで形式証拠と言明証拠を照合すると、相対論の時間伸縮説には二段階の誤認が認められる。第一段階では、物理的成立根拠が生成されていない時間を、時計、振動子、信号、記録などの物理担体から独立した「時間そのもの」として法則に先行させる。第二段階では、重力や運動に応答した物理担体上の比較差を、その「時間そのもの」の伸縮へ帰属させる。また、時間の不存在を述べる言明と時間そのものへの属性付与が同じ説明体系に併置される場合、両者が同一の時間内容型と適用域を対象とすれば両立せず、異なる対象または適用域を対象とすればその切替の明示を要する。時計指示差、時計率差、固有時差、座標差その他の関係量への切替から、物理担体と独立した「時間そのもの」の属性変化は導かれない。さらに、その時間属性を生命過程へ移し、物理担体についての実験成果の効力を生命過程の直接実証へ拡張する連鎖は、生命適用を伴う三段階誤認をなす。より一般には、限定された計算、予測、模型適合または実験の成功が、数式全体の物理的成立、未生成時間の資格、未測定対象への適用、時間に関する存在論的主張へ移される、同じ構造の越境が複数分野で反復している。本稿はこれを限定成果の無制限継承として特定する。成果の効力は、その成果が直接支持する対象、述語、証拠の型、成立条件および適用域に限定される。
現代物理学が時間に関する独立した謎としてきた問題のうち、未生成時間への依存を成立条件とするものを考える。生成済みの物理関係と未生成の「時間そのもの」への属性帰属を区別し、時間を物理的に生成すると、その成立条件は除去される。その結果、これらの謎はすべて独立した問題としての成立根拠を失い、消滅する。その後に残る課題は、生成済み時間表現の成立条件、有効域、最初の失効位置、破綻分類、修復順序および次に取得すべき証拠の確定である。物理法則で時間変数を使うには、その時間内容と物理的成立根拠を法則使用に先立って生成しなければならない。物理法則の時間変数は原始前提では成立しない。
English abstract (translation)
The local-comparison theory of time reference (LCTR) transfers the time variable appearing in physical laws from a primitive premise of law description to a representation that can be used after its physical grounds have been generated within the theory. What this paper changes is the order of presupposition governing how theoretical physics states its laws: before a time variable is entered into a law, its grounds and qualification for use must be constructed.
Its theoretical structure integrates the design principles of computer science concerning types, dependencies, states, and change effects as a mathematical structure that specifies the generation of physical time, qualification for use, invalidation localization, and downstream regeneration.
The construction begins by retaining, as records, local differences in indications and states arising in apparatuses and objects, and by determining, without temporal quantities, where the information required for comparison is joined. It then proceeds through the integration and ordering of comparison results and through dynamical description and time representation to the construction of a time variable usable within laws. It also specifies the respective establishment conditions for the validity domain of continuous approximation and for differential form. A time variable may be used only when the establishment conditions along the generation dependencies leading to that use are satisfied. Through this generation, LCTR successively gives the establishment conditions for the identity of time content, before-and-after relations, comparability and incomparability, linear order, and real-valued representation, and separates the establishment of time structure from the choice of time coordinates. This construction gives a constructive definition of physical time in terms of its establishment conditions rather than its verbal meaning.
If a condition of the generation process is not satisfied, the audit identifies the conditions that first fail along the generation dependencies and localizes nonestablishment to the corresponding positions. It then returns the validity domain of the time variable, the set of first invalidation positions, boundary information for the approximation scale, the causes of invalidation, and the structural burden. For continuous approximation and differential forms, it thereby presents, along a single dependence order, the range in which they may be used, where and why they cease to be valid, and the objects to be repaired and regenerated or recomputed. The audit thus supplies continuous approximation and differentiation with a conditional operational warranty that states their conditions of use and causes of invalidation. LCTR changes the status of classical continuous time from a primitive premise of law description to a generated approximate representation with physical establishment conditions and a maximal domain of validity.
The audit covers both formal theoretical conditions and conditions of physical realization. It keeps theoretical and engineering conditions distinct in type while connecting physical carriers, records, communication, finite resolution, and evidence provenance within a single audit dependence, and includes presentation of physical realization and the available range of use among the obligations for establishing a theory. Qualification to describe multiple objects on a common time representation and to use simultaneity judgments, synchronization, and a common time representation is obtained on the domain where each object’s physical carriers, records, information coupling, communication, and multi-object relations are established; remote or global constructions additionally require consistency conditions for transport and gluing.
Primitive-time input is defined here as entering time content into law operations or result derivations while lacking a complete generation path that establishes that content from nontemporal physical inputs. Mathematical consistency, predictive performance, and empirical fit do not supply the generation path missing from primitive-time input. The evidence-effect domain is defined as the range directly supported by successful measurement, prediction, model fit, or computation. A claim that transfers a result to another object, predicate, evidence type, condition of establishment, or application domain exceeds that evidence-effect domain.
Under this criterion, 72 representative sources spanning theories, experiments, metrological standards, and engineering from antiquity to the present were audited. Every source contained primitive-time input and results dependent on it. No source generated from nontemporal physical inputs the entirety of the time content it used. Even sources possessing physical relations corresponding to part of the generation process did not reach generation of all the time content they used; primitive-time input and results dependent on it remained. This unanimity shows that primitive-time input is not confined to a particular period or field but has recurred throughout the history of physics.
Current theoretical descriptions containing primitive-time input do not satisfy physical-time qualification. Modern physics, with its present use of time variables unchanged, is therefore not established. When primitive-time input backgrounds a condition required for use, and independent evidence establishes both actual invalidation of that same condition and downstream dependence reaching a result, the result itself loses qualification for use in the evaluation domain and requires regeneration or recomputation after repair. Existing mathematical, experimental, and engineering results and physical relations, by contrast, are retained within their evidence-effect domains and can be reused safely where time content and its grounds have been generated and their validity domains and invalidation positions audited. For quantities that contain a time dimension or are defined using time, retention of physical relations is separated from qualification for use of time-dependent expressions, and the latter is determined within the post-generation validity domain.
Result-preserving re-grounding, which integrates invalidation of qualification under primitive-time premises, retention of existing results, and their safe reuse, distinguishes removal of external time from generation of physical time as separate obligations. It generates time usable within laws from records, comparisons, differences in object states, and observer-side information coupling. Generation of time order and construction of causal order are separate obligations: establishing causal order does not entail the establishment of a clock scale, time intervals, or law time. This generation order places periods, frequencies, and Hz among post-generation metrological results, identifies the objects on which Lorentz transformations act as generated time representations and spatial displays, and separates local proper time and global law time into distinct stages of establishment. It reformulates the problem of time in quantum gravity as a problem of qualification for the use of law time, specifies the arrow of time as a subsequent orientation condition on generated time representations, and imposes on claims of the creation, emergence, recovery, or nonexistence of time the obligation to prove a generation path or alternative structure and the exclusion of primitive-time dependence from all time content and subsequent results. Along that generation dependence, it places problems conventionally discussed as separate problems of time at distinct invalidation positions. Classical physics, relativity, metrology and engineering, quantum gravity, and cosmology can thereby be compared along the common axes of the burdens required to establish time, validity domains, and invalidation positions.
When formal evidence and statement evidence are collated along these common axes, the time-stretching account in relativity exhibits a two-stage misrecognition. The first stage places time whose physical grounds have not been generated in advance of laws as “time itself,” independent of physical carriers such as clocks, oscillators, signals, and records. The second attributes comparison differences on physical carriers responding to gravity or motion to stretching of that “time itself.” If statements asserting the nonexistence of time and statements attributing properties to time itself are placed within the same explanatory system, the two are incompatible when they target the same time-content type and application domain; when they target different objects or domains, the transition must be stated. A transition to clock-indication differences, clock-rate differences, proper-time differences, coordinate differences, or other relational quantities does not entail a change in an attribute of “time itself” independent of physical carriers. A further chain that transfers the time attribute to living processes and extends the force of experimental results concerning physical carriers to direct demonstration of living processes constitutes a three-stage misrecognition involving biological application. More generally, the same kind of transgression recurs across multiple fields when the success of a limited computation, prediction, model fit, or experiment is transferred to the physical establishment of an entire mathematical expression, the qualification of ungenerated time, application to an unmeasured target, or an ontological claim about time. This paper identifies that pattern as the unbounded inheritance of limited results. The force of a result is restricted to the object, predicate, evidence type, condition of establishment, and application domain that the result directly supports.
Consider those problems treated by modern physics as independent mysteries concerning time whose constitutive conditions depend on ungenerated time. Once generated physical relations are distinguished from the attribution of properties to an ungenerated “time itself,” and time is physically generated, that constitutive condition is removed. Every such mystery consequently loses its grounds as an independent problem and disappears. What remains is to determine the conditions of establishment, validity domain, first invalidation positions, failure classification, repair order, and next evidence to be acquired for generated time representations. To use a time variable in a physical law, its time content and physical grounds must be generated before its use in the law. A time variable in a physical law is not established as a primitive premise.
検証資産
付属の lctr-verification.zip は、第2〜6章の数学的構成について、Lean 4・MathlibとIsabelle/HOLによる形式化、日英本文との対応表、検証結果および再実行手順を収録する。Leanの証明はlean4exportで出力し、nanodaとcon-lecheによって独立に再検査する。
補助検査には、cvc5・Z3によるSMT検査とCarcaraによる証明トレース検査、SymPy・Maximaによる数式処理、Pint・Astropyによる単位・次元検査、MMTによる型検査、およびOpenMathとContent MathMLの間の式構造照合を用いる。
第7・8章と補遺については、同梱した72資料の監査データから、局所到達性、生成の上限、構造署名および件数を再計算する検査器を収録する。
Verification assets
The accompanying lctr-verification.zip provides formalizations of the mathematical constructions in Chapters 2–6 in Lean 4 with Mathlib and in Isabelle/HOL, together with correspondence to the Japanese and English text, verification results, and reproduction instructions. Lean proofs are exported with lean4export and independently rechecked by nanoda and con-leche.
Auxiliary checks use cvc5 and Z3 for SMT solving, Carcara for proof-trace checking, SymPy and Maxima for symbolic computation, Pint and Astropy for unit and dimensional checks, and MMT for type checking. Expression structures are also compared between OpenMath and Content MathML representations.
For Chapters 7 and 8 and the supplement, the archive includes a checker that recomputes local reachability, generation upper bounds, structural signatures, and counts from the accompanying audit dataset for the 72 sources.
ライセンス
著者による日本語・英語の8PDF、説明文および監査データにはCC BY-NC-ND 4.0を適用する。著者が作成した検証プログラム、実行用スクリプトおよび形式化コードにはBSD-3-Clauseを適用する。第三者資料には、それぞれの著作権表示とライセンスが適用される。これらの適用範囲は、検証資産のZIPと展開済みファイルにも共通する。
Licenses
The author's eight Japanese and English PDFs, documentation, and audit data are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. The author's verification programs, execution scripts, and formalization code are licensed under BSD-3-Clause. Third-party materials retain their respective copyright notices and license terms. These scopes also apply to the verification archive and its expanded files.
論文・関連資料 / Paper and related materials
Comment papers by the same author / 同じ著者によるコメント論文
v1.0.1
補遺の番号体系をS系列へ変更し、関連する参照を更新した。併せて、内容に変更を伴わない軽微な修正を行った。
Supplement numbering has been changed to the S series, and the corresponding cross-references have been updated. Minor editorial revisions have also been made without altering the content.
Files
lctr_main_supp_full_jp.pdf
Files
(84.2 MB)
| Name | Size | |
|---|---|---|
|
md5:5354a477189ff7f241bfbd47a8ed4129
|
52.0 MB | Preview Download |
|
md5:98c384156d0e8ed24dbc21f2da80431c
|
399.2 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:1fdfa3564aa4b5009812cb16c5347d81
|
915.5 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:ca849473365dd9e66b9d38757be9a18a
|
3.3 MB | Preview Download |
|
md5:f146cc161a6aad5d6589edb324c26f42
|
4.1 MB | Preview Download |
|
md5:5873dea87a7d2e11dae79020b3418725
|
6.3 MB | Preview Download |
|
md5:fb82b20f1e819fcebdd815a151602f48
|
6.7 MB | Preview Download |
|
md5:9598f8bbd3b9b362db41313f81923a3f
|
4.9 MB | Preview Download |
|
md5:ff7b90ca10abdb3f296ff98dbbee7a61
|
5.4 MB | Preview Download |
Additional details
Additional titles
- Translated title (English)
- Moving the Time Variable from a Premise of Physical Law to a Consequence: A General Theory of the Complete Description of Time Establishment through Local Comparison and Failure Classification
References
- Isaac Newton. Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica . Royal Society, London, 1687.
- Albert Einstein. Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper. Annalen der Physik , 322(10):891–921, 1905.
- Hermann Minkowski. Raum und Zeit. Jahresbericht der Deutschen Mathematiker-Vereinigung, 18:75–88, 1909. Lecture delivered in 1908.
- Albert Einstein. Die Grundlage der allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie. Annalen der Physik, 354(7):769–822, 1916.
- Aristotle. Aristotle's Physics: Books III and IV . Clarendon Aristotle Series. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1983. Translated with introduction and notes by Edward Hussey; new impression with corrections and additions, 1993; Book IV, Chapters 11–14, Bekker 218b21–224a15.
- Richard P. Feynman, Robert B. Leighton, and Matthew Sands. The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume I . Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1963. Chapter 4, Section 4-4; Chapter 5; Chapters 15–17.
- Percy W. Bridgman. The Logic of Modern Physics . Macmillan, New York, 1927.
- Karel V. Kuchař. Time and interpretations of quantum gravity. In Proceedings of the 4th Canadian Conference on General Relativity and Relativistic Astrophysics , pages 211–314, 1992.
- Chris J. Isham. Canonical quantum gravity and the problem of time. In L. A. Ibort and M. A. Rodríguez, editors, Integrable Systems, Quantum Groups, and Quantum Field Theories, pages 157–287. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1993.
- Don N. Page and William K. Wootters. Evolution without evolution: Dynamics described by stationary observables. Physical Review D , 27(12):2885–2892, 1983.
- Carlo Rovelli. Partial observables. Physical Review D , 65(12):124013, 2002.
- Bureau International des Poids et Mesures. The International System of Units (SI Brochure). BIPM, Sèvres, 9 edition, 2019. 9th edition, updated in 2026.
- Edwin F. Taylor and John Archibald Wheeler. Spacetime Physics: Introduction to Special Relativity. W. H. Freeman and Company, New York, 2 edition, 1992.
- Wolfgang Rindler. Essential Relativity: Special, General, and Cosmological . SpringerVerlag, New York, Heidelberg and Berlin, 2 edition, 1977.
- Charles W. Misner, Kip S. Thorne, and John Archibald Wheeler. Gravitation. W. H. Freeman and Company, San Francisco, 1973.
- National Institute of Standards and Technology. Putting einstein to the test. https://www.nist.gov/atomic-clocks/a-powerful-tool-for-science/ putting-einstein-test, April 2025. Created April 3, 2025; updated April 17, 2025; accessed July 29, 2026.
- European Space Agency. Clocks, gravity, and the limits of relativity. https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_ Exploration/Research/Clocks_gravity_and_the_limits_of_relativity, May 2019. Published May 23, 2019; accessed July 29, 2026.
- Markus Pössel. From light clocks to time dilation. Einstein Online, 13:1004, 2021. https://www.einstein-online.info/en/spotlight/ light-clocks-time-dilation/ ; accessed July 29, 2026.
- P. A. M. Dirac. The theory of gravitation in hamiltonian form. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences , 246(1246):333–343, 1958.
- Richard Arnowitt, Stanley Deser, and Charles W. Misner. The dynamics of general relativity. In Louis Witten, editor, Gravitation: An Introduction to Current Research , pages 227–265. Wiley, New York, 1962.
- Bryce S. DeWitt. Quantum theory of gravity. i. the canonical theory. Physical Review, 160(5):1113–1148, 1967.
- James B. Hartle and Stephen W. Hawking. Wave function of the universe. Physical Review D, 28(12):2960–2975, 1983.
- Roger Penrose. Singularities and time-asymmetry. In S. W. Hawking and W. Israel, editors, General Relativity: An Einstein Centenary Survey , pages 581–638. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1979.
- Jacob D. Bekenstein. Black holes and entropy. Physical Review D , 7(8):2333–2346, 1973.
- S. W. Hawking. Particle creation by black holes. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 43:199–220, 1975.
- S. W. Hawking. Breakdown of predictability in gravitational collapse. Physical Review D, 14(10):2460–2473, 1976.
- Don N. Page. Information in black hole radiation. Physical Review Letters , 71(23):3743–3746, 1993.
- John von Neumann. Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik . Springer, Berlin, 1932.
- Wojciech H. Zurek. Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical. Reviews of Modern Physics , 75(3):715–775, 2003.
- Jürgen Ehlers, Felix A. E. Pirani, and Alfred Schild. The geometry of free fall and light propagation. In L. O'Raifeartaigh, editor, General Relativity: Papers in Honour of J. L. Synge , pages 63–84. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1972.
- Luca Bombelli, Joohan Lee, David Meyer, and Rafael D. Sorkin. Space-time as a causal set. Physical Review Letters , 59(5):521–524, 1987.
- Juan M. Maldacena. The large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity. Advances in Theoretical and Mathematical Physics , 2:231–252, 1998.
- Shinsei Ryu and Tadashi Takayanagi. Holographic derivation of entanglement entropy from the anti-de sitter space/conformal field theory correspondence. Physical Review Letters, 96(18):181602, 2006.
- Steven Weinberg. The cosmological constant problem. Reviews of Modern Physics , 61(1):1–23, 1989.
- Adam G. Riess, Alexei V. Filippenko, Peter Challis, Alejandro Clocchiatti, Alan Diercks, Peter M. Garnavich, Ron L. Gilliland, Craig J. Hogan, Saurabh Jha, Robert P. Kirshner, B. Leibundgut, M. M. Phillips, David Reiss, Brian P. Schmidt, Robert A. Schommer, R. Chris Smith, J. Spyromilio, Christopher Stubbs, Nicholas B. Suntzeff, and John Tonry. Observational evidence from supernovae for an accelerating universe and a cosmological constant. The Astronomical Journal , 116(3):1009–1038, 1998.
- S. Perlmutter, G. Aldering, G. Goldhaber, R. A. Knop, P. Nugent, P. G. Castro, S. Deustua, S. Fabbro, A. Goobar, D. E. Groom, I. M. Hook, A. G. Kim, M. Y. Kim, J. C. Lee, N. J. Nunes, R. Pain, C. R. Pennypacker, R. Quimby, C. Lidman, R. S. Ellis, M. Irwin, R. G. McMahon, P. Ruiz-Lapuente, N. Walton, B. Schaefer, B. J. Boyle, A. V. Filippenko, T. Matheson, A. S. Fruchter, N. Panagia, H. J. M. Newberg, W. J. Couch, and The Supernova Cosmology Project. Measurements of Omega and Lambda from 42 high-redshift supernovae. The Astrophysical Journal, 517(2):565–586, 1999.
- J. Bailey, K. Borer, F. Combley, H. Drumm, F. Krienen, F. Lange, E. Picasso, W. von Ruden, F. J. M. Farley, J. H. Field, W. Flegel, and P. M. Hattersley. Measurements of relativistic time dilatation for positive and negative muons in a circular orbit. Nature, 268:301–305, 1977.
- Leon F. Curtiss. Measurements of radioactivity. Circular of the Bureau of Standards 476, National Bureau of Standards, October 1949.
- Robert V. Pound and Jr. Rebka, Glen A. Apparent weight of photons. Physical Review Letters, 4(7):337–341, 1960.
- J. C. Hafele and Richard E. Keating. Around-the-world atomic clocks: Observed relativistic time gains. Science, 177(4044):168–170, 1972.
- J. C. Hafele and Richard E. Keating. Around-the-world atomic clocks: Predicted relativistic time gains. Science, 177(4044):166–168, 1972.
- Joel L. Lebowitz. Boltzmann's entropy and time's arrow. Physics Today, 46(9):32–38, 1993.
- Julian B. Barbour. The timelessness of quantum gravity: I. the evidence from the classical theory. Classical and Quantum Gravity , 11(12):2853–2873, 1994.
- Julian B. Barbour. The timelessness of quantum gravity: Ii. the appearance of dynamics in static configurations. Classical and Quantum Gravity , 11(12):2875–2897, 1994.
- Alain Connes and Carlo Rovelli. Von neumann algebra automorphisms and time-thermodynamics relation in general covariant quantum theories. Classical and Quantum Gravity, 11(12):2899–2918, 1994.
- Clifford Headley, J. B. Clayton, and W. A. Reed. Methods of suppressing stimulated brillouin scattering in optical fibers by manipulation of the fiber properties. In Gordon W. Day, Douglas L. Franzen, and Paul A. Williams, editors, Technical Digest: Symposium on Optical Fiber Measurements, 1996 , number 905 in NIST Special Publication, pages 105–110. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Boulder, CO, October 1996.
- Stephen L. Adler. Why decoherence has not solved the measurement problem: A response to p. w. anderson. Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics , 34:135–142, 2003.
- Philip W. Anderson. Science: A dappled world or a seamless web? Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics , 32(3):487–494, 2001.
- Charles W. Clark. Effects of configuration interaction on intensities and phase shifts. In David R. Lide, editor, A Century of Excellence in Measurements, Standards, and Technology: A Chronicle of Selected NBS/NIST Publications, 1901–2000 , number 958 in NIST Special Publication, pages 116–119. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, January 2001.
- Tamara M. Davis and Charles H. Lineweaver. Expanding confusion: Common misconceptions of cosmological horizons and the superluminal expansion of the universe. Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia , 21:97–109, 2004.
- Maximilian Schlosshauer. Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics. Reviews of Modern Physics , 76:1267–1305, 2005.
- Claus Kiefer. Quantum cosmology and the arrow of time. Brazilian Journal of Physics , 35(2A):296–299, 2005.
- Øyvind Grøn and Øystein Elgarøy. Is space expanding in the friedmann universe models? American Journal of Physics , 75:151–157, 2007.
- Matthew J. Francis, Luke A. Barnes, J. Berian James, and Geraint F. Lewis. Expanding space: The root of all evil? Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia , 24(2):95–102, 2007.
- Richard J. Cook and M. Shane Burns. Interpretation of the cosmological metric. American Journal of Physics , 77:59–66, 2009.
- J. A. Peacock. A diatribe on expanding space, 2008.
- Emory F. Bunn and David W. Hogg. The kinematic origin of the cosmological redshift. American Journal of Physics , 77:688–694, 2009.
- Claus Kiefer. Does time exist in quantum gravity?, 2009.
- Carlo Rovelli. Forget time. Foundations of Physics , 41:1475–1490, 2011.
- Mark Van Raamsdonk. Building up spacetime with quantum entanglement. General Relativity and Gravitation , 42:2323–2329, 2010.
- Brian Greene. NOVA: The fabric of the cosmos: The illusion of time. PBS/NOVA television program, 2011. Hosted by Brian Greene; produced, written, and directed by Randall MacLowry; official transcript.
- Peter Wolf, Luc Blanchet, Christian J. Bordé, Serge Reynaud, Christophe Salomon, and Claude Cohen-Tannoudji. Does an atom interferometer test the gravitational redshift at the compton frequency? Classical and Quantum Gravity , 28(14):145017, 2011.
- Edward Anderson. Problem of time in quantum gravity. Annalen der Physik , 524:757–786, 2012.
- George F. R. Ellis. Space time and the passage of time, 2012.
- David Tong. Dynamics and relativity. University of Cambridge lecture notes, 2013. Chapter 7, Special Relativity.
- Geraint F. Lewis. On the relativity of redshifts: Does space really expand? Australian Physics, 53(3):95–100, 2016.
- Lee Smolin. Temporal relationalism; beyond spacetime, 2018. Temporal Relationalism, arXiv:1805.12468v1 (2018); Beyond Spacetime, Cambridge University Press (2020), pp. 143–175, doi:10.1017/9781108655705.010.
- NASA Space Place and NASA/JPL–Caltech. Is time travel possible? https: //spaceplace.nasa.gov/time-travel/en/, April 2020. Published April 30, 2020.
- D. M. Asner, Christoph Hanhart, and Mikhail Mikhasenko. 50. resonances. Review of Particle Physics, 2023 update, August 2023. Revised August 2023.
- Richard P. Feynman, Fernando B. Morinigo, and William G. Wagner. Feynman Lectures on Gravitation . Addison–Wesley, 1995. Lectures delivered at Caltech during the 1962–63 academic year.
- Jayant V. Narlikar. An Introduction to Relativity . Cambridge University Press, 2010.
- Werner Heisenberg. Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science . Harper & Brothers, New York, 1958.
- National Institute of Standards and Technology. Einstein's general relativity and your age, 2022.
- E. Savalle, C. Guerlin, P. Delva, F. Meynadier, C. le Poncin-Lafitte, and P. Wolf. Gravitational redshift test with the future ACES mission, 2019.
- Consultative Committee for Time and Frequency. Mise en pratique for the definition of the second in the SI. 20 May 2019.