Published October 8, 2026 | Version 1.0.1

Map-Guided Theory Development: A Versioned Protocol for Thought Experiments, Semantic Audits, and Human-AI Research

Authors/Creators

  • 1. Independent researcher, Shenzhen, China

Description

Developing a theory requires more than collecting plausible propositions. Definitions can change between research episodes, separate witnesses can be combined incorrectly, and a successful local proof can cease to address the original question. We present Map-Guided Theory Development (MGTD), a protocol in which a versioned, semantically annotated research map mediates between conjecture generation, thought experiments, conditional deduction, criticism, and preservation. Claims retain their domains, quantifiers, interpretation, source versions, and epistemic status. Conjunctive premises are bound to a common application contract, alternative proof routes remain distinct, and a completed cycle includes a census-wide compatibility review plus deeper rederivation of affected conclusions. Minimal unresolved obligation sets provide a transparent representation of possible next research steps without asserting their truth or feasibility. We state elementary guarantees for the restricted deductive component and give constructive examples of the limits of structural and local checking. A retrospective case contains 1,278 recorded review items; it illustrates artifact design, not independent validation of the underlying consciousness theory. A small executable conformance suite rejects 12 deliberately constructed contract violations, accepts 12 benign controls, and checks frontier calculations on 1,024 finite rule graphs. The contribution is an explicit, reusable synthesis for theory-oriented human–AI research, not the invention of argument graphs, a universal discovery algorithm, or evidence of improved scientific productivity.

Corrected v1.0.1 Zenodo version of DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23241205. Editorial corrections to title-page and publication-status statements only; theory and reproducibility evidence remain unchanged. Substantial ChatGPT assistance under human direction; not independently peer-reviewed. No measured improvement in scientific productivity is claimed.

Notes

MGTD-PAPER-v1.0.1; previous DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23241205; new PDF SHA256 98abef0e92d0bb599146cdf525d98acb7045a168912ec9e87ba7723bc958097c; exact version linked by Zenodo newversion. NOT externally peer reviewed.

Files

MGTD_Method_Paper_v1.0.1.md

Files (1.0 MB)

Name Size
md5:e374cc5dd649639ef4fc52fdcdf13ddc
372 Bytes Download
md5:218e32c1a742e12d5108f211428ce401
51.2 kB Preview Download
md5:f02123ba51ddd4583342c87257f805d1
138.4 kB Preview Download
md5:07e4f9e49022701fdd36d4926fd9df3e
843.6 kB Preview Download
md5:0d8f32f16eef767b450562a234094c56
815 Bytes Preview Download

Additional details

Related works

References
10.5281/zenodo.23206492 (DOI)