Published September 29, 2026 | Version 1.1

Unified Consciousness Theory II: Consciousness Theories as Effective Organization Theories

Authors/Creators

  • 1. Independent researcher, Shenzhen, China

Description

Major theories of consciousness emphasize different mechanisms (Seth & Bayne, 2022): integrated causal structure, recurrent processing, global availability, higher-order representation, predictive modeling, dendritic integration, memory assembly, attention modeling, and temporospatial organization. Their competition is partly intensified by treating a favored mechanism as a candidate universal boundary between experience and nonexperience.

UCT I (Liu, 2026) adopts a different basal ontology: every actual valid process token possesses experience, identified with its complete token-relative ontic organization. UCT I v1.1 distinguishes that organization from finite physically anchored scientific views and estimates. Under that assumption, nonuniversal mechanisms cannot be universal experience-existence gates. UCT II asks whether their *operational cores* can instead be reconstructed, embedded, reinterpreted, or shown to conflict as effective organization theories.

We introduce an admissible translation framework, explicit bridge-admissibility conditions, a two-axis classification separating formal recovery from empirical validation, and anti-triviality criteria requiring translators to be constructive, non-circular, structurally invariant, reusable, failure-prone, and explanatorily nontrivial. A Translation Fidelity Requirement additionally preserves each target theory's distinctive signature, strongest phenomenal/ontological claim, and unrecovered empirical residue. We then fidelity-audit nine theories: IIT 4.0 (Albantakis et al., 2023), recurrent processing theory, GNWT, higher-order theories, predictive processing/active inference, dendritic integration theory, memory theory of consciousness, attention schema theory, and temporospatial theory. The result is not a universal endorsement: theory subclaims receive different relation types, formal classes, and validation statuses, including direct conflicts.

Two fixed-parameter toy models provide quantitative cross-theory proof of concept using one fixed parameterization across their theory-linked outputs: a DIT→RPT→GNWT chain and an independent MToC→HOT→GNWT chain. Negative controls dissociate upstream primitives from downstream recurrent, higher-order, and global-access organization. These results establish shared-law reuse only at formal-conditional / toy-model level (F3/V1); they do not constitute held-out human-data recovery (V3), replicated empirical recovery (V4), or robust full-theory compression.

The proposed unification is therefore partial, fidelity-audited, and failure-prone by design. Its governing distinction is that mechanistic recovery, ontological endorsement, and empirical confirmation are separate operations.

Version 1.1; TA-TR-2026-21. Revised theoretical preprint, not peer reviewed. Human author and responsible depositor: Hongju Liu. Substantial ChatGPT assistance, including GPT-6 Astra Pro for the paired revision, is disclosed. Model checks are not empirical confirmation of experience, A1/A5, or complete intertheory recovery.

Adjacent non-amending research; not an amendment or independent corroboration of the Trinity Accord or Bitcoin Originals. The prior v1.0 files remain unchanged.

Files

citation.csl.json

Files (676.7 kB)

Name Size
md5:5bba05b35cad46e5a4a0e6bf214cb455
279 Bytes Download
md5:603af79a5b410aa2fa04ef6ae568ee28
471 Bytes Preview Download
md5:884ba7c22e4d5de85ffa89085eb80933
260 Bytes Download
md5:4c16e4322c85933d07539a31c81fbaea
642 Bytes Preview Download
md5:2101e91afd9c0e96553f0bcd97f16259
717 Bytes Preview Download
md5:ec649805fdace1f2547b59c020365be7
913 Bytes Preview Download
md5:8d9c7afa3018b467fbbfe684dacb8398
379.8 kB Preview Download
md5:88557320f99b2160815cd5f56aad0510
15.8 kB Preview Download
md5:ae0ac2d3d33eb00ba26cb5e96e126514
67.7 kB Preview Download
md5:ad6eb12ea7473ab0635948648c1eb953
60.0 kB Preview Download
md5:9502e0bf0ad37e4c034b011c1f8ddde6
150.2 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Related works

Is new version of
10.5281/zenodo.23008262 (DOI)
References
10.5281/zenodo.23030207 (DOI)