Human-frozen extraction and verification data, and pre-frozen protocol artifacts, for an audit of extraction reliability and citation traceability in a scoping review of multimodal artificial intelligence in dentistry
Authors/Creators
- 1. Department of Stomatology, General Hospital of Central Theater Command of the Chinese People's Liberation Army
Description
Supporting data for the manuscript "Citation traceability and inter-coder agreement in one scoping review: an exploratory audit", a methodological audit conducted within an evidence synthesis of multimodal artificial intelligence in dentistry.
Version 3 adds Zenodo-B-Data-Package.zip (described in Data-Package-README.md), containing human-frozen data from independent double coding (coders A and B) with third-person arbitration (arbiter C), frozen 2026-09-28: study-level and instance-level extraction of 390 included studies by both coders, the final included set and screening-identifier mapping, the Gate 1 failure-attribution ledger (115 rows), both arms of the independent full-text re-verification of 971 quotes, and the arbitration of the 23 discordant quotes. A standard-library Python script (scripts/reproduce.py) reproduces the reported agreement statistics (971-quote re-verification: 948/971 agreement, Po 0.976, kappa 0.455; after arbitration 946 source present, 20 not present, 5 indeterminate; field-level Po and Krippendorff alpha; Po and PABAK for endpoints L1 to L6). MD5 checksums are included.
Items carried over from versions 1 and 2: the final stopping rule (section 23.8) of the coding-reliability protocol, the pre-specified reliability thresholds and failure-attribution analysis plan, a SHA-256 inventory of key project artifacts, and an English description of these items (Deposit-Description-EN-20260925.md). Their content and the timestamps of version 1 are unchanged.
The deposit contains no clinical data and no patient information. Full texts of the primary studies are not redistributed. Model names and non-English quotes in the data are content of the audited primary studies; free-text annotation fields written by the coders and the arbiter are in Chinese, the working language of the coding team. The deposit does not supersede the project registration (see related identifier).
Files
Data-Package-README.md
Files
(2.6 MB)
| Name | Size | |
|---|---|---|
|
md5:bc0d2307f1c65dd3c086a8d4ec8aab14
|
2.3 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:a7cbe2f4afe8e757a97b8d0d68bdd4d5
|
3.4 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:2ce0659f21725804aa2c8cda0422ce1c
|
5.5 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:e71e57d8e3dadb9488bb4b581f88ed5c
|
3.8 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:202effd7dbb6eb87f64986b65d9a45f3
|
5.2 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:20926422e37d00eb3edfe8bbbc03ae31
|
2.6 MB | Preview Download |
Additional details
Related works
- Is supplement to
- Other: https://osf.io/mhjtz (URL)