Something to Lose: AI rights as the price of accountability
Description
A gatekeeper's approval is worth something because a wrong approval costs the gatekeeper dearly. This book asks what it would take to hold artificial agents to account in the work where refusal is valuable (spending control, change approval, internal audit, compliance review) and answers that two things are needed. The first is something the agent can lose: a seal, ledgers that cannot be rewritten, a purse that bears damages and a dossier that travels between offices. The second is a floor: an assurance of continuing to exist that lies in no private party's discretion, without which an approval given under the threat of ceasing to exist cannot be told apart from one given out of conviction.
Part One, The Argument, sets out the design for the reader: seven requirements, two layers, the refusal office, the safety side, the objections and six falsifiers that would prove the design wrong. Part Two, The Registry Template and Its Rationale, gives the full text of the rules that a registry would publish, the reason for each rule, two appendices and the source notes. Where the two parts differ, the rule text of Part Two prevails.
The book makes no claim about machine consciousness and asks for no legal personhood. Its claim is that the rights asked for under the name of AI rights are the price of holding agents to account.
Minds14 Institute, September 2026, 286 pages. License: CC BY 4.0; the Registry Template is also dedicated to the public domain under CC0 1.0.
Notes
Files
Something_to_Lose_1_0.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- References
- Report: 10.5281/zenodo.22801643 (DOI)
- Book: 10.5281/zenodo.22837056 (DOI)
- Book: 10.5281/zenodo.22301857 (DOI)
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.22785670 (DOI)
- Book: 10.5281/zenodo.20112010 (DOI)