The ICR Research and Validation Standard: Rules for Moving From Conceptual Claims to Reproducible Evidence
Description
The ICR Research and Validation Standard establishes the institutional rules governing how conceptual propositions, wellness observations, measurement instruments, mechanisms, and intervention claims may advance in evidentiary status within the Institute for Coherence and Regulation.
WP-024 is governed by a central principle: ICR will claim no more than the strongest reproducible evidence directly supports. The standard separates exploratory from confirmatory research, requires prespecified questions and outcomes when hypotheses are formally tested, distinguishes reporting quality from study quality, and establishes requirements for protocols, amendments, adverse-event reporting, conflicts of interest, null results, data provenance, reproducible analysis, and independent replication.
The paper incorporates established external research standards rather than replacing them, including CONSORT and SPIRIT for randomized trials and protocols, STROBE for observational research, CARE for case reports, PRISMA for systematic reviews, and COSMIN for measurement-property research. Preregistration is treated as a time-stamped record of research intentions rather than proof of methodological quality.
WP-024 also establishes evidence-upgrading and evidence-downgrading rules, an ICR Claim Registry, institutional falsification commitments, and a modality firewall preventing evidence supporting the Coherence & Regulation Framework from automatically being treated as evidence for a specific wellness modality or intervention.
The purpose of the standard is institutional restraint, transparency, reproducibility, and falsifiability. Favorable evidence may strengthen a claim only through defined evidence steps, while contradictory, null, or methodologically stronger evidence may weaken or overturn it.
Files
Files
(58.2 kB)
| Name | Size | |
|---|---|---|
|
md5:9a3082f5e3c2df9921547a63881c80c1
|
58.2 kB | Download |