Artifacts for: Credit Without Debit: Formal Verification of Banking Payment Systems
Authors/Creators
Description
Banking payment systems, handling trillions of dollars annually, are widely assumed to provide strong security and access-control guarantees because transfers result in permanent movement of funds and are governed by strict operational rules. In this paper, we present a formal model of Automated Clearing House (ACH) payment processing that captures the delayed and asynchronous nature of transfers, the independent control of consumer accounts across different banks, and the temporary states visible to users before settlement completes. Using a property-guided verification framework on a parameterized model, we analyze whether fundamental guarantees such as authorization-before-access hold throughout a payment transfer's lifecycle. Our analysis reveals vulnerabilities in institutional choices, permitted by Nacha rules, treating authorization as a one-time check and by exposing provisional credits before access control and settlement complete. We identify three classes of attack that exploit these vulnerabilities and validate them empirically in two U.S. banks and third-party financial platforms. We disclosed our findings and proposed remedies to all affected institutions. Follow-up testing at those institutions confirms that these attacks are no longer possible.
Files
ach-model-checking-main.zip
Additional details
Dates
- Accepted
-
2026-09-14
Software
- Repository URL
- https://github.com/alirafiqmalik/ach-model-checking
- Programming language
- Python , Shell , Makefile , Dockerfile
- Development Status
- Active