Published August 27, 2026 | Version v1

The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics as an Argument for a Compact Law of the World

Description

The phenomenon noted by Wigner (1960) — the systematic predictive effectiveness of mathematical structures developed without regard to physics — has received no generally accepted explanation. This paper shows that it is explained by the hypothesis of a compact generating law of the world: the effectiveness of mathematics is observable evidence of the algorithmic compressibility of reality, and compressibility is precisely the existence of a short expression of the law. The status of the notion of compressibility employed is specially clarified: it is taken qualitatively — as the existence of a short expression of the law, and not as a particular numerical value of Kolmogorov complexity — which removes two known difficulties (the dependence of complexity on the choice of universal machine up to an additive constant, and the non-computability of the complexity function itself), since the qualitative distinction "there is a compact ground / there is none" is invariant, whereas the exact number is not. It is also noted that, on an atemporal reading of the fundamental level, compressibility should be understood statically: "programme" here is a metaphor for generative dependence, not a process in time. Two circumstances weakening the exclusivity of the argument are honestly acknowledged: radical mathematical Platonism explains Wigner's phenomenon more directly — under the identity of physics and mathematics, predictiveness is tautological — and the argument itself is not exclusive, counting in favour of both hypotheses. What the difference nonetheless consists in is shown: the price of the explanation is fundamentally different — the directness of Platonism is bought by postulating an infinite multitude of unobservable structures, whereas the explanation via compressibility requires only an observably confirmable property of the world. The boundaries are named: what is explained is the presence of a short law, not its particular form; Platonism is not refuted but shown to be superfluous for this explanation.

 

This paper develops a single line of argument from the author's more general work, where the system is set out as a whole: Maslennikov, I. (2026). The Structural Determinant Hypothesis: Existence as Structural Equilibrium. Zenodo. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.20122809. Certain formulations and passages of argument are carried over from that deposited preprint; here they are expanded, made precise, and supplied with an examination of objections absent from the original text.

Files

Paper10_Wigner_EN.pdf

Files (101.5 kB)

Name Size
md5:2c267f502ab7f9ef2b1b73acfe954c77
101.5 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Related works

Is derived from
Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.20122809 (DOI)