Published August 14, 2026 | Version v1.0.0

Energy System Uncertainty Catalog

  • 1. Institute of Renewable energy Technology (Hochschule Nordhausen)
  • 2. ROR icon Nordhausen University of Applied Sciences

Description

Energy System Uncertainty Catalog

A structured catalog of uncertainties for energy-system modelling, covering parametric, structural, and temporal uncertainties across renewable energy, heat, bioenergy, Power-to-X/hydrogen, storage, imports, grid infrastructure, and demand sectors.

The catalog is designed to support uncertainty analysis, sensitivity analysis, scenario development, and model robustness assessment in integrated energy-system models.

Overview

Energy-system models are affected by multiple sources of uncertainty, including uncertain technology costs and potentials, modelling assumptions, system constraints, demand evolution, and weather-dependent time series. However, these uncertainties are often treated inconsistently across studies.

This repository provides a structured and traceable catalog of relevant uncertainty parameters that can be used to systematically identify and characterize uncertainty in energy-system models.

The catalog distinguishes between three main uncertainty classes:

  • Parametric uncertainty — uncertainty in numerical model inputs such as investment costs, technology efficiencies, capacities, potentials, and technical parameters.
  • Structural uncertainty — uncertainty arising from modelling choices, system representation, constraints, optimization assumptions, and technology inclusion/exclusion.
  • Temporal uncertainty — uncertainty associated with weather years, demand profiles, time series, and other time-dependent model inputs.

Catalog Structure

The main catalog is provided as an Excel workbook:

Uncertainty Catalog.xlsx

The workbook contains the following sheets:

Main

Provides an overview of the uncertainty classification and technology categories used throughout the catalog.

Parametric

Contains numerical model parameters and their associated uncertainty ranges.

Each parameter includes information such as:

Field Description
ID Unique uncertainty identifier
Parameter Parameter name
Technology Category Relevant technology or sector
Model Component Specific model component
Sector Electricity, heat, gas, etc.
Unit Parameter unit
Baseline Reference value
Lower Bound Lower uncertainty boundary
Upper Bound Upper uncertainty boundary
Uncertainty Type Epistemic, aleatory, or mixed
Reference Plot Location of supporting reference data
Source / Reference Literature and data sources
Justification Rationale for the selected uncertainty range
Description Interpretation of the parameter
Parameter Name in Model Corresponding model variable

Structural

Contains uncertainties associated with the formulation and structure of the energy-system model.

Examples include:

  • Temporal resolution
  • CO₂ constraints
  • Grid losses
  • Storage operating assumptions
  • Optimization approach
  • Penalty costs
  • Technology inclusion/exclusion
  • Alternative system configurations

Temporal

Contains uncertainties related to time-dependent inputs and scenarios, including:
  • Wind generation profiles
  • Rooftop PV profiles
  • Open-field PV profiles
  • Solar-thermal generation
  • Electricity demand
  • Heat demand
  • Gas demand

The catalog distinguishes between aleatory uncertainty, such as interannual weather variability, and mixed uncertainty, where both variability and modelling assumptions contribute.

Sources

Contains the literature and other sources used to derive or justify the uncertainty ranges.

Reference plot

Contains the reference information used to derive selected numerical uncertainty ranges for technology parameters.

Files

Energy-system-uncertainty-catalog-uncertainty.zip

Files (59.5 MB)

Additional details

References

  • Peter Viebahn, Ole Zelt: Technologien fuer die Energiewende Technologiebericht Band 1, zuletzt geprüft am 30.06.2026.
  • Lopion, Peter Marco (2020): Model-based analysis of cost-efficient CO$_{2}$ reduction strategies. Unter Mitarbeit von Detlef Stolten und Robert Pitz-Paal: RWTH Aachen University.
  • Frenkel, Christoph; Hofmann, Laura; Liebe, Jana; Oderdorfer, Amélie; Reinhardt, Theresa; Schmidt, Christoph et al. (2021): So geht's. Wie Thüringen klimaneutral wird - die Ergebnisse der Energiesystemmodellierung. Nordhausen: Hochschule Institut für Regenerative Energietechnik (in.RET).
  • Brandes, J.; Haun, M.; Wrede, D.; Jürgens, P.; Kost, C.; Henning, H.-M. (2021): Wege zu einem Klimaneutralen Energiesystem. Die deutsche Energiewende im Kontext gesellschaftlicher Verhaltensweisen.
  • Fraunhofer-Institut für System- und Innovationsforschung ISI (2025): Langfristszenarien für die Transformation des Energiesystems in Deutschland. Online verfügbar unter https://langfristszenarien.de/enertile-explorer-wAssets/docs/LFS3_O45-Energieangebot_final.pdf, zuletzt geprüft am 30.06.2026.
  • Detlef Stolten, Peter Markewitz, Thomas Schöb, Felix Kullmann: Neue Ziele auf alten Wegen? Strategien für eine treibhausgasneutrale Energieversorgung bis zum Jahr 2045, zuletzt geprüft am 30.06.2026.
  • Stiftung Klimaneutralität | Agora Energiewende | Agora Verkehrswende: Klimaneutrales Deutschland 2045, zuletzt geprüft am 30.06.2026.
  • Danish Energy Agency & Energinet. (2022). Technology Data for Energy Plants: Electricity and District Heating Generation. Danish Energy Agency.
  • Suna, D. et al. (2022): Sondierung des wesentlichen F&E-Bedarfs zur Optimierung von städtischen Energiespeichern in integrierten Energiesystemen.
  • Erlach, B.; Henning, H.-M.; Kost, C. (2018): Optimierungsmodell REMod-D: Materialien zur Analyse" Sektorkopplung"-Untersuchungen und Überlegungen zur Entwicklung eines integrierten … Online verfügbar unter https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=zpj1njcaaaaj&hl=de&oi=sra.
  • Deutsche Energieagentur (Hg.), "dena-Leitstudie Integrierte Energiewende", Berlin, 2018
  • Elsner, P., Fischedick, M., Sauer, D.U.: "Flexibilitätskonzepte für die Stromversorgung 2050, Technologien – Szenarien – Systemzusammenhänge", Schriftenreihe Energiesysteme der Zukunft, München, 2015.
  • ThEGA, "Neue ThEGA-Analyse: Großes Solarpotenzial entlang Thüringer Autobahnen und Bahnstrecken," ThEGA, Nov. 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.thega.de/aktuelles/detail/neue-thega-analyse-grosses-solarpotenzial-entlang-thueringer-autobahnen-und-bahnstrecken/
  • T. Weber, "Thüringen: Strom aus Wind- und Solarparks mit 23 Gigawatt würde am wenigsten kosten," Erneuerbare Energien, Jan. 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.erneuerbareenergien.de/transformation/netze/thueringen-strom-aus-wind-und-solarparks-mit-23-gigawatt-wuerde-am-wenigsten-kosten
  • Wesselak, Viktor; Reinhardt, Theresa; Schmidt, Christoph; Voswinckel, Sebastian (2025): Einfluss des Windkraftanteils am Energiemix auf die volkswirtschaftlichen Gesamtkosten des Energiesystems – Das Beispiel Thüringen. Online verfügbar unter https://www.hs-nordhausen.de/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2025/12/REGWA25_Paper_PV_Wind.pdf, zuletzt geprüft am 01.07.2026.
  • Thüringer Energienetze (2024): Netzausbauplan 2024. Online verfügbar unter https://www.thueringer-energienetze.com/Content/Documents/Ueber_uns/NAP2024.pdf, zuletzt geprüft am 01.07.2026.
  • Montel Energy Brainpool (2026): Energy BrainReport für Deutschland, Prämissen und Berechnungsergebnisse für das 1. Quartal 2026.
  • 50Hertz Transmission GmbH (2024): Preisblatt 2024. Online verfügbar unter https://www.50hertz.com/xspProxy/api/staticfiles/50hertz-client/dokumente/vertragspartner/netzkunden/netzzugang/231213_finales%20preisblatt%202024_50hertz.pdf, zuletzt geprüft am 01.07.2026.
  • R.Bala Krishnan | H. Hauer-Berghuis | L. Hofmann | A.Lubojanski | S. Neldner | A. Oberdorfer | T.Reinhardt | C. Rothe | C. Schmidt | V. Wesselak (Projektleitung); Szenarien zur Entwicklung des Thüringer Energiebedarfs bis 2045, Oktober 2023