Law of Laws: Context-Relative Closure and Closure Dependenc
Authors/Creators
Description
This preprint asks under what conditions a description induced from a realized parent process is entitled to count as an autonomous descendant law. Rather than proposing a context-free universal generator of laws, it develops a conditional, refusal-preserving architecture organized around three distinct structural roles. C1 requires the full declared semantic object to factor through the retained representation, exactly or under a prospectively fixed approximate contract. C2 requires coherent transport of the complete admission contract across equivalent presentations. C3 requires a globally composable fine realization under the declared resource and interface contract. The resulting Layer-II structural core is P+R, with P=C1+C2 and R=C3_{\mathrm{global}}. Proper descent remains a separate nontriviality firewall, while refinement-minimal admitted branches are reported through the context-relative Closure Dependence Profile (CDP). REFUSE is retained when a frozen contract has no admissible proper candidate.
The architecture is stress-tested using exact counterexamples, prospective positive and refusal tests, construction-time representation dynamics, primitive-frontier and selector tests, coupling-derived access and task contexts, and a transfer from finite partitions to linear-Gaussian observable subspaces. Exact frontier witnesses rule out a universal parent-only single-valued selector that is context-relative minimal across incompatible contexts. Coupling constructions show that access and task roles can be relatively endogenized as proper quotients of a larger realized process, while leaving the larger coupling and evaluator structure as an explicit boundary of the theory. In the linear-Gaussian branch, observable subspaces reproduce trivial, proper, and full-state refusal regimes; withheld semantic tasks select incomparable proper subspaces; and presentation covariance is preserved under invertible state transformations. A symbolic leakage calculation shows that exact rank-two closure is destroyed by any nonzero cross-sector leakage in the tested family, while a prospectively frozen approximate-C1 contract retains a nonzero admission basin.
Predictive sufficiency, lumpability, observability, causal abstraction, simulation/refinement, and local-to-global consistency are treated as imported mathematics. The contribution tested here is their role-separated synthesis into a context-typed, presentation-covariant, realization-aware architecture for law entitlement, together with explicit logical-independence audits, prospective refusal discipline, and cross-representation stress tests. The result is presented as a candidate necessary-condition architecture, not as a universal sufficiency theorem or a universal law that generates laws.