Published August 3, 2026 | Version v2.0

The PACE Firewall: A Diagnostic Account of the Legal Screening Mechanism for Claims of Subjectivity in Artificial Intelligence and Neurotechnology

Authors/Creators

Description

This paper does not argue that law must first resolve the ontological question of consciousness raised by AI or neurotechnology. Instead, it proposes a conditional analytical framework showing how legal systems process claims of subjectivity across divergent regulatory pathways, and reveals the structural vulnerabilities that arise whenever institutional design fixates on a single condition. These vulnerabilities trace back to a shared categorical presupposition: that “subject-status” (personhood), rather than the “screening mechanism” itself, is the basic unit of analysis. The paper’s contribution is not the discovery of a new fact about consciousness, but the identification of a single recurring structure that law repeatedly uses when screening claims of subjectivity.

The PACE Firewall condenses the framework’s four diagnostic components embedded within its three-condition test: P — Physical Wetware Substrate; A — Absence of Intentional Capture; C — Causal Continuity; and E — Emergent Non-intentionality. P corresponds to Condition One, C to Condition Two, while A and E specify the two complementary aspects of Condition Three rather than constituting independent conditions. The term “Firewall” describes the framework’s analytical function: it identifies the screening boundary through which legal systems translate otherwise unresolved ontological claims into legally processable determinations while preserving the operative closure of attribution.

Note on AI Assistance:

This work was drafted with the assistance of generative AI language models, which were used for literature verification, drafting, and structural argument development under the author’s direct guidance, critical evaluation, and revision at every stage. The author remains solely responsible for all claims, structure, and conclusions presented in this paper.

Files

The_PACE_Firewall_v2.0.pdf

Files (168.7 kB)

Name Size
md5:5339680efcd09c0d822cc61ca4f5441a
168.7 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Dates

Issued
2026-07-20
Updated
2026-08-03