BUT-H v2.0 — Before Mathematization: The Right to Call Them One. A Human-Domains Instance of the Before Unity Theory Framework: Auditing Acts of Classification over Persons
Authors/Creators
Description
BUT-H is the human-domains instance of the Before Unity Theory (BUT) framework, addressed to the question of when a multiplicity of persons — registered through a declared feature space — becomes eligible to be treated as a classified unit: a class, a segment, a risk tier. The population-level formal core is inherited from BUT-S v2.0 by explicit reduction (classification cuts as partition-induced lumpings); the instance-specific contributions are the declared boundary of the mathematization act (the measurement map is not formalized, by design), an individual-exposure and cut-perturbation apparatus (flip margin, registry margin, exposure curve) with no counterpart in the parent framework, a three-level residue taxonomy including the non-formalizable extra-Σ residue as a mandatory declaration, the human-domain frame F_H (purpose, authority, contestability, temporal validity, looping exclusion), a two-branch Genesis-H eligibility predicate, and the BUT Passport — a componentwise audit artifact with named failure modes (orphan threshold, exact-by-default, hidden cut, silent completeness claim) and a diagnostic-determinism property with declared scope. The framework certifies auditability and eligibility, never legitimacy and never sincerity; its limits — documentation burden, sealed evidence, passport-washing — are stated within. An appendix audits a real executed threshold, historical and residual (the 620 conventional-mortgage minimum, retired from automated underwriting effective November 16, 2025), with a sensitivity table under declared interpolation assumptions, and audits the successor regime as a cut of undeclared location, with a boundability subclassification. Positioned against the quantification-critique literature (Porter, Hacking, O'Neil, Desrosières), the fairness-impossibility results (Kleinberg et al., Chouldechova), and the audit-adjacent families (model cards, datasheets, recourse, selective classification, conformal prediction). The paper proves no new mathematics and declares it; the contribution is the audit obligation.
Keywords:
Before Unity Theory; BUT-H; BUT Passport; classification audit; mathematization; quantification; thresholds; stability margin; auditability; algorithmic accountability; measurement; residue; frame declaration; credit scoring; hidden cut; Genesis predicate; ZLT
Files
BUT H 2.0.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- Is derived from
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.20477000 (DOI)
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.20644608 (DOI)
- References
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.20476934 (DOI)