Published July 23, 2026 | Version v1

Trail Stop 6: Distinguishing Major and Minor Comments

Authors/Creators

  • 1. ROR icon University of Tennessee Health Science Center

Description

This articles outlines the essential skills for becoming an effective peer reviewer. It emphasizes the distinction between major and minor comments, advocating for organized, constructive feedback that prioritizes significant issues affecting a manuscript's quality. By focusing on the severity and revisability of concerns, reviewers can facilitate meaningful revisions and improve publication readiness.

Files

Trail Stop 6_ Distinguishing Major and Minor Comments – Writer's Camp.pdf

Files (621.9 kB)