De la Inteligencia Artificial al Transhumanismo en el Ámbito de la Defensa
Authors/Creators
- 1. Centro Universitario de la Defensa - Academia General Militar
Description
LEGAL REVIEW
Laina Gallego, José María. “De la Inteligencia Artificial al Transhumanismo en el Ámbito de la Defensa.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 9, June 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.
Review
Artificial intelligence and transhumanism have become two of the most influential concepts shaping contemporary debates on defence innovation, military ethics and emerging technologies. While artificial intelligence is already transforming operational planning, autonomous systems and decision-support capabilities, transhumanism introduces far more profound questions concerning the modification of the human condition itself. In this thought-provoking article, José María Laina Gallego explores the intellectual relationship between both phenomena, arguing that technological innovation in defence cannot be understood solely as a matter of operational effectiveness but must also be examined through the lenses of ethics, human dignity and legal regulation. By integrating philosophy, technology, defence studies and legal reflection, the article offers an original contribution to one of the most rapidly evolving areas of security policy.
The article begins by distinguishing artificial intelligence from broader technological progress. While technological innovation has accompanied human development throughout history, the author argues that artificial intelligence represents a qualitative transformation because of its capacity to learn, adapt and increasingly perform functions traditionally associated with human cognition. Nevertheless, the study carefully rejects the assumption that artificial intelligence reproduces genuine human intelligence. Instead, AI is presented as a distinct form of computational intelligence whose remarkable capabilities should not obscure its fundamental limitations, particularly regarding consciousness, common sense and moral judgement. This distinction provides the conceptual foundation upon which the remainder of the analysis is constructed.
One of the article's principal strengths lies in its examination of transhumanism as an extension of humanity's longstanding aspiration to overcome biological limitations. Rather than portraying transhumanism as a purely futuristic movement, Laina Gallego situates it within broader historical aspirations for self-improvement, longevity and enhanced physical and intellectual performance. The article recognises that advances in biotechnology, regenerative medicine, neurotechnology and artificial intelligence increasingly make some of these ambitions technically conceivable. However, it simultaneously questions whether every technological possibility necessarily constitutes genuine human progress, thereby introducing an ethical perspective that remains central throughout the study.
Particularly valuable is the discussion concerning the concept of human enhancement. The author distinguishes therapeutic interventions intended to restore normal human functions from enhancement technologies designed to surpass ordinary biological capacities. Examples such as genetic modification, cybernetic implants, neural interfaces and advanced prosthetic systems illustrate the increasingly blurred boundary between medical treatment and technological augmentation. Rather than adopting either an enthusiastic or alarmist position, the article encourages critical reflection regarding the ethical legitimacy of transforming human nature itself.
The implications for defence constitute the most original section of the study. Laina Gallego argues that military organisations may become among the principal beneficiaries of transhumanist technologies through the development of what might be described as "enhanced soldiers." Brain-computer interfaces, powered exoskeletons, accelerated tissue regeneration, sensory enhancement and cognitive augmentation are presented as technologies capable of significantly improving military performance. At the same time, the author correctly observes that these innovations inevitably generate profound legal and ethical questions concerning autonomy, responsibility, proportionality and the preservation of human dignity within armed forces. This balanced assessment distinguishes the article from more technologically deterministic approaches frequently encountered in discussions of military innovation.
The article further strengthens its analysis by introducing comparative perspectives drawn from Japan and the European Union. Japan is presented as one of the world's leading technological powers, particularly in robotics and artificial intelligence, while simultaneously illustrating the growing social and institutional interest surrounding transhumanism. Although Japanese technological development has not yet produced a fully articulated legal framework governing human enhancement, the country's leadership in robotics and assistive technologies provides an important reference point for future regulatory debates.
The discussion of the European Union is equally significant. Laina Gallego reviews the evolution of European policy documents concerning artificial intelligence, including the 2020 White Paper on Artificial Intelligence and the ethical guidelines adopted by the High-Level Expert Group on AI. Particular attention is devoted to the seven well-established requirements for trustworthy artificial intelligence, including human oversight, technical robustness, privacy, transparency, fairness, societal well-being and accountability. By examining these normative developments, the article demonstrates that Europe increasingly seeks to position itself as a global leader in human-centred artificial intelligence grounded in democratic values and fundamental rights.
One of the study's greatest contributions lies in its sustained emphasis on the role of law. Rather than viewing legal regulation as an obstacle to technological innovation, the author argues that law should actively shape the future development of artificial intelligence and transhumanist technologies before irreversible transformations occur. This preventive approach reflects an understanding that legal systems should not merely react to technological change but anticipate its consequences by establishing normative principles capable of protecting fundamental rights, human dignity and democratic accountability. Such an argument becomes particularly persuasive when applied to military technologies whose operational deployment may significantly affect both combatants and civilians.
The article also addresses one of the central philosophical dilemmas surrounding transhumanism: the meaning of improvement itself. Technological enhancement does not automatically equate to genuine human flourishing. According to the author, many proposed enhancements require careful ethical evaluation because they may fundamentally alter personal identity, social equality and even the definition of humanity itself. This philosophical reflection considerably enriches the legal discussion by demonstrating that regulation cannot be based exclusively upon technical feasibility or military utility.
Methodologically, the article combines philosophical analysis, legal reflection, comparative policy studies and defence technology within a coherent interdisciplinary framework. References to European Union policy documents, Japanese technological initiatives, bioethical scholarship and contemporary debates surrounding artificial intelligence provide a broad intellectual foundation while maintaining a clear focus upon defence applications. The interdisciplinary character of the study represents one of its principal academic strengths.
The accompanying visual material substantially reinforces the central argument. Images depicting electroencephalographic interfaces, brain-controlled prosthetic limbs, the Japanese Hybrid Assistive Limb (HAL) exoskeleton and military Human Universal Load Carrier (HULC) systems effectively illustrate the progressive convergence between artificial intelligence, robotics, neurotechnology and human enhancement. Rather than serving merely illustrative purposes, these examples demonstrate that many technologies commonly associated with speculative transhumanism are already emerging within contemporary medical and defence research.
From a broader strategic perspective, the article successfully demonstrates that future military superiority may depend not only upon increasingly autonomous systems but also upon the relationship between technological innovation and the human operator. Artificial intelligence and transhumanism therefore should not be analysed independently. Instead, both constitute interconnected dimensions of a broader transformation affecting defence policy, operational capability, military ethics and international regulation.
Overall, this article provides a timely and intellectually balanced examination of one of the most important emerging debates in contemporary defence studies. By combining technological analysis with ethical reflection and legal reasoning, José María Laina Gallego offers a comprehensive assessment of the opportunities and risks associated with artificial intelligence and transhumanism in the military domain. The study represents a valuable contribution for scholars of defence policy, military ethics, artificial intelligence governance, bioethics and international security seeking to understand the legal and philosophical implications of human enhancement in future armed forces.
Abstract
This review examines José María Laina Gallego's analysis of the relationship between artificial intelligence and transhumanism within the field of defence. The article explores how advances in artificial intelligence, neurotechnology, robotics and biotechnology are progressively converging towards forms of human enhancement with potential military applications. It analyses the ethical implications of enhanced soldiers, examines regulatory approaches adopted by the European Union and Japan, and argues that legal systems should anticipate rather than merely respond to technological transformation. By integrating philosophy, defence studies, bioethics and legal analysis, the study provides an important contribution to contemporary debates concerning human dignity, military innovation and the governance of emerging technologies.